UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-I202110 Marks150 Words
Q17.

Mention the evolutionary changes that occur during domestication of plants. Also mention its advantages and disadvantages.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of plant evolution and the impact of human selection during domestication. The answer should begin by defining domestication and outlining the key evolutionary changes – both intentional and unintentional – that occur. It should then discuss the advantages and disadvantages of these changes, considering both agricultural productivity and genetic diversity. A structured approach, categorizing changes into morphological, physiological, and reproductive aspects, will be beneficial. Examples of domesticated crops should be used to illustrate the points.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Plant domestication, a cornerstone of human civilization, represents a unique form of artificial selection. It’s the process whereby wild plant species are genetically modified over time through human intervention to become more useful for agriculture. This process, beginning around 10,000 years ago with the Neolithic Revolution, has dramatically altered plant morphology, physiology, and reproductive strategies. While leading to increased food production and security, domestication has also resulted in significant evolutionary consequences, impacting genetic diversity and potentially increasing vulnerability to pests and diseases. Understanding these changes is crucial for modern crop improvement and conservation efforts.

Evolutionary Changes During Domestication

Domestication induces a range of evolutionary changes, broadly categorized as follows:

1. Morphological Changes

  • Loss of Seed Dormancy: Wild plants often exhibit seed dormancy to ensure germination under favorable conditions. Domestication selects for non-dormant seeds, allowing for synchronized germination and harvest. Example: Wheat and rice.
  • Reduced Shattering: Wild grasses readily shed their seeds, aiding dispersal. Domestication favors plants with seeds that remain attached to the plant, facilitating harvest. Example: Barley.
  • Increased Seed/Fruit Size: Humans preferentially selected for larger seeds and fruits, leading to a significant increase in size compared to their wild ancestors. Example: Modern maize compared to its ancestor, teosinte.
  • Altered Branching Patterns: Wild plants often exhibit a profuse branching pattern. Domestication selects for more compact, determinate growth habits, making harvesting easier. Example: Peas.

2. Physiological Changes

  • Increased Sugar Content: In fruits, domestication has often led to increased sugar content, making them more palatable. Example: Modern apples and grapes.
  • Reduced Production of Secondary Metabolites: Wild plants produce various secondary metabolites (e.g., toxins, bitter compounds) for defense. Domestication often selects for reduced levels of these compounds, improving palatability and digestibility. Example: Cultivated tomatoes have lower levels of solanine than their wild relatives.
  • Altered Flowering Time: Domestication can lead to changes in flowering time, allowing for adaptation to different growing seasons and synchronization with human agricultural practices.

3. Reproductive Changes

  • Self-Pollination: Many domesticated crops have shifted towards self-pollination, ensuring predictable seed production and reducing the need for pollinators. Example: Common beans and wheat.
  • Loss of Asexual Reproduction: While some wild plants reproduce asexually, domestication often favors sexual reproduction, increasing genetic diversity (though often reduced overall).

Advantages of Domestication

  • Increased Yield: Domestication has dramatically increased crop yields, supporting larger human populations.
  • Improved Nutritional Value: Selective breeding has enhanced the nutritional content of many crops.
  • Enhanced Palatability: Reduced levels of toxins and increased sugar content have made crops more appealing to consume.
  • Adaptation to Diverse Environments: Domestication has allowed crops to be grown in a wider range of environments.

Disadvantages of Domestication

  • Reduced Genetic Diversity: Domestication often leads to a significant reduction in genetic diversity, making crops more vulnerable to pests, diseases, and climate change.
  • Increased Susceptibility to Pests and Diseases: Loss of defense mechanisms (secondary metabolites) can increase susceptibility to pests and diseases.
  • Dependence on Human Intervention: Many domesticated crops are now entirely dependent on human intervention for survival and reproduction.
  • Environmental Impact: Intensive agriculture associated with domesticated crops can have negative environmental impacts, such as soil erosion and water pollution.

The concept of ‘Bottleneck effect’ is highly relevant here, where a large population (wild species) is reduced to a small founding population (domesticated variety), leading to loss of genetic variation.

Conclusion

Plant domestication has been a transformative process, fundamentally altering both plant evolution and human society. While providing immense benefits in terms of food security and agricultural productivity, it has also come at the cost of reduced genetic diversity and increased vulnerability. Modern crop improvement strategies increasingly focus on utilizing wild relatives to reintroduce lost genetic diversity and enhance crop resilience, recognizing the importance of preserving the evolutionary heritage of our cultivated plants. Sustainable agricultural practices are also crucial to mitigate the environmental impacts associated with domestication.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Artificial Selection
The intentional breeding of plants or animals for specific traits, as opposed to natural selection, where traits are favored based on environmental pressures.
Genetic Erosion
The loss of genetic diversity, including the loss of entire species or breeds, due to factors such as habitat destruction, overexploitation, and the replacement of traditional varieties with improved ones.

Key Statistics

Approximately 7,000 plant species have been cultivated for food throughout human history, but only about 30 crops provide 90% of the world’s food supply.

Source: FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations), 2014

Approximately 75% of plant genetic diversity has been lost since the 1900s due to the widespread adoption of a limited number of high-yielding crop varieties.

Source: FAO, State of the World’s Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture, 2019

Examples

Maize Domestication

Maize (corn) is a prime example of dramatic domestication. Its ancestor, teosinte, had small, hard seeds enclosed in a tough husk, with only a few seeds per plant. Through selective breeding, maize evolved to have large, easily accessible kernels arranged in rows on a cob, with hundreds of seeds per plant.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of genetic engineering in modern plant domestication?

Genetic engineering allows for the precise introduction of specific genes into crops, accelerating the domestication process and enabling the development of crops with novel traits, such as pest resistance or enhanced nutritional value. However, it also raises ethical and environmental concerns.

Topics Covered

BotanyAgricultureEvolutionPlant DomesticationCrop EvolutionAgriculture