UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-I202210 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q5.

Write a comparative account of the icosahedral and helical symmetry of viruses.

How to Approach

This question requires a comparative analysis of two fundamental viral symmetries: icosahedral and helical. The answer should begin by defining both symmetries, then detail their structural characteristics, assembly processes, examples of viruses exhibiting each symmetry, and their respective advantages and disadvantages. A tabular comparison will enhance clarity. Focus on the protein subunit arrangement and nucleic acid packaging within each structure.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Viruses, obligate intracellular parasites, exhibit remarkable diversity in their structure and genetic material. A key aspect of viral architecture is symmetry, which dictates the arrangement of protein subunits (capsomeres) that enclose the viral genome. The two most common types of symmetry observed in viruses are icosahedral and helical. Understanding these symmetries is crucial for comprehending viral assembly, stability, and host interactions. Icosahedral symmetry provides a robust and efficient way to enclose a genome, while helical symmetry is often associated with viruses possessing segmented genomes.

Icosahedral Symmetry

Icosahedral symmetry is characterized by a 20-sided structure composed of equilateral triangles. This arrangement results from the most efficient way to enclose a fixed volume with the least amount of surface area. The icosahedron is formed by 60 asymmetric units, each consisting of multiple protein subunits.

  • Capsomere Arrangement: Capsomeres are arranged in a repeating pattern to form the icosahedral shell, or capsid.
  • Assembly: Assembly is self-assembling, driven by interactions between protein subunits.
  • Genome Packaging: The genome is packaged inside the capsid. The size of the genome is limited by the capsid volume.
  • Examples: Adenoviruses, Poliovirus, Herpesviruses.
  • Advantages: High stability, efficient use of building blocks, allows for relatively large genome size.
  • Disadvantages: Complex assembly process, limited flexibility.

Helical Symmetry

Helical symmetry is characterized by a spiral or helical structure. The protein subunits are arranged in a helical fashion around the nucleic acid, forming a rod-like structure. The length of the helix is determined by the length of the nucleic acid.

  • Capsomere Arrangement: Protein subunits are arranged in a helical pattern around the nucleic acid.
  • Assembly: Assembly begins with the binding of protein subunits to the nucleic acid.
  • Genome Packaging: The nucleic acid is intimately associated with the protein subunits, forming a nucleoprotein complex.
  • Examples: Tobacco Mosaic Virus (TMV), Influenza virus, Measles virus.
  • Advantages: Relatively simple assembly, allows for flexible genome length.
  • Disadvantages: Less stable than icosahedral structures, limited genome capacity compared to some icosahedral viruses.

Comparative Table

Feature Icosahedral Symmetry Helical Symmetry
Shape 20-sided polyhedron Spiral or rod-shaped
Capsomere Arrangement Equilateral triangles Helical pattern
Genome Packaging Genome enclosed within capsid Genome associated with protein subunits
Stability High Lower
Genome Size Relatively large Variable, often smaller
Examples Adenovirus, Poliovirus TMV, Influenza virus

Some viruses exhibit complex symmetry, combining features of both icosahedral and helical symmetries. Bacteriophages, for example, often have an icosahedral head containing the genome and a helical tail used for attachment and injection of the genetic material.

Conclusion

In conclusion, icosahedral and helical symmetries represent fundamental strategies employed by viruses to protect and deliver their genetic material. Icosahedral symmetry prioritizes stability and efficient packaging, while helical symmetry offers simplicity and flexibility. The choice of symmetry is likely influenced by factors such as genome size, host interactions, and evolutionary pressures. Understanding these symmetries is essential for developing antiviral therapies and vaccines targeting viral structure and assembly.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Capsomere
A protein subunit that makes up the capsid of a virus. Capsomeres self-assemble to form the complete capsid structure.
Nucleoprotein complex
A complex formed between the viral nucleic acid and viral proteins, often found in viruses with helical symmetry. It provides structural support and protection to the genome.

Key Statistics

Approximately 95% of known viruses exhibit either icosahedral or helical symmetry.

Source: Flint, S. J., et al. Principles of Virology. ASM Press, 2015.

The capsid of a simple icosahedral virus can be constructed from as few as 60 protein subunits.

Source: Lodish, H., et al. Molecular Cell Biology. W.H. Freeman, 2000.

Examples

Human Papillomavirus (HPV)

HPV, a common sexually transmitted infection, exhibits icosahedral symmetry. Its capsid is composed of 72 capsomeres arranged in a T=7 lattice, encapsulating a circular DNA genome.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a virus have both icosahedral and helical symmetry?

Yes, some viruses, particularly bacteriophages, exhibit complex symmetry, combining features of both icosahedral and helical structures. They often have an icosahedral head and a helical tail.

Topics Covered

MicrobiologyVirologyViral StructureViral ReplicationCapsid