UPSC MainsPHILOSOPHY-PAPER-I202120 Marks
Q22.

Explain with reference to Yoga Philosophy, the nature of klesas. How does the removal of these lead to kaivalya?

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, specifically the concept of *kleshas* and their role in hindering *kaivalya*. The answer should begin by defining Yoga philosophy and its core aim. Then, systematically explain each of the five *kleshas* – *avidya, asmitā, rāga, dvesha, and abhinivesha* – with examples. Finally, elaborate on how the systematic removal of these *kleshas* through the eight limbs of Yoga leads to the state of *kaivalya* (isolation/liberation). A structured approach, defining terms and providing illustrative examples, is crucial for a good score.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Yoga, as a school of Indian philosophy, aims at the cessation of suffering and the attainment of liberation (*kaivalya*). Rooted in the teachings of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, it provides a systematic path to achieve this goal. Central to this path is understanding the nature of suffering, which, according to Yoga philosophy, arises from the afflictions or *kleshas*. These *kleshas* are fundamental obstacles that cloud the true nature of the Self (*Purusha*) and bind us to the cycle of birth and death. This answer will explore the nature of these *kleshas* and how their removal, through the practice of Yoga, ultimately leads to the realization of *kaivalya*.

Understanding Kleshas in Yoga Philosophy

The term *klesha* literally means ‘afflictions’ or ‘causes of suffering’. Patanjali identifies five primary *kleshas* that are the root causes of all our mental and emotional turmoil. These are not merely negative emotions but deeply ingrained tendencies that distort our perception of reality.

1. Avidya (Ignorance)

Avidya is considered the root *klesha*, the fundamental ignorance of the true nature of reality. It’s the mistaken identification of the impermanent (*anitya*) as permanent, the impure as pure, the painful as pleasurable, and the non-Self (*anatma*) as the Self (*atma*). This misperception leads to all other *kleshas*.

Example: Believing that our physical body and possessions define who we are, leading to attachment and fear of loss.

2. Asmitā (Egoism/I-am-ness)

Asmitā arises from *avidya* and is the false identification of the Self with the intellect, mind, and body. It’s the sense of ‘I-am-ness’ that creates a separate self, leading to possessiveness, pride, and a sense of individuality.

Example: Feeling superior to others based on achievements or social status.

3. Rāga (Attachment)

Rāga is the attachment to pleasurable experiences. It’s the desire to cling to things that bring us joy and avoid those that cause pain. This attachment creates dependence and suffering when those pleasurable experiences are lost or change.

Example: Being overly attached to material possessions, relationships, or sensory pleasures.

4. Dvesha (Aversion)

Dvesha is the opposite of *rāga* – the aversion to unpleasant experiences. It’s the desire to avoid things that cause us pain or discomfort. This aversion leads to anger, hatred, and resentment.

Example: Feeling angry or resentful towards someone who has wronged us.

5. Abhinivesha (Fear of Death/Clinging to Life)

Abhinivesha is the innate fear of death and the instinctive desire to preserve life. It’s a deeply ingrained survival instinct that can lead to anxiety, insecurity, and a reluctance to embrace change.

Example: An overwhelming fear of illness or aging, leading to unhealthy coping mechanisms.

The Removal of Kleshas and the Path to Kaivalya

Patanjali outlines the eight limbs of Yoga (*Ashtanga Yoga*) as the means to systematically dismantle these *kleshas* and attain *kaivalya*. These limbs are:

  • Yamas (Ethical Restraints): Non-violence (*ahimsa*), truthfulness (*satya*), non-stealing (*asteya*), continence (*brahmacharya*), and non-possessiveness (*aparigraha*).
  • Niyamas (Observances): Purity (*shaucha*), contentment (*santosha*), austerity (*tapas*), self-study (*svadhyaya*), and surrender to a higher power (*ishvara pranidhana*).
  • Asana (Postures): Physical postures that cultivate stability and ease.
  • Pranayama (Breath Control): Techniques to regulate the breath and vital energy.
  • Pratyahara (Withdrawal of the Senses): Turning inward and detaching from external stimuli.
  • Dharana (Concentration): Focusing the mind on a single point.
  • Dhyana (Meditation): Sustained concentration leading to a state of deep absorption.
  • Samadhi (Absorption): The ultimate state of union with the divine, where the *kleshas* are completely dissolved.

Through consistent practice of these limbs, the mind becomes purified and the *kleshas* lose their grip. As *avidya* diminishes, the other *kleshas* also weaken. With the complete cessation of *kleshas*, the true nature of *Purusha* (the Self) is revealed, leading to *kaivalya* – a state of complete liberation, independence, and blissful awareness.

The process isn’t instantaneous. It requires dedicated practice (*abhyasa*) and detachment (*vairagya*). As the *kleshas* are gradually removed, the individual experiences increasing freedom from suffering and a deeper understanding of their true nature.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the *kleshas* are the fundamental causes of suffering in Yoga philosophy, stemming from ignorance and manifesting as egoism, attachment, aversion, and fear of death. The eight limbs of Yoga provide a practical path to systematically dismantle these afflictions, leading to the purification of the mind and the realization of *kaivalya*. This state of liberation is not merely an escape from suffering but a profound awakening to the true nature of reality and the Self. The journey requires consistent effort and detachment, ultimately culminating in a state of blissful freedom.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Kaivalya
Kaivalya, in Yoga philosophy, refers to the state of liberation or isolation. It signifies the complete separation of *Purusha* (the Self) from *Prakriti* (nature), resulting in freedom from suffering and the cycle of birth and death.
Purusha and Prakriti
In Yoga philosophy, *Purusha* represents the pure consciousness or Self, while *Prakriti* is the material world, including mind and body. The *kleshas* create a false identification between *Purusha* and *Prakriti*, leading to suffering. *Kaivalya* is the realization of their distinctness.

Key Statistics

A 2016 study by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) found that regular yoga practice can reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression, suggesting a practical benefit related to the reduction of *kleshas*.

Source: National Institutes of Health (NIH), 2016

According to a 2020 report by the Yoga Journal, over 36 million people practice yoga in the United States, indicating a growing interest in practices aimed at mental and emotional well-being, which aligns with the reduction of *kleshas*.

Source: Yoga Journal, 2020

Examples

The Story of Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita

Arjuna’s initial despair and reluctance to fight in the Mahabharata war exemplify the influence of *rāga* (attachment to loved ones) and *dvesha* (aversion to causing harm). Krishna’s teachings guide him to overcome these *kleshas* and fulfill his duty, illustrating the path to liberation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it possible to completely eliminate all kleshas?

While complete elimination of *kleshas* is the ultimate goal, it’s a gradual process. Even advanced practitioners may experience subtle remnants of *kleshas*. The aim is to weaken their influence and prevent them from causing suffering.

Topics Covered

Indian PhilosophyYogaKlesasKaivalyaLiberation