UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II202320 Marks
Q7.

Give an account of seven different pairs of contrasting characters whose inheritance was studied by Mendel in Garden Pea (Pisum sativum). Give the reasons for Mendel's success in the study.

How to Approach

This question requires a clear understanding of Mendel's experiments and his laws of inheritance. The approach should be to first list the seven contrasting characters, detailing the dominant and recessive traits. Then, briefly explain Mendel's success, highlighting his meticulous methodology, quantitative approach, and the choice of Pisum sativum. A table can be used for clarity in presenting the contrasting characters. Finally, a concise conclusion summarizing Mendel’s contribution is crucial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Gregor Mendel, often hailed as the "father of genetics," laid the foundation for our understanding of heredity through his groundbreaking experiments with garden peas ( *Pisum sativum*) in the mid-19th century. His meticulous observations and quantitative analysis, published in 1865, revealed the principles of inheritance, which were largely overlooked until their rediscovery in 1900. Mendel selected seven easily distinguishable traits in pea plants, allowing him to track inheritance patterns across generations. This answer will detail these seven contrasting characters and discuss the key factors that contributed to Mendel’s remarkable success.

Mendel's Seven Contrasting Characters in Garden Pea (Pisum sativum)

Mendel carefully selected *Pisum sativum* for his experiments due to its distinct, easily observable traits and its ability to self-pollinate and cross-pollinate. He studied the inheritance of seven pairs of contrasting characters. Here’s a breakdown:
Character Dominant Trait Recessive Trait
Seed Shape Round (RR) Wrinkled (rr)
Seed Color Yellow (YY) Green (yy)
Cotyledon Color Yellow (YY) Green (yy)
Pod Shape Inflated (II) Constricted (ii)
Flower Color Purple (PP) White (pp)
Stem Length Tall (TT) Dwarf (tt)
Flower Position Axial (AA) Terminal (aa)

Each row in the table represents a contrasting pair of traits. The "Dominant Trait" appears in the F1 generation when a plant with two recessive alleles is crossed with a plant with two dominant alleles. The "Recessive Trait" only appears in the F2 generation, usually in a ratio of 1:3.

Reasons for Mendel's Success

Mendel’s success wasn’t merely a matter of chance; it was a result of his rigorous methodology and careful planning. Several factors contributed to his groundbreaking discoveries:
  • Choice of Plant Material: *Pisum sativum* was ideal. It exhibits clear contrasting traits, has a short generation time, is easy to cultivate, and can self-pollinate.
  • Large Sample Size: Mendel analyzed a large number of plants across multiple generations. This helped minimize the impact of chance variations and allowed him to identify consistent patterns. He tracked over 8,000 plants!
  • Controlling Pollination: He meticulously controlled pollination by manually cross-pollinating plants and preventing self-pollination. This ensured that the parental traits were accurately combined.
  • Quantitative Approach: Mendel used mathematical ratios to analyze his results, a novel approach at the time. He didn’t just observe; he quantified.
  • Focus on Single Traits: He studied one trait at a time, allowing him to isolate the inheritance patterns for each characteristic.
  • Careful Record Keeping: Mendel kept detailed records of his experiments, allowing him to analyze the data systematically.
  • Ignoring Environmental Influences: While not fully understanding the complexities of gene-environment interaction, he minimized the impact of environmental factors by ensuring consistent growing conditions.

Impact of Mendel’s Work

Mendel’s work, initially published in "Experiments on Plant Hybridization" (1865), remained largely unrecognized for over three decades. However, its rediscovery in 1900 by Hugo de Vries, Carl Correns, and Erich von Tschermak independently validated his findings and established him as the founder of genetics. His laws of segregation and independent assortment are fundamental principles in modern biology, impacting fields from agriculture to medicine.

DEFINITION Allele An allele is a variant form of a gene. Different alleles result in variations in inherited characteristics such as hair color or blood type. STATISTIC Mendel analyzed over 8,000 pea plants to establish his laws of inheritance. This large sample size contributed significantly to the reliability of his results. Mendel’s original publication, "Experiments on Plant Hybridization" (1865) EXAMPLE Modern Application: Crop Improvement Mendel's principles are directly applied in modern agriculture to develop crop varieties with desirable traits, such as disease resistance or increased yield. For example, breeders use selective breeding based on Mendelian inheritance to create high-yielding wheat varieties. FAQ Why didn’t Mendel’s work gain immediate recognition? Mendel’s work was published in a German botanical journal with limited circulation. The scientific community wasn't ready to accept his quantitative approach to heredity, and the concepts were too abstract for the prevailing biological theories of the time. SCHEME National Food Security Mission (NFSM) While not directly related to Mendel's work, NFSM exemplifies the application of genetic principles in agriculture to improve food production and nutritional security. It aims to increase rice, wheat, and maize production through improved varieties and better agronomic practices. 2007-08 CASE-STUDY Bt Cotton in India The introduction of Bt cotton in India, genetically engineered to be resistant to bollworms, demonstrates the practical application of genetic principles. While controversial, it highlights the potential of genetic modification to address agricultural challenges, based on understanding gene inheritance and expression. Increased cotton yield and reduced pesticide use in some regions, but also concerns regarding farmer debt and seed costs. DEFINITION Genotype Genotype refers to the genetic constitution of an organism. It is the combination of alleles an organism possesses for a specific trait. STATISTIC The rediscovery of Mendel’s work in 1900 occurred independently by Hugo de Vries, Carl Correns, and Erich von Tschermak. Historical accounts of the rediscovery of Mendel’s laws

Conclusion

Mendel’s meticulous experiments with garden peas revolutionized our understanding of heredity. His identification of seven contrasting characters and his rigorous quantitative approach laid the groundwork for the science of genetics. While initially overlooked, his laws of segregation and independent assortment remain cornerstones of modern biology, impacting diverse fields. The enduring legacy of Mendel’s work underscores the importance of careful observation, quantitative analysis, and a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom in scientific inquiry.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Topics Covered

BotanyGeneticsBiologyInheritanceMendelian GeneticsPlant Breeding