UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II202010 Marks
Q1.

How do you measure refractive index of minerals and distinguish high and low relief minerals under microscope?

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of optical mineralogy. The approach should involve first defining refractive index and its significance in mineral identification. Then, explain the methods used to measure it, focusing on techniques applicable under a microscope. Finally, differentiate between high and low relief minerals, linking it to refractive index and the refractive index of the mounting medium. A clear explanation of how these properties aid in mineral identification is crucial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Refractive index (RI) is a fundamental optical property of minerals, representing the ratio of the speed of light in a vacuum to its speed in the mineral. It’s a crucial parameter for mineral identification, as each mineral possesses a characteristic RI range. Under a polarized light microscope, the refractive index manifests as ‘relief’ – the degree to which a mineral stands out in contrast to its surrounding mounting medium. Understanding how to measure RI and interpret relief is therefore essential for petrographic analysis and geological interpretation. This answer will detail the methods for measuring RI and distinguishing between high and low relief minerals.

Measuring Refractive Index of Minerals

Several methods are employed to determine the refractive index of minerals. Under a microscope, the following techniques are commonly used:

  • Beckeline Method: This is a classical method. A mineral grain is mounted on a slide with a liquid of known refractive index. The grain is rotated, and the first and fourth order interference colors are observed. By comparing these colors with a Michel-Levy chart, the refractive index can be determined.
  • Oil Immersion Method: A drop of immersion oil with a known refractive index is placed on the slide. The mineral grain is immersed in the oil, and the interference colors are observed. If the mineral ‘disappears’ (no relief), the RI of the mineral is equal to the RI of the oil. This method is used to quickly estimate the RI.
  • Refractometer: While not strictly a microscopic technique, refractometers provide precise RI measurements. A thin section can be prepared and the RI measured directly.

Understanding Relief

Relief refers to the apparent contrast in brightness between a mineral grain and the surrounding mounting medium (typically Canada Balsam, with an RI of approximately 1.544). This contrast is directly related to the difference in refractive indices between the mineral and the mounting medium.

Distinguishing High and Low Relief Minerals

The distinction between high and low relief minerals is based on the magnitude of the difference in their refractive indices compared to the mounting medium.

  • High Relief Minerals: These minerals exhibit a significant difference in refractive index compared to the mounting medium (typically >0.05). They appear bright and sharply defined against the surrounding medium. Examples include:
    • Apatite (RI ~ 1.63-1.65)
    • Zircon (RI ~ 1.92-1.98)
    • Magnetite (RI ~ 2.35-2.55)
  • Low Relief Minerals: These minerals have a refractive index very close to that of the mounting medium (typically <0.01). They appear less distinct and blend into the surrounding medium. Examples include:
    • Quartz (RI ~ 1.54-1.55)
    • Feldspars (RI ~ 1.52-1.56)
    • Mica (RI ~ 1.56-1.60)

Factors Affecting Relief

Besides the refractive index difference, other factors can influence the observed relief:

  • Angle of Incidence: Relief is maximized when the light ray is perpendicular to the mineral grain.
  • Mineral Composition: Variations in chemical composition within a mineral species can affect its refractive index.
  • Grain Orientation: The orientation of the mineral grain relative to the polarized light can influence the observed relief.

Table Summarizing Relief and Refractive Index

Mineral Type Refractive Index (Approximate) Relief Appearance under Microscope
Quartz 1.54-1.55 Low Subtle, blends with mounting medium
Apatite 1.63-1.65 High Bright, sharply defined
Zircon 1.92-1.98 Very High Extremely bright, high contrast
Feldspar 1.52-1.56 Low to Moderate Slightly visible, moderate contrast

Conclusion

In conclusion, measuring the refractive index of minerals and interpreting relief are vital skills in optical mineralogy. The Beckeline and oil immersion methods, coupled with careful observation of interference colors, allow for accurate RI determination. Distinguishing between high and low relief minerals, based on the difference in RI compared to the mounting medium, is a fundamental step in mineral identification under a polarized light microscope. These techniques, when combined with other optical properties, provide a powerful toolkit for geological analysis and understanding the composition of rocks and minerals.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Birefringence
Birefringence is the difference between the maximum and minimum refractive indices in a mineral. It is a key property used in mineral identification under polarized light.
Isotropic Minerals
Isotropic minerals have the same refractive index in all directions and do not exhibit birefringence. Examples include garnet and halite.

Key Statistics

Canada Balsam, a common mounting medium, has a refractive index of approximately 1.544 at 20°C.

Source: Deer, W. A., Howie, R. A., & Zussman, J. (1992). An introduction to the rock-forming minerals. Longman Scientific & Technical.

The refractive index of diamond is exceptionally high, ranging from 2.417 to 2.419, contributing to its brilliance and high relief when observed in contact with other minerals.

Source: GIA (Gemological Institute of America) data (as of 2023)

Examples

Identifying Olivine

Olivine, with a high refractive index (1.65-1.70), exhibits very high relief in typical rock sections. This allows for easy identification even in fine-grained rocks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if the refractive index of the mineral is exactly the same as the mounting medium?

If the refractive indices are identical, the mineral will appear to "disappear" under crossed polars, exhibiting zero relief. This is a useful technique for quickly estimating the RI.