UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I202315 Marks
Q26.

Discuss the division of the novel, Tess of the d'Urbervilles into seven phases and how each phase signifies Tess's life and destiny.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of Thomas Hardy’s *Tess of the d'Urbervilles*. The approach should be to identify the seven phases as generally recognized by literary critics (though Hardy doesn’t explicitly label them), and then analyze how each phase contributes to the unfolding of Tess’s tragic destiny. Focus on the thematic significance of each phase – innocence, seduction, hardship, attempted redemption, despair, flight, and final capture – and how they collectively portray Tess as a victim of societal forces and fate. Structure the answer chronologically, dedicating a paragraph or two to each phase.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Thomas Hardy’s *Tess of the d'Urbervilles: A Pure Woman Faithfully Presented* (1891) is a landmark novel of Victorian literature, renowned for its unflinching portrayal of social hypocrisy and the plight of rural England. While Hardy doesn’t formally divide the novel into sections, critics commonly identify seven distinct phases in Tess Durbeyfield’s life, each marking a significant shift in her circumstances and contributing to her tragic fate. These phases aren’t merely chronological markers; they represent stages in Tess’s loss of innocence, her struggle against societal constraints, and her ultimate descent into despair. This answer will explore these seven phases and demonstrate how each one is integral to understanding Tess’s life and the deterministic forces that shape her destiny.

Phase 1: The Starlit Meadow & The Discovery of Her Pedigree (Chapters 1-7)

The novel begins with the idyllic scene of John Durbeyfield discovering his family’s noble ancestry, the d’Urbervilles. This initial phase establishes Tess’s rural background and the false hope that her lineage might improve their fortunes. It’s a period of relative innocence, but already foreshadows the disruption to come. The emphasis on the natural world contrasts sharply with the societal pressures that will later engulf Tess. This phase sets the stage for the tragedy by introducing the idea of a past that haunts the present.

Phase 2: The Temptation at the Flintcomb-Ash Farm (Chapters 8-14)

Sent to claim kinship with the wealthy d’Urberville family, Tess encounters Alec Stokes, who exploits her vulnerability and seduces her. This phase marks the loss of Tess’s innocence and the beginning of her suffering. The seduction isn’t presented as a willing act but as a consequence of Alec’s manipulative power and Tess’s naiveté. This phase is crucial in establishing Tess as a victim of circumstance and societal expectations regarding female sexuality.

Phase 3: Return to Talbothays & The Dairy Life (Chapters 15-23)

Tess finds temporary respite and happiness working at Talbothays Dairy. This phase represents a period of pastoral beauty and genuine connection, particularly with Angel Clare. It’s a time of hope and the possibility of redemption. However, the idyllic setting is constantly threatened by the shadow of her past. The dairy symbolizes purity and naturalness, a stark contrast to the corrupting influences she has already experienced.

Phase 4: The Confession & Angel’s Rejection (Chapters 24-31)

Tess, driven by a desire for honesty and a belief in Angel’s moral integrity, confesses her past to him on their wedding night. Angel’s subsequent rejection, rooted in his Victorian ideals of female purity, is a pivotal moment. This phase highlights the hypocrisy of societal standards and the double standards applied to men and women. Angel’s inability to accept Tess’s past condemns her to further suffering.

Phase 5: Alec’s Return & Tess’s Despair (Chapters 32-41)

Following Angel’s departure to Brazil, Tess is relentlessly pursued by Alec, who eventually forces himself upon her again. This phase marks Tess’s descent into utter despair and a sense of powerlessness. She is trapped between her love for Angel and the inescapable reality of her situation. Alec’s return symbolizes the enduring power of the past and the impossibility of escaping its consequences.

Phase 6: The Murder of Alec & Flight with Angel (Chapters 42-48)

Driven to desperation, Tess murders Alec in a desperate attempt to reclaim her agency and secure a future with Angel. This act, while morally ambiguous, is presented as a consequence of the relentless pressures she has faced. The subsequent flight with Angel offers a brief period of happiness, but it is overshadowed by the knowledge of her crime and the inevitability of capture. This phase represents Tess’s final, desperate attempt to control her own destiny.

Phase 7: Arrest, Imprisonment & Execution (Chapters 49-54)

The final phase culminates in Tess’s arrest at Stonehenge, a site steeped in ancient history and symbolic of pagan beliefs. Her execution, despite Angel’s belated attempts to intervene, underscores the unforgiving nature of Victorian justice and the deterministic forces that have shaped her life. This phase serves as a powerful indictment of societal hypocrisy and the tragic consequences of rigid moral codes. The setting at Stonehenge suggests a return to a pre-Christian, more accepting worldview, highlighting the injustice of her fate.

Conclusion

The seven phases of *Tess of the d'Urbervilles* are not merely a narrative structure but a carefully crafted progression that reveals the systematic dismantling of Tess’s life and spirit. Each phase contributes to the novel’s central themes of fate, social injustice, and the plight of women in Victorian society. Hardy’s masterful use of these phases allows him to present Tess not as a fallen woman, but as a victim of circumstances beyond her control, ultimately challenging the reader to question the moral foundations of the society in which she lived. The novel remains a powerful and enduring testament to the destructive consequences of societal hypocrisy and the enduring power of fate.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Victorian Morality
A set of strict social and sexual codes prevalent in Victorian England (1837-1901), emphasizing duty, thrift, respectability, and sexual restraint, particularly for women.
Determinism
The philosophical belief that all events are ultimately determined by causes external to the will and are beyond our control. This is a key theme in *Tess of the d'Urbervilles*.

Key Statistics

In the late 19th century, the illegitimacy rate in rural England was significantly higher than in urban areas, reflecting the social and economic pressures faced by unmarried mothers.

Source: Various historical demographic studies (knowledge cutoff 2021)

Approximately 20% of births in England and Wales in the late 19th century were illegitimate, indicating the prevalence of out-of-wedlock pregnancies and the social stigma associated with them.

Source: Historical records from the General Register Office (knowledge cutoff 2021)

Examples

The New Woman Movement

The "New Woman" movement of the late 19th century challenged traditional gender roles and advocated for greater educational and economic opportunities for women, a context relevant to understanding Tess’s struggle for independence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Stonehenge significant in the novel?

Stonehenge represents a connection to a pre-Christian past, a time when societal norms were different and perhaps more accepting. Tess’s arrest there symbolizes a return to ancient, pagan beliefs and highlights the injustice of her fate within the rigid framework of Victorian society.

Topics Covered

LiteratureHistoryVictorian Literature, Narrative Structure, Feminist Literature