UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II202120 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q11.

Classify types of male sterility and self-incompatibility system in plants. Describe the limitations of cytoplasmic genetic male sterility system in hybrid seed production.

How to Approach

This question requires a structured response, classifying male sterility and self-incompatibility, then critically analyzing cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) limitations. I will begin by defining these concepts and classifying their types. Then, I’ll elaborate on CMS, highlighting its advantages and subsequently detailing its limitations in hybrid seed production, particularly concerning genetic purity and environmental instability. A tabular comparison will aid clarity. The conclusion will summarize key points and suggest future directions.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Hybrid seed production is crucial for modern agriculture, contributing significantly to enhanced yields and crop diversity. Male sterility, the inability of a plant to produce viable pollen, is a vital tool in hybrid seed development, eliminating the need for hand-pollination. This phenomenon manifests in various forms, both genetic and cytoplasmic, each with its own mechanisms and limitations. Self-incompatibility, another crucial factor, prevents self-pollination, further aiding hybrid development. Understanding these mechanisms and their associated challenges is essential for ensuring the efficiency and sustainability of hybrid seed production, especially in the context of climate change and evolving pest pressures.

Types of Male Sterility in Plants

Male sterility can be broadly classified into genetic and cytoplasmic male sterility. Genetic male sterility arises from mutations in genes affecting pollen development, while cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) is controlled by factors present in the cytoplasm, often associated with organelles like mitochondria or chloroplasts.

Genetic Male Sterility

  • Conditional Male Sterility: Sterility is temperature-dependent or induced by specific chemicals. Example: Certain varieties of rice exhibit male sterility at higher temperatures.
  • Recessive Male Sterility: Sterility is expressed only when the plant carries two copies of the recessive sterility gene.
  • Dominant Male Sterility: Sterility is expressed when the plant carries even a single copy of the dominant sterility gene.
  • Gametic Sterility: The pollen grains are formed but are non-functional.

Self-Incompatibility (SI) Systems

Self-incompatibility prevents self-pollination and promotes outcrossing, crucial for hybrid vigour. There are different types:

  • Sporophytic Incompatibility: The pollen grain's ability to germinate and grow is determined by the genotype of the parent plant.
  • Gametophytic Incompatibility: The pollen grain’s ability to fertilize the ovule is determined by its own genotype. This is more common in Rosaceae and Solanaceae families.
  • Anther-Stigma Incompatibility: The pollen is unable to germinate on the stigma.
  • Pollination-Pollen Tube Growth Incompatibility: The pollen grain germinates but the pollen tube doesn't grow down the style.

Cytoplasmic Male Sterility (CMS)

CMS is a fascinating phenomenon where male sterility is controlled by cytoplasmic factors, often linked to mitochondrial or chloroplast genes. The most common type is Ogura CMS, prevalent in rice and other crops.

Mechanism of CMS (Ogura Type)

In Ogura CMS, a transposable element (TE), tms-1, is inserted into the cob gene within the chloroplast genome. This disrupts the normal function of the cob gene, which is essential for cytochrome oxidase synthesis, a vital component of the electron transport chain in mitochondria. The disruption leads to the production of abnormal microspores and ultimately, male sterility.

Advantages of CMS in Hybrid Seed Production

  • Eliminates Hand-Pollination: This significantly reduces labor costs and increases efficiency.
  • Large-Scale Seed Production: Allows for cost-effective production of hybrid seeds at a commercial scale.
  • Widespread Adoption: CMS has been instrumental in the adoption of hybrid varieties in crops like rice, maize, and cotton.

Limitations of Cytoplasmic Genetic Male Sterility (CMS) in Hybrid Seed Production

Despite its advantages, CMS faces several limitations that hinder its wider applicability and sustainability.

Limitation Description Impact
Genetic Purity Loss CMS lines can segregate, leading to the loss of sterility and the production of fertile plants. This happens due to recombination events within the chloroplast genome. Reduces hybrid seed purity and yield. Requires careful selection and maintenance of CMS lines.
Environmental Instability CMS expression can be influenced by environmental factors like temperature and photoperiod. Stress conditions can sometimes restore fertility. Unpredictable seed production and reduced reliability of hybrid performance.
Limited Genetic Diversity CMS often restricts the available genetic diversity in breeding programs. The reliance on specific CMS lines can narrow the gene pool. Increases vulnerability to pests, diseases, and environmental stresses.
Restoration of Fertility Nuclear genes (Rf genes) can restore fertility in CMS lines, often through interaction with the cytoplasmic male sterility system. This is undesirable in hybrid seed production. Contamination of CMS lines with fertile plants, leading to non-hybrid progeny.

The National Mission on Oilseed & Pulses (NMOOP), launched in 2010-11, aims to increase the production of oilseeds and pulses, and hybrid seed production is a key component. However, addressing the limitations of CMS remains a priority.

Case Study: Rice Hybrid Development in India: The development and widespread adoption of cytoplasmic male sterile rice varieties like DRR (Deep Red Rindless) has revolutionized rice production in India. However, the emergence of fertile plants due to genetic segregation and environmental factors poses a continuous challenge, requiring ongoing breeder seed production and quality control. Question: Why is genetic diversity important in CMS breeding programs? Answer: Limited genetic diversity in CMS lines makes crops vulnerable to diseases and environmental changes. Maintaining a wide gene pool is essential for long-term sustainability. Ogura CMS: A type of cytoplasmic male sterility commonly found in rice and other crops, characterized by a transposable element insertion in the cob gene of the chloroplast genome. Globally, hybrid seeds account for approximately 70% of the area under maize, 60% under cotton, and 30% under rice. (Source: FAOSTAT - Knowledge Cutoff) National Mission on Oilseed & Pulses (NMOOP): This scheme focuses on enhancing oilseed and pulse production, including promoting the use of hybrid seeds and addressing challenges related to CMS.

Conclusion

In conclusion, male sterility and self-incompatibility are critical components of hybrid seed production, enabling efficient breeding and higher yields. While CMS offers significant advantages, its limitations concerning genetic purity, environmental instability, and reduced genetic diversity necessitate continuous research and development of alternative strategies, such as genetic male sterility systems or exploring gene editing techniques to improve CMS stability. Future research should focus on mitigating these limitations to ensure the long-term sustainability and effectiveness of hybrid seed production in a changing climate.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Self-Incompatibility
A genetic mechanism that prevents self-fertilization in plants, promoting outcrossing and genetic diversity.
Transposable Element (TE)
A DNA sequence that can change its position within a genome, often disrupting gene function and contributing to genetic variation. In CMS, TEs like <i>tms-1</i> can cause male sterility.

Key Statistics

Hybrid maize accounts for approximately 80% of the maize area cultivated in the United States. (Source: USDA NASS - Knowledge Cutoff)

Source: USDA NASS

Approximately 25% of flowering plant species exhibit self-incompatibility. (Source: Various botanical literature - Knowledge Cutoff)

Source: Botanical Literature

Examples

Bt Cotton and CMS

The combination of Bt technology (insect resistance) and CMS in cotton has significantly increased yields and reduced pesticide use, but also highlights the need for managing the limitations of CMS to maintain genetic purity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between genetic and cytoplasmic male sterility?

Genetic male sterility is controlled by genes in the nuclear genome, while cytoplasmic male sterility is controlled by factors in the cytoplasm, often related to organelles.

Topics Covered

AgricultureGeneticsBotanyPlant BreedingHybrid SeedReproductive Systems