UPSC MainsMANAGEMENT-PAPER-II20225 Marks
Q13.

Define the terms 'work study' and 'method study'.

How to Approach

This question requires a clear and concise definition of 'work study' and 'method study', highlighting their individual characteristics and relationship. The answer should demonstrate an understanding of their importance in operations management and industrial engineering. A structured approach involving defining each term separately, outlining their objectives, techniques used, and finally, their interrelation will be effective. Focus on practical application and avoid overly theoretical explanations.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

In the realm of operations management, enhancing productivity and efficiency is paramount. Work study, a systematic examination and redesign of work methods, plays a crucial role in achieving these goals. It’s a foundational technique in industrial engineering, aiming to optimize processes and reduce wastage. Within work study lies method study, a specific component focused on analyzing and improving the way work is performed. Understanding the nuances of both these terms is essential for any aspiring manager or engineer seeking to improve organizational performance. This answer will delineate the definitions, objectives, and techniques associated with both work study and method study.

Work Study: A Comprehensive Overview

Work study is a technique which is used to examine work methods and to improve the efficiency of work. It is a systematic examination of the methods of carrying on operations and the conditions under which they are performed, in order to effect improvement. It’s a broad term encompassing a range of techniques, primarily method study and work measurement.

  • Objectives of Work Study:
    • Improve operational efficiency.
    • Reduce production costs.
    • Improve working conditions.
    • Enhance worker satisfaction.
    • Facilitate better planning and control.
  • Techniques used in Work Study:
    • Method Study
    • Work Measurement
    • Micro-motion study
    • Process charting
    • Operation research

Method Study: A Detailed Examination

Method study is the systematic recording, examination and improvement of existing and proposed work methods to optimize effectiveness and efficiency. It is a key component of work study, focusing specifically on the *way* work is done, rather than the time taken to do it (which is the focus of work measurement).

  • Objectives of Method Study:
    • Improve processes and procedures.
    • Eliminate unnecessary movements.
    • Simplify work content.
    • Standardize work practices.
    • Reduce fatigue and improve safety.
  • Techniques used in Method Study:
    • Process Charting: Visually representing the sequence of operations, transportations, inspections, delays, and storages.
    • Flow Diagrams: Illustrating the physical movement of materials and people.
    • String Diagrams: Mapping the path of movement of workers or materials.
    • Operation Research: Applying mathematical and analytical techniques to optimize processes.
    • 5S Methodology: Sort, Set in order, Shine, Standardize, Sustain – a system for organizing workspaces.

Work Study vs. Method Study: A Comparative Analysis

While closely related, work study and method study are not interchangeable. Method study is a *part* of work study. The following table highlights the key differences:

Feature Work Study Method Study
Scope Broader; includes method study and work measurement. Narrower; focuses solely on improving methods.
Focus Efficiency of work – both method and time. Efficiency of method – how work is done.
Techniques Method study, work measurement, micro-motion study, etc. Process charting, flow diagrams, string diagrams, 5S, etc.
Outcome Improved overall productivity and reduced costs. Improved work methods, reduced unnecessary movements, and standardized procedures.

For example, a manufacturing company might use method study to redesign the assembly line layout to minimize worker movement. Subsequently, work study, including work measurement, would be used to determine the standard time required for each task on the redesigned line, ensuring optimal efficiency.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both work study and method study are vital tools for optimizing operational efficiency. Work study provides a holistic approach to improving work systems, while method study focuses specifically on refining the methods used to perform tasks. Their combined application leads to streamlined processes, reduced costs, improved working conditions, and ultimately, enhanced organizational performance. As businesses increasingly focus on lean manufacturing and continuous improvement, the importance of these techniques will only continue to grow.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Work Measurement
The application of techniques to determine the time a healthy worker should take to complete a specified task at a defined rate of working.
Motion Study
The study of the movements used to perform a task, aiming to eliminate unnecessary motions and improve efficiency.

Key Statistics

According to a study by the Institute of Industrial Engineers, organizations that implement work study techniques can experience productivity gains of up to 20%.

Source: Institute of Industrial Engineers (Knowledge cutoff: 2023)

A report by McKinsey Global Institute estimates that automating and optimizing work processes, including through work study techniques, could boost global productivity by 0.8 to 1.4 percent annually.

Source: McKinsey Global Institute (Knowledge cutoff: 2023)

Examples

Toyota Production System (TPS)

Toyota’s success is largely attributed to its implementation of work study principles, particularly method study, to eliminate waste (Muda) and continuously improve its manufacturing processes. The focus on ‘Kaizen’ (continuous improvement) is a direct application of method study principles.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is work study applicable only to manufacturing industries?

No, work study principles can be applied to a wide range of industries, including service sectors like healthcare, banking, and education, to improve processes and efficiency.

Topics Covered

Operations ManagementIndustrial EngineeringManagementWork StudyMethod StudyEfficiency