UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II202020 Marks
Q7.

Revolt of 1857: Causes & Context

For long, the Revolt of 1857, has been mistaken to be a mere mutiny of the Indian sepoys in the Bengal army. However, its causes need to be searched for not only in the dissatisfaction of the army, but in a long drawn process of fundamental social and economic change that upset the peasant communities. Discuss.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the Revolt of 1857. The approach should be to first acknowledge the initial perception of the revolt as a mere sepoy mutiny, then systematically dismantle this view by highlighting the long-term socio-economic factors that created widespread discontent. The answer should cover the impact of British policies on various sections of society – peasants, artisans, landlords, and religious groups – demonstrating how these policies contributed to the uprising. A chronological structure, focusing on the build-up to 1857, is recommended.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Revolt of 1857, often initially portrayed as a simple mutiny sparked by greased cartridges, was in reality a watershed moment in Indian history. While the immediate trigger involved the grievances of sepoys, attributing the uprising solely to military discontent presents a drastically incomplete picture. The revolt was, in fact, the culmination of a protracted period of socio-economic and political transformation imposed by British rule, which fundamentally altered the lives of diverse communities across India. This transformation, marked by land revenue systems, economic exploitation, and socio-religious interference, created a fertile ground for widespread resentment and ultimately, rebellion.

The Socio-Economic Landscape Under British Rule

British policies, implemented over decades, systematically dismantled the existing Indian economic and social fabric. This created widespread discontent among various sections of society, laying the groundwork for the 1857 revolt.

Impact on the Peasantry

  • Land Revenue Systems: The introduction of systems like the Permanent Settlement (1793), Ryotwari, and Mahalwari led to increased land revenue demands, often exceeding the peasants’ capacity to pay. This resulted in widespread land alienation, indebtedness, and eviction.
  • Commercialization of Agriculture: The British encouraged the cultivation of cash crops like indigo and opium, often at the expense of food crops. This led to famines and food insecurity, as evidenced by the Bengal famine of 1770 and subsequent famines in the 19th century.
  • Decline of Village Industries: British manufactured goods flooded the Indian market, decimating local handicrafts and industries. This resulted in unemployment and economic hardship for artisans.

Impact on the Zamindars and Landlords

While some zamindars benefited from the Permanent Settlement, many others suffered due to the rigid revenue demands and the loss of traditional rights. The introduction of new land revenue systems often led to their dispossession and resentment towards the British.

Impact on Artisans and Craftsmen

The decline of Indian handicrafts due to competition from British goods led to widespread unemployment and poverty among artisans. Textile artisans in Dhaka and Murshidabad were particularly affected. This created a class of disaffected individuals who were readily susceptible to anti-British sentiment.

Socio-Religious Concerns

  • Interference in Religious Practices: British attempts to impose Western values and reforms, such as the abolition of Sati (1829) and the promotion of English education, were perceived by many as an attack on their religious and cultural traditions.
  • Missionary Activities: The increasing presence of Christian missionaries and their proselytizing activities fueled anxieties among Hindus and Muslims.
  • Taxation on Temples and Mosques: The British government’s taxation policies on religious institutions were seen as disrespectful and intrusive.

The Military Grievances as a Catalyst

While socio-economic factors created the underlying conditions for revolt, the immediate trigger was the discontent within the Bengal army.

  • Greased Cartridges: The introduction of the Enfield rifle and the greased cartridges, rumored to be coated with animal fat, offended both Hindu and Muslim sepoys.
  • Discrimination: Indian sepoys faced discrimination in terms of pay, promotion, and treatment compared to their British counterparts.
  • Religious Sensitivities: Restrictions on religious practices within the army also contributed to resentment.

Regional Variations and Participation

The revolt was not uniform across India. Different regions witnessed varying degrees of participation, driven by specific local grievances.

Region Key Grievances & Leaders
Awadh Annexation by the British, displacement of the Nawab, widespread peasant discontent. Begum Hazrat Mahal led the resistance.
Kanpur High taxation, oppression of peasants. Nana Sahib and Tantia Tope played prominent roles.
Jhansi Doctrine of Lapse, Rani Lakshmibai’s refusal to accept British sovereignty.
Bihar Tribal uprisings led by Birsa Munda (though later, it reflects similar discontent).

The Role of Dispossessed Rulers and Chiefs

Dispossessed rulers and chiefs, such as Nana Sahib, Rani Lakshmibai, and Bahadur Shah Zafar, provided leadership and legitimacy to the revolt. Their participation transformed the sepoy mutiny into a broader rebellion against British rule.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Revolt of 1857 was far more than a mere military uprising. It was a complex phenomenon rooted in the long-term socio-economic and political consequences of British colonialism. The disruption of traditional economic structures, the imposition of alien laws and customs, and the erosion of social hierarchies created widespread discontent among diverse sections of Indian society. While the greased cartridges served as the immediate spark, the underlying causes lay in the fundamental changes that had upset the peasant communities and other segments of the population, making the revolt a powerful expression of resistance against colonial rule. The revolt, though ultimately suppressed, forced the British to reassess their policies and led to significant administrative changes.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Doctrine of Lapse
A policy introduced by Lord Dalhousie in 1848, which allowed the British to annex Indian states if the ruler died without a natural male heir.
Permanent Settlement
Introduced by Lord Cornwallis in 1793, this system fixed land revenue at a permanent amount, creating a class of zamindars who owned the land and collected revenue from the peasants.

Key Statistics

Between 1854 and 1860, the land revenue assessments in India increased by 20% (Source: R.C. Dutt, The Economic History of India, 1902).

Source: R.C. Dutt, The Economic History of India, 1902

The British East India Company’s revenue from India increased from £8 million in 1765 to £26 million in 1857 (Source: Estimates based on historical records).

Source: Based on historical records and economic analyses (knowledge cutoff 2023)

Examples

Indigo Rebellion (1859-60)

The Indigo Rebellion in Bengal, preceding the 1857 revolt, demonstrated the extent of peasant discontent caused by the forced cultivation of indigo. It involved widespread protests and clashes between peasants and indigo planters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was the Revolt of 1857 a national revolt?

While the revolt was widespread, it lacked a unified national leadership or ideology. Participation was uneven across India, and many regions remained unaffected. However, it represented a significant challenge to British authority and laid the groundwork for the Indian nationalist movement.

Topics Covered

HistoryModern IndiaRevolt of 1857Social HistoryEconomic History