UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I202120 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q22.

Discuss Tom Jones as a bildungsroman and a picaresque novel.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of literary genres – bildungsroman and picaresque – and their manifestation in Henry Fielding’s *Tom Jones*. The answer should define both genres, then systematically analyze *Tom Jones* through the lens of each, providing specific examples from the novel. A comparative approach highlighting overlaps and divergences will demonstrate a nuanced understanding. Structure the answer by first defining the genres, then analyzing *Tom Jones* as a bildungsroman, followed by its picaresque elements, and finally a synthesis.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Henry Fielding’s *Tom Jones* (1749) is widely considered a cornerstone of the English novel. Its sprawling narrative, vibrant characters, and satirical wit have secured its place in literary history. However, its categorization remains a subject of debate. While often celebrated for its realistic portrayal of 18th-century England, *Tom Jones* simultaneously exhibits characteristics of two distinct narrative forms: the bildungsroman, a novel of formation focusing on a protagonist’s psychological and moral development, and the picaresque novel, characterized by an episodic structure and a roguish protagonist navigating a corrupt society. This essay will explore *Tom Jones* as both a bildungsroman and a picaresque novel, demonstrating how Fielding masterfully blends these conventions.

*Tom Jones* as a Bildungsroman

The term ‘bildungsroman’ (German for ‘novel of formation’) describes a genre focused on the psychological and moral growth of a protagonist from youth to maturity. Key features include a protagonist’s search for identity, disillusionment with societal norms, and eventual integration (or rejection) of those norms. *Tom Jones* demonstrably fits this framework.

  • Early Innocence and Subsequent Disillusionment: Tom begins as a naive, impulsive youth, largely unaware of the complexities of the world. His expulsion from school and subsequent adventures expose him to the hypocrisy and moral failings of 18th-century society, shattering his initial idealism.
  • Moral Development: Throughout his journey, Tom undergoes a significant moral evolution. While initially driven by passion and self-interest, he gradually learns the importance of compassion, responsibility, and genuine affection. His relationships with Sophia Western and Partridge contribute to this development.
  • Search for Identity: Tom’s true parentage is a central mystery, driving his quest for self-discovery. The revelation of his legitimate birth is not merely a plot device but a symbolic representation of his achieving a stable identity and social position.
  • Integration into Society: Unlike some bildungsromans that end with the protagonist’s rejection of society, *Tom Jones* concludes with Tom’s marriage to Sophia and his establishment as a landowner, signifying his integration into the social order.

*Tom Jones* as a Picaresque Novel

The picaresque novel, originating in Spain in the 16th century, features an episodic narrative following the adventures of a ‘picaro’ – a roguish, often lower-class protagonist who survives by his wits in a corrupt society. *Tom Jones* shares several key characteristics with this genre.

  • Episodic Structure: The novel is structured as a series of loosely connected episodes, each presenting Tom in a new location and encountering a new set of characters. This episodic nature mirrors the wandering life of a picaro.
  • Roguish Protagonist: Tom, despite his inherent goodness, frequently engages in mischievous and morally questionable behavior – gambling, fighting, and pursuing numerous romantic interests. This aligns with the picaro’s tendency towards roguery.
  • Satirical Depiction of Society: Fielding uses Tom’s adventures to satirize the hypocrisy, class divisions, and moral corruption of 18th-century England. The novel exposes the flaws of various social institutions and characters.
  • Realistic Portrayal of Lower Classes: Unlike traditional novels that focused on the aristocracy, *Tom Jones* gives voice to characters from all social strata, providing a realistic depiction of life in 18th-century England.
  • Travel and Adventure: Tom’s journey from Somerset to London and back is filled with adventure, encounters with diverse characters, and a constant struggle for survival, hallmarks of the picaresque tradition.

Synthesis: Blending of Genres

While *Tom Jones* exhibits characteristics of both the bildungsroman and the picaresque novel, it is not simply a hybrid of the two. Fielding consciously utilizes the conventions of both genres to create a more complex and nuanced narrative. The picaresque structure provides the framework for Tom’s adventures and allows Fielding to satirize society, while the bildungsroman elements provide a psychological depth and moral framework for Tom’s development.

The episodic nature of the picaresque allows Fielding to expose Tom to a wide range of experiences that contribute to his growth, while the bildungsroman focus ensures that these experiences are not merely random but contribute to his evolving character. Fielding elevates the picaresque by imbuing it with a moral purpose, transforming the picaro into a protagonist whose journey is ultimately one of self-discovery and moral improvement.

Feature Bildungsroman Picaresque Novel
Focus Psychological and moral development of protagonist Adventures of a roguish protagonist in a corrupt society
Protagonist Seeks identity and meaning Survives by wits and cunning
Structure Linear, focused on protagonist’s growth Episodic, loosely connected adventures
Social Commentary Often implicit, through protagonist’s experiences Explicit, through satire and exposure of societal flaws

Conclusion

In conclusion, *Tom Jones* is a remarkably complex novel that successfully integrates the conventions of both the bildungsroman and the picaresque novel. Fielding’s masterful blending of these genres allows him to create a narrative that is both entertaining and insightful, offering a compelling portrait of 18th-century England and a nuanced exploration of human nature. The novel’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to resonate with readers on multiple levels, as a thrilling adventure story and a profound meditation on the challenges of growing up and finding one’s place in the world.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Bildungsroman
A German term meaning "novel of formation," referring to a novel that traces the psychological and moral development of its protagonist from youth to adulthood.
Picaresque Novel
A genre of prose fiction that depicts the adventures of a roguish, but appealing, hero of low social class who lives by his wits in a corrupt society.

Key Statistics

By 1750, approximately 20% of the English population was literate, creating a growing readership for novels like *Tom Jones*.

Source: British Library (knowledge cutoff 2021)

First edition of *Tom Jones* sold approximately 10,000 copies within the first year of publication, demonstrating its immediate popularity.

Source: Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (knowledge cutoff 2021)

Examples

Great Expectations

Charles Dickens’ *Great Expectations* is another classic example of a bildungsroman, tracing Pip’s journey from humble beginnings to social aspiration and eventual moral maturity.

Lazarillo de Tormes

Considered the first picaresque novel, *Lazarillo de Tormes* (1554) established the conventions of the genre with its episodic structure and roguish protagonist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is *Tom Jones* purely a comedy?

While *Tom Jones* is undeniably humorous, it also contains elements of tragedy and social critique. Fielding uses comedy to expose the flaws of society and to highlight the suffering of those who are marginalized.

How does Fielding’s narrative voice contribute to the novel’s effect?

Fielding employs a highly intrusive narrative voice, frequently addressing the reader directly and offering commentary on the characters and events. This creates a sense of intimacy and allows Fielding to guide the reader’s interpretation of the story.

Topics Covered

LiteratureNovelLiterary FormsTom JonesBildungsromanPicaresque