UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I202215 Marks
Q11.

Wordsworth constitutes a sublimity out of his own overbearing subjectivity. Discuss with reference to the poems prescribed for study.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of Wordsworth’s poetic philosophy and its manifestation in his works. The core argument posits that Wordsworth’s ‘sublimity’ isn’t derived from external grandeur, but from the intensity of his own subjective experience. The answer should explore this claim by analyzing specific poems, focusing on how Wordsworth transforms ordinary experiences into moments of profound emotional and spiritual significance through his intensely personal perspective. Structure the answer by first defining ‘sublimity’ in the Romantic context, then demonstrating how Wordsworth’s subjectivity shapes his portrayal of nature, memory, and the common man, using examples from prescribed poems.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Romantic era witnessed a shift in aesthetic sensibilities, moving away from the Neoclassical emphasis on reason and objectivity towards a celebration of emotion, imagination, and individual experience. Central to this shift was the concept of the ‘sublime’ – initially understood as awe-inspiring grandeur in nature, as articulated by Edmund Burke. However, Romantic poets like Wordsworth redefined the sublime, locating it not merely in external phenomena, but within the human mind’s capacity to perceive and feel. Wordsworth, in particular, constitutes a sublimity not by depicting majestic landscapes, but by imbuing ordinary subjects with extraordinary emotional depth through his intensely personal and ‘overbearing subjectivity,’ a characteristic that fundamentally shapes his poetic vision, as evidenced in poems like ‘Tintern Abbey,’ ‘Ode: Intimations of Immortality,’ and ‘The Prelude.’

Wordsworth and the Redefinition of the Sublime

Traditionally, the sublime was associated with vastness, power, and terror – think of mountains, storms, or the ocean. However, Wordsworth’s approach diverges significantly. He finds the sublime not in these external forces, but in the ‘mind’s own power’ to transform and interpret experience. This is a crucial point: the source of the sublime isn’t the object itself, but the subjective response to it. This subjectivity isn’t presented as a weakness, but as a strength, a means of accessing deeper truths about existence.

Subjectivity and the Portrayal of Nature

In ‘Tintern Abbey’ (Lines Composed a Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey, On Revisiting the Banks of the Wye During a Tour. July 13, 1798), Wordsworth doesn’t simply describe the beauty of the Wye Valley. He details *his* emotional and spiritual connection to the landscape, tracing the evolution of his feelings over time. The poem isn’t about the valley itself, but about how the memory of the valley has shaped his inner life. The ‘sense sublime / Of something far more deeply interfused’ isn’t inherent in nature, but is a feeling *generated* within Wordsworth’s consciousness through his interaction with it. He projects his own emotional state onto the landscape, creating a symbiotic relationship where both are elevated.

Memory and the Reconstruction of Experience

Wordsworth’s subjectivity is powerfully evident in his treatment of memory. In ‘Ode: Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood,’ the loss of childhood’s innate spiritual vision is lamented. However, this loss isn’t presented as purely negative. Instead, memory becomes a crucial faculty for reconstructing and re-experiencing that lost connection. The poem’s sublime moments aren’t found in present reality, but in the poet’s recollection of past joys. The ‘spots of time’ – moments of intense emotional significance – are not objectively remarkable events, but become sublime through the power of memory and the poet’s subjective interpretation. He actively *creates* the sublime through the act of remembering.

The Common Man and the Dignity of Ordinary Life

Wordsworth’s focus on the ‘common man’ is another manifestation of his subjective approach. He elevates the experiences of ordinary people – farmers, shepherds, wanderers – not because of their inherent grandeur, but because he imbues them with dignity and significance through his empathetic imagination. In ‘The Prelude,’ particularly the ‘Lucy’ poems (though not explicitly prescribed, they are illustrative), the death of a young woman is not simply a tragic event, but a profound meditation on loss, mortality, and the interconnectedness of all things. The sublime isn’t in the event itself, but in the depth of the poet’s emotional response and his ability to find universal meaning in a personal tragedy. He doesn’t attempt to objectively represent Lucy; he presents his subjective experience of her and her loss.

The ‘Overbearing’ Aspect of Subjectivity

The phrase ‘overbearing subjectivity’ suggests a forceful imposition of the poet’s will onto the material world. Wordsworth doesn’t passively observe; he actively shapes and transforms his experiences through the lens of his own emotions and imagination. This can sometimes lead to a sense of self-absorption, but it’s precisely this intensity of feeling that generates the sublime. He doesn’t shy away from exploring the complexities and contradictions of his own inner life, and it is in this unflinching self-examination that his poetry achieves its power.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Wordsworth’s poetry demonstrably constitutes a sublimity born from his own intensely subjective experience. He doesn’t seek the sublime in external grandeur, but actively creates it through the power of memory, imagination, and empathetic connection. His focus on the inner life, the common man, and the transformative potential of nature, all filtered through the lens of his ‘overbearing subjectivity,’ redefined the Romantic understanding of the sublime and continues to resonate with readers today. Wordsworth’s legacy lies in his ability to find the extraordinary within the ordinary, and to elevate the human spirit through the power of poetic expression.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Sublime
Originally denoting elevated grandeur and awe-inspiring power, particularly in nature. In Romanticism, it shifted to encompass the emotional and spiritual experience of encountering something beyond comprehension, often found within the human mind itself.
Spots of Time
Moments of intense emotional or spiritual significance that leave a lasting impression on the mind, shaping one’s character and understanding of the world, as described by Wordsworth in ‘Ode: Intimations of Immortality.’

Key Statistics

Wordsworth published *Lyrical Ballads* in 1798, co-authored with Samuel Taylor Coleridge, marking a pivotal moment in the English Romantic movement.

Source: Abrams, M.H. *The Mirror and the Lamp*. Oxford University Press, 1953.

The Romantic period in English literature is generally considered to have spanned from 1798 (publication of *Lyrical Ballads*) to 1837 (the beginning of the Victorian era).

Source: Bloom, Harold. *The Visionary Company*. Cornell University Press, 1993.

Examples

The Ruined Cottage

In *The Prelude*, Wordsworth’s detailed account of a ruined cottage and the story of its former inhabitant exemplifies his ability to find profound emotional resonance in the most humble of settings. The sublime arises not from the cottage itself, but from the poet’s empathetic engagement with the lives of those who once lived there.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Wordsworth’s subjectivity a flaw in his poetry?

Not at all. While some critics have accused Wordsworth of self-absorption, his subjectivity is precisely what gives his poetry its unique power and emotional depth. It allows him to access universal truths through the exploration of his own inner life.

Topics Covered

LiteraturePoetryPhilosophyWordsworthSublimeSubjectivityRomanticismNature Poetry