UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II202010 Marks150 Words
Q1.

Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each : (a) “Maharaja Ranjit Singh died in 1839. His death was the signal for an outburst of anarchy all over the Punjab.”

How to Approach

This question requires a critical assessment of the impact of Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s death on the Punjab. The answer should move beyond a simple narrative of anarchy and delve into the underlying factors that contributed to the instability. Focus on the succession crisis, the role of the Khalsa army, the British East India Company’s machinations, and the internal weaknesses within the Sikh empire. A balanced approach acknowledging both the immediate chaos and the long-term causes is crucial. Structure the answer chronologically, starting with the immediate aftermath of his death and then analyzing the contributing factors.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the founder of the Sikh Empire, died in June 1839, leaving behind a powerful but fragile state. His reign, marked by military prowess and administrative acumen, had successfully consolidated Sikh power in the Punjab region. However, the empire was built on a complex foundation of personal loyalty to the Maharaja and a powerful, yet potentially unruly, Khalsa army. The assertion that his death unleashed “an outburst of anarchy” holds considerable truth, but a nuanced examination reveals that the ensuing chaos was not merely a spontaneous reaction but a culmination of pre-existing vulnerabilities exacerbated by a flawed succession process and external pressures.

The Immediate Aftermath: A Succession Crisis

Ranjit Singh’s death triggered an immediate power vacuum. He had not clearly designated a successor, leading to a fierce struggle for control among his sons and the powerful Dogra brothers (Gulab Singh, Dhian Singh, and Suchet Singh). Kharak Singh, the eldest surviving son, was initially installed as Maharaja, but he was quickly sidelined by Dhian Singh, who effectively became the regent. This manipulation fueled resentment and instability.

The Role of the Khalsa Army

The Khalsa army, the backbone of the Sikh Empire, played a pivotal role in the ensuing chaos. Ranjit Singh had maintained control through a delicate balance of power and patronage. However, his successors lacked his charisma and authority. The army, accustomed to a strong leader and regular rewards, became increasingly assertive and prone to mutiny. The Panchayats (army councils) gained significant influence, challenging the authority of the court.

Internal Weaknesses of the Sikh Empire

Several internal weaknesses contributed to the empire’s rapid decline:

  • Lack of a Clear Succession System: The absence of a codified law of succession led to constant power struggles.
  • Court Intrigues: The Sikh court was rife with conspiracies and rivalries, particularly between the Sandhawalia and Dogra families.
  • Financial Strain: Ranjit Singh’s lavish spending and military campaigns had strained the empire’s finances.
  • Regional Discontent: Some regions within the empire, such as Multan and Kashmir, harbored resentment towards Sikh rule.

The British East India Company’s Role

The British East India Company actively exploited the instability in the Punjab. They maintained a presence on the frontier and carefully monitored the situation. The Company saw the disintegration of the Sikh Empire as an opportunity to expand its influence. They provided covert support to various factions within the Sikh court, further exacerbating the internal conflicts. The First Anglo-Sikh War (1845-46) was a direct consequence of the chaos following Ranjit Singh’s death and the Company’s expansionist policies.

Chronology of Anarchy (1839-1849)

Year Event
1839 Death of Ranjit Singh; Kharak Singh becomes Maharaja, then sidelined by Dhian Singh.
1840 Kharak Singh is poisoned; Nau Nihal Singh becomes Maharaja but dies within months.
1841 The Khalsa army asserts its dominance; Dhian Singh assassinated.
1845-46 First Anglo-Sikh War; Sikh defeat and Treaty of Lahore.
1849 Annexation of the Punjab by the British East India Company.

The period between 1839 and 1849 witnessed a rapid descent into anarchy, characterized by assassinations, power struggles, and ultimately, the loss of Sikh independence. The initial outburst of chaos was indeed significant, but it was the culmination of deeper structural weaknesses and external interference that sealed the fate of the empire.

Conclusion

The statement that Ranjit Singh’s death signaled an outburst of anarchy in the Punjab is largely accurate. While the immediate aftermath was marked by chaos and instability, this was not simply a spontaneous event. It was the result of a flawed succession process, internal weaknesses within the Sikh Empire, the assertive role of the Khalsa army, and the opportunistic intervention of the British East India Company. The subsequent annexation of the Punjab in 1849 demonstrates the devastating consequences of this period of turmoil, marking the end of an era and the beginning of British rule in the region.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Khalsa
The Khalsa was a collective body of Sikhs formed in 1699 by Guru Gobind Singh, representing a community that pledged to uphold religious principles and military prowess.
Regent
A regent is a person appointed to rule a kingdom, empire, or territory because the monarch is a minor, absent, or incapacitated.

Key Statistics

The Sikh Empire under Ranjit Singh reached its peak in the 1830s, controlling a territory of approximately 120,000 square miles.

Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica (Knowledge Cutoff: 2023)

The indemnity imposed on the Sikhs by the Treaty of Lahore was 1.5 million pounds sterling, a crippling financial burden.

Source: Khushwant Singh, A History of the Sikhs, Vol. 2 (Knowledge Cutoff: 2023)

Examples

The Dogra Brothers

Gulab Singh, Dhian Singh, and Suchet Singh, the Dogra brothers, played a crucial role in the power struggles following Ranjit Singh’s death, manipulating events to advance their own interests and ultimately contributing to the empire’s downfall.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Khalsa army become so powerful after Ranjit Singh’s death?

Ranjit Singh had carefully balanced the power of the Khalsa army through patronage and strong leadership. His successors lacked these qualities, allowing the army to assert its dominance and interfere in political affairs.

Topics Covered

HistoryModern IndiaSikh EmpirePunjab History19th Century India