UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-I202220 Marks
Q26.

How migration is affected by push and pull factors ? Explain how these factors play a role in understanding new settlement patterns.

How to Approach

This question requires a geographical and sociological understanding of migration. The answer should begin by defining push and pull factors, then elaborate on how they influence migration patterns. It should then explain how these factors contribute to the formation of new settlement patterns, including rural-urban migration, international migration, and internal displacement. Examples and case studies should be used to illustrate the concepts. A structured approach, dividing the answer into sections on push factors, pull factors, and resultant settlement patterns, will be effective.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Migration, a fundamental aspect of human history, is the movement of people from one place to another with the intention of settling, permanently or temporarily, at a new location. This movement is rarely random; it is largely influenced by a complex interplay of ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors. Push factors are the negative aspects of a place that encourage people to leave, while pull factors are the positive aspects of a destination that attract people. Understanding these factors is crucial to comprehending the evolving demographic landscape and the formation of new settlement patterns globally, particularly in a rapidly changing world marked by economic disparities, political instability, and environmental challenges.

Understanding Push and Pull Factors

Migration decisions are rarely based on a single factor. Instead, individuals and groups weigh a combination of push and pull forces. These factors can be economic, social, political, or environmental.

Push Factors

  • Economic Hardship: Lack of employment opportunities, low wages, and limited economic prospects are significant push factors. For example, agricultural distress in the Indian states of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh pushes many rural laborers to seek work in cities like Delhi and Mumbai.
  • Political Instability & Conflict: War, persecution, and political unrest force people to flee their homes. The Syrian refugee crisis, triggered by the civil war, is a prime example.
  • Environmental Degradation: Natural disasters like floods, droughts, and desertification, coupled with climate change impacts, can displace populations. The displacement of communities in the Sundarbans due to rising sea levels is a relevant example.
  • Social Issues: Discrimination, lack of access to education and healthcare, and social unrest can also act as push factors.

Pull Factors

  • Economic Opportunities: Higher wages, better employment prospects, and a perceived higher standard of living attract migrants. The ‘Gulf Boom’ of the 1970s and 80s drew millions of Indian workers to the Middle East.
  • Political Stability & Freedom: Countries offering political stability, freedom, and democratic governance are attractive destinations.
  • Better Living Conditions: Access to better healthcare, education, and infrastructure are strong pull factors. Canada and Australia consistently attract skilled migrants due to these factors.
  • Social Networks: The presence of family and friends in a destination country can significantly influence migration decisions. Chain migration, where migrants follow relatives and friends, is a common phenomenon.

New Settlement Patterns Shaped by Push and Pull Factors

The interplay of push and pull factors directly shapes new settlement patterns, leading to various forms of migration and resulting demographic shifts.

Rural-Urban Migration

This is perhaps the most common form of migration globally. Push factors like landlessness, agricultural poverty, and lack of opportunities in rural areas drive people to urban centers, attracted by employment, education, and better living standards. This has led to the rapid growth of megacities in developing countries like India, China, and Brazil. According to the World Bank, 55% of the world’s population lives in urban areas as of 2023.

International Migration

Driven by significant economic and political disparities between countries, international migration involves movement across national borders. For instance, the migration of skilled workers from India and the Philippines to the United States and Europe is driven by better career prospects and higher salaries. Remittances sent by international migrants are a significant source of income for many developing countries.

Internal Displacement

This refers to the forced movement of people within their own country due to conflict, violence, or natural disasters. India has witnessed significant internal displacement due to Naxalite conflicts, ethnic tensions, and natural disasters like floods and cyclones. The displacement of people in Kashmir due to political instability is another example.

Counter-Urbanization & Amenity Migration

While most migration is towards urban areas, counter-urbanization – the movement of people from cities to rural areas – is also occurring in some developed countries. This is often driven by a desire for a quieter lifestyle, lower housing costs, and access to natural amenities. Amenity migration, where people move to attractive rural areas for recreational or lifestyle reasons, is also becoming increasingly common.

Migration Type Dominant Push Factors Dominant Pull Factors Resultant Settlement Pattern
Rural-Urban Agricultural distress, lack of rural employment Urban employment, better education Growth of cities, urban sprawl
International Political instability, economic hardship Economic opportunities, political freedom Diaspora communities, demographic shifts in host countries
Internal Displacement Conflict, natural disasters Perceived safety, access to aid Informal settlements, strain on resources in host areas

Conclusion

In conclusion, migration is a complex phenomenon deeply rooted in the interplay of push and pull factors. These factors, encompassing economic, political, social, and environmental dimensions, shape not only the decision to migrate but also the resulting settlement patterns. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for effective policy-making related to urban planning, resource allocation, and the integration of migrants. As global challenges like climate change and political instability intensify, migration patterns are likely to become even more complex, requiring proactive and nuanced approaches to manage their impacts and harness their potential benefits.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Chain Migration
Chain migration is the process where migrants follow family members or friends who have already established themselves in a new location.

Key Statistics

India received $111.22 billion in remittances in 2023, making it the top recipient globally.

Source: World Bank, Migration and Development Brief 36 (April 2024)

According to the UN, there were an estimated 281 million international migrants in the world in 2020.

Source: United Nations, International Migration Report 2020

Examples

The Kerala Model of Migration

Kerala, India, has a long history of international migration to the Gulf countries. Remittances from Keralite workers have played a crucial role in the state’s economic development and social progress.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does climate change influence migration?

Climate change acts as a significant ‘push’ factor, leading to displacement due to sea-level rise, extreme weather events, and resource scarcity. This is often referred to as ‘climate migration’ or ‘environmental migration.’

Topics Covered

GeographySociologyPopulation GeographyMigrationDemography