UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-I202120 Marks
Q20.

Development-induced displacement poses serious challenges. Mention its causes, consequences and solutions.

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer addressing the causes, consequences, and solutions related to development-induced displacement. The approach should be structured around these three core components. Begin by defining development-induced displacement and its context. Then, systematically analyze the causes (categorizing them if possible), followed by a detailed examination of the consequences – social, economic, environmental, and psychological. Finally, propose comprehensive and sustainable solutions, incorporating legal, policy, and community-based approaches. Use examples and case studies to illustrate the points.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Development-induced displacement (DID) refers to the forced relocation of people due to projects undertaken in the name of economic development. These projects can range from large dams and infrastructure development to mining operations and conservation initiatives. While development is crucial for societal progress, it often comes at the cost of displacing vulnerable populations, particularly indigenous communities and marginalized groups. According to a 2018 report by the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC), India consistently ranks among the countries with the highest numbers of people displaced internally due to development projects. This displacement presents significant humanitarian and socio-economic challenges, demanding a nuanced understanding of its causes, consequences, and potential solutions.

Causes of Development-Induced Displacement

The causes of DID are diverse and often interconnected. They can be broadly categorized as follows:

  • Infrastructure Projects: Construction of dams (e.g., Sardar Sarovar Dam), highways, railways, airports, and urban expansion projects necessitate land acquisition and displacement.
  • Industrial Development: Mining activities (coal, iron ore, bauxite), power plants (thermal, nuclear), and industrial estates often lead to displacement of local communities.
  • Natural Resource Extraction: Exploration and extraction of oil, gas, and minerals frequently displace populations, particularly in resource-rich areas.
  • Conservation Initiatives: Creation of national parks, wildlife sanctuaries, and biosphere reserves can lead to the displacement of communities residing within these protected areas. (e.g., displacement of tribal communities for tiger reserves).
  • Disaster Mitigation Projects: Construction of embankments, flood control structures, and resettlement of communities from disaster-prone areas.

Consequences of Development-Induced Displacement

The consequences of DID are far-reaching and affect multiple dimensions of human life:

  • Socio-Cultural Disruption: Displacement often leads to the loss of traditional livelihoods, social networks, cultural identity, and community cohesion.
  • Economic Hardship: Displaced people frequently experience loss of land, assets, and income sources, leading to increased poverty and economic vulnerability. The compensation provided is often inadequate and delayed.
  • Environmental Degradation: Displacement can exacerbate environmental problems in resettlement areas due to increased pressure on resources and unsustainable practices.
  • Psychological Trauma: The experience of displacement can cause significant psychological distress, including anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder.
  • Health Issues: Poor living conditions in resettlement sites, lack of access to healthcare, and psychological stress can lead to increased morbidity and mortality.
  • Political Marginalization: Displaced communities often lack political representation and are excluded from decision-making processes that affect their lives.

The following table summarizes the key consequences:

Dimension Consequences
Social Loss of community, cultural identity, social networks
Economic Loss of livelihood, increased poverty, inadequate compensation
Environmental Resource depletion, pollution, ecological imbalance
Psychological Stress, anxiety, depression, trauma
Political Marginalization, lack of representation

Solutions to Mitigate Development-Induced Displacement

Addressing DID requires a holistic and rights-based approach:

  • Strengthening Legal Frameworks: The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (RFCTLARR Act) is a significant step, but its implementation needs to be strengthened. Amendments should address loopholes and ensure effective grievance redressal mechanisms.
  • Prioritizing Alternatives to Displacement: Exploring alternative project designs and locations that minimize displacement. Conducting thorough social impact assessments (SIAs) before project approval.
  • Comprehensive Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R&R) Plans: Developing R&R plans that are participatory, culturally sensitive, and provide adequate compensation, housing, livelihood opportunities, and social services.
  • Community Participation: Ensuring meaningful participation of affected communities in all stages of the project cycle, from planning to implementation and monitoring.
  • Livelihood Restoration: Providing skills training, employment opportunities, and access to credit to enable displaced people to restore their livelihoods.
  • Monitoring and Evaluation: Establishing independent monitoring mechanisms to track the implementation of R&R plans and ensure accountability.
  • Land Pooling and Land Sharing: Exploring innovative approaches like land pooling and land sharing to minimize displacement and maximize benefits for all stakeholders.

Conclusion

Development-induced displacement remains a complex and pressing issue in India. While development is essential, it must not come at the cost of human rights and social justice. Strengthening legal frameworks, prioritizing alternatives to displacement, ensuring meaningful community participation, and implementing comprehensive R&R plans are crucial steps towards mitigating the negative consequences of DID. A paradigm shift is needed, moving from a purely economic perspective to a more holistic and equitable approach that prioritizes the well-being of affected communities and promotes sustainable development. Future policies should focus on proactive measures to prevent displacement and empower displaced communities to rebuild their lives with dignity.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Development-Induced Displacement (DID)
The involuntary relocation of people due to development projects, encompassing infrastructure, industrial, and conservation initiatives.
Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R&R)
The process of restoring the livelihoods and living standards of people displaced by development projects, including providing compensation, housing, and social services.

Key Statistics

According to the World Bank, approximately 3.4 million people are displaced annually due to development projects globally.

Source: World Bank (Knowledge cutoff: 2023)

A 2022 study by the Centre for Policy Research found that approximately 65 million people have been displaced in India due to development projects since independence.

Source: Centre for Policy Research (Knowledge cutoff: 2023)

Examples

Narmada Bachao Andolan

A social movement opposing the Sardar Sarovar Dam project in the Narmada Valley, highlighting the displacement of thousands of tribal people and the environmental consequences.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of Social Impact Assessment (SIA) in preventing DID?

SIA is a crucial tool for identifying potential social impacts of development projects, including displacement. It helps in assessing the vulnerability of affected communities and developing mitigation measures to minimize negative consequences.

Topics Covered

GeographySocial IssuesEnvironmentDisplacementResettlementSocial ImpactEnvironmental Impact