UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-I202015 Marks
Q14.

Describe three main controlling factors of soil formation. How does the modern soil differ from the palaeosoil?

How to Approach

This question requires a two-pronged answer. First, detail the three main factors controlling soil formation – climate, organisms, relief/topography, parent material, and time. Second, delineate the differences between modern soils and palaeosoils, focusing on characteristics like degree of weathering, organic matter content, and the presence of diagnostic horizons. A comparative approach, potentially using a table, will be beneficial. The answer should demonstrate an understanding of pedology and geomorphology.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Soil, the unconsolidated mineral and organic material on the immediate surface of the Earth, is a crucial resource supporting life. Its formation is a complex process influenced by a multitude of interacting factors. Understanding these factors is vital for sustainable land management and agricultural practices. While modern soils are the product of ongoing processes, palaeosoils – ancient soils preserved within sedimentary records – offer a glimpse into past environmental conditions. This answer will describe the three main controlling factors of soil formation and highlight the key distinctions between modern and palaeosoils.

Three Main Controlling Factors of Soil Formation

Soil formation, or pedogenesis, is governed by five primary factors, often remembered by the acronym CLORPT. However, focusing on three key factors provides a comprehensive understanding:

1. Climate

Climate is arguably the most influential factor. Temperature and precipitation dictate the rate of chemical weathering, the intensity of biological activity, and the type of vegetation that develops.

  • Temperature: Higher temperatures generally accelerate weathering and decomposition rates.
  • Precipitation: Rainfall influences leaching (removal of soluble materials) and the downward movement of soil constituents. Arid climates lead to accumulation of salts, while humid climates promote intense weathering and podzolization.
  • Example: Tropical rainforests exhibit highly weathered soils (Oxisols) due to high temperatures and rainfall, while temperate grasslands develop Mollisols with thick, dark topsoil.

2. Organisms (Biota)

Living organisms, including plants, animals, bacteria, and fungi, play a critical role in soil formation.

  • Vegetation: Plant roots physically break down rocks, add organic matter (humus) through decomposition, and influence soil structure.
  • Microorganisms: Bacteria and fungi decompose organic matter, releasing nutrients and contributing to humus formation.
  • Animals: Earthworms, termites, and other animals mix soil, improve aeration, and create channels for water infiltration.
  • Example: Lichens contribute to the initial breakdown of rock surfaces, initiating soil formation.

3. Relief (Topography)

The slope and aspect of the land significantly influence soil development.

  • Slope: Steeper slopes experience greater erosion, resulting in thinner soils. Gentle slopes allow for greater soil accumulation.
  • Aspect: The direction a slope faces affects its exposure to sunlight and moisture, influencing temperature and vegetation. South-facing slopes in the Northern Hemisphere are generally warmer and drier than north-facing slopes.
  • Drainage: Topography controls drainage patterns, influencing soil moisture content and the distribution of nutrients.
  • Example: Soils on mountain ridges are typically thin and rocky due to erosion, while soils in valleys are deeper and more fertile.

Modern Soil vs. Palaeosoil

Modern soils are actively forming under present-day environmental conditions, while palaeosoils represent ancient soil horizons preserved in the geological record. Significant differences exist between the two:

Feature Modern Soil Palaeosoil
Degree of Weathering Variable, depending on climate and time. Can range from slightly weathered to highly weathered. Generally more intensely weathered than modern soils in similar climates, reflecting longer exposure to weathering processes.
Organic Matter Content Typically contains significant amounts of organic matter, especially in the topsoil. Often depleted in organic matter due to diagenesis (physical and chemical changes during sediment burial).
Soil Horizons Well-developed soil horizons (O, A, E, B, C, R) are common. Horizons may be poorly developed or truncated due to erosion or burial. Diagnostic horizons may be altered or absent.
Biological Activity High levels of biological activity (roots, microorganisms, animals). Limited or no biological activity. Fossilized root traces or burrows may be present.
Mineral Composition Reflects the parent material and weathering processes occurring today. May contain minerals indicative of past environmental conditions (e.g., specific clay minerals formed under different climates).

Palaeosoils are valuable archives of past climates and environments. Their study provides insights into long-term landscape evolution and the impact of past climate change. For example, the presence of a buried A horizon with paleosols can indicate a period of landscape stability followed by erosion and burial.

Conclusion

In conclusion, soil formation is a complex interplay of climate, organisms, and relief, alongside parent material and time. These factors dictate the characteristics of modern soils, which are dynamic and responsive to current environmental conditions. Palaeosoils, in contrast, offer a preserved record of past soil-forming processes, providing crucial information for understanding Earth’s history and predicting future environmental changes. Studying both modern and palaeosoils is essential for effective land management and a comprehensive understanding of our planet.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Pedogenesis
The process of soil formation, involving the physical, chemical, and biological weathering of rocks and the accumulation of organic matter.
Diagenesis
All the physical, chemical, and biological changes that occur to sediments after their initial deposition.

Key Statistics

Approximately 95% of food production relies directly or indirectly on soil (FAO, 2015 - knowledge cutoff).

Source: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO)

Globally, approximately 33% of soils are degraded (UNCCD, 2017 - knowledge cutoff).

Source: United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD)

Examples

Chernozems of the Great Plains

The dark, fertile Chernozems of the Great Plains in North America are a prime example of soils developed under grassland vegetation and a temperate climate, characterized by thick A horizons rich in humus.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does human activity impact soil formation?

Human activities like deforestation, agriculture, and urbanization significantly alter soil formation processes. Deforestation increases erosion, agriculture depletes organic matter, and urbanization seals the soil surface, hindering natural processes.