Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
Temple architecture in India is a testament to the country’s rich cultural and artistic heritage. Broadly, it can be categorized into two main styles: Nagara and Dravida. These styles, while both rooted in Hindu religious beliefs, developed distinct characteristics influenced by regional geography, materials available, and socio-political contexts. The Nagara style flourished in North India, while the Dravida style dominated South India. Understanding the differences between these two styles is fundamental to appreciating the diversity and evolution of Indian art and architecture. This answer will delineate these differences with representative examples.
Nagara and Dravida Styles: A Comparative Analysis
Both Nagara and Dravida styles share common ground in their underlying principles of temple design, reflecting the Hindu cosmology. However, their execution differs significantly.
1. Geographical Distribution and Historical Context
The Nagara style (meaning ‘city’) originated and evolved in North India, encompassing regions from the Himalayas to the Vindhyas. It reached its zenith between the 5th and 10th centuries AD, with variations emerging in different regions like Odisha (Kalinga style), Gujarat (Solanki style), and Rajasthan (Mandal style). The Dravida style, prevalent in South India, flourished from the 7th century AD onwards, with significant developments under the Pallavas, Cholas, Pandyas, and Vijayanagara empires.
2. Plan and Layout
Nagara temples typically follow a square plan, with the garbhagriha (sanctum sanctorum) at the center. This is often preceded by a mandapa (hall) and a ardhamandapa (intermediate hall). The entire structure is built on a raised platform called a jagati. Dravida temples also have a square plan, but they are characterized by a more complex layout with multiple enclosures (prakaras) surrounded by high walls. The gopurams (gateway towers) are a prominent feature, often taller than the main temple tower.
3. Shikhar (Tower)
This is perhaps the most distinguishing feature. The Nagara shikhar is curvilinear, rising gradually to a point. It is often referred to as a ‘shikhara’ and is crowned with a kalasha (finial). Different sub-styles exhibit variations – the Odisha style features a ‘rekha-deul’ with a pronounced curvilinear tower, while the Solanki style in Gujarat incorporates intricate carvings and miniature shrines. In contrast, the Dravida shikhar, known as a ‘vimana’, is pyramidal in shape, composed of diminishing tiers of receding blocks. It is capped by a dome-shaped structure called a stupi.
4. Ornamentation and Sculptures
Nagara temples generally feature more restrained ornamentation compared to Dravida temples. Sculptures are often integrated into the walls and pillars, depicting scenes from Hindu mythology and epics. The emphasis is on linear designs and geometric patterns. Dravida temples are renowned for their elaborate and profuse ornamentation. Sculptures are more numerous and dynamic, covering almost every surface. The pillars are often intricately carved with depictions of deities, mythical creatures, and floral motifs.
5. Materials Used
Nagara temples were primarily constructed using stone, although brick and wood were also employed, particularly in earlier phases. The availability of sandstone and marble influenced the architectural styles in different regions. Dravida temples predominantly used granite, which was readily available in South India. The use of granite allowed for the construction of massive structures and intricate carvings.
| Feature | Nagara Style | Dravida Style |
|---|---|---|
| Geographical Location | North India | South India |
| Plan | Square, with jagati | Square, with multiple prakaras |
| Shikhar | Curvilinear (shikhara) | Pyramidal (vimana) |
| Ornamentation | Restrained, linear designs | Elaborate, profuse sculptures |
| Materials | Stone, brick, wood | Granite |
| Examples | Khajuraho Temples, Sun Temple (Modhera), Lingaraja Temple (Bhubaneswar) | Brihadeeswarar Temple (Thanjavur), Meenakshi Amman Temple (Madurai), Shore Temple (Mahabalipuram) |
Examples: The Khajuraho temples (Nagara) are famous for their intricate sculptures and curvilinear shikharas. The Brihadeeswarar Temple in Thanjavur (Dravida) exemplifies the grandeur of the style with its massive vimana and elaborate gopurams. The Shore Temple at Mahabalipuram showcases early Dravida architecture, while the Lingaraja Temple in Bhubaneswar represents the Kalinga sub-style of Nagara architecture.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Nagara and Dravida styles of temple architecture represent distinct regional expressions of Indian artistic and religious traditions. While both styles share a common foundation in Hindu cosmology, they differ significantly in their plan, shikhar, ornamentation, and materials. These differences reflect the unique geographical, cultural, and historical contexts in which they evolved. Studying these styles provides valuable insights into the diversity and dynamism of Indian art and architecture, and their enduring legacy continues to inspire awe and reverence.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.