UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-II202310 Marks150 Words
Q1.

Hearts with one purpose alone Through summer and winter seem Enchanted to a stone To trouble the living stream.

How to Approach

This question requires a literary analysis of the provided stanza. The approach should focus on identifying the central theme, imagery, and poetic devices employed. The answer should demonstrate an understanding of the metaphorical language used and its potential interpretations. Structure the answer by first identifying the core idea, then elaborating on the symbolism within the lines, and finally, offering a concise conclusion summarizing the overall meaning. Focus on the contrast presented between the 'hearts' and the 'living stream'.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The provided stanza, evocative in its imagery, presents a poignant reflection on the potential for human connection to become stagnant and detached from the natural flow of life. The lines speak to a state of emotional or spiritual inertia, where individuals, despite possessing shared feelings ("Hearts with one purpose alone"), become "enchanted to a stone," losing their vitality and ability to interact with the dynamic world around them. The 'living stream' symbolizes life's continuous movement and change, and the stanza explores the tragic consequences of resisting this flow. This analysis will delve into the symbolism and meaning embedded within these verses.

Central Theme: Stagnation and Detachment

The overarching theme of the stanza is the danger of emotional or spiritual stagnation. The 'hearts with one purpose alone' suggest a shared bond, perhaps love, ambition, or ideology. However, this unity, rather than fostering growth, leads to a rigid fixation, symbolized by being "enchanted to a stone." This enchantment implies a loss of agency and a surrender to a fixed state, hindering the natural progression of life.

Symbolism of Key Elements

The 'Hearts'

The 'hearts' represent the emotional core of individuals, their capacity for feeling and connection. The phrase "with one purpose alone" suggests a focused intensity, but also a potential for narrowness. This singular focus, if unchecked, can lead to an inward turning, isolating the hearts from external influences.

The 'Stone'

The 'stone' is a powerful symbol of immobility, coldness, and lifelessness. To be "enchanted to a stone" signifies a complete loss of vitality and responsiveness. It suggests a hardening of emotions, a refusal to adapt or change, and a detachment from the natural world. The enchantment implies a self-imposed state, a willing surrender to this stagnation.

The 'Living Stream'

The 'living stream' represents the continuous flow of life, encompassing change, growth, and interaction. It symbolizes the dynamic forces that shape our experiences and the importance of remaining open to new possibilities. The hearts' inability to trouble the stream suggests their failure to engage with life's currents, remaining passive observers rather than active participants.

Poetic Devices and their Impact

  • Metaphor: The entire stanza is built upon extended metaphors, comparing hearts to stones and life to a stream.
  • Imagery: The vivid imagery of stone and water creates a strong sensory experience, reinforcing the contrast between stagnation and flow.
  • Alliteration: The repetition of sounds, though subtle, contributes to the musicality of the verse and emphasizes key phrases.

Interpretations and Context

The stanza can be interpreted in various ways. It could represent a critique of rigid ideologies that stifle individual expression, or a lament for lost love that has become frozen in time. It could also be a broader commentary on the human tendency to cling to the past, resisting the inevitable changes of life. The lack of specific context allows for a universal application of its themes.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the stanza powerfully conveys the dangers of emotional and spiritual stagnation. Through evocative imagery and metaphorical language, it highlights the importance of remaining open to change and actively engaging with the 'living stream' of life. The 'hearts enchanted to a stone' serve as a cautionary tale, reminding us that a singular purpose, if pursued without flexibility and connection, can lead to a profound sense of detachment and loss of vitality.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Metaphor
A figure of speech that directly compares two unlike things without using "like" or "as," suggesting a resemblance or shared quality.
Imagery
The use of vivid and descriptive language to create mental images and appeal to the reader's senses.

Key Statistics

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), globally, over 280 million people suffer from depression (as of 2023).

Source: World Health Organization (WHO), 2023

Studies show that prolonged social isolation can increase the risk of premature mortality by 26% (Holt-Lunstad et al., 2015).

Source: Holt-Lunstad, J., et al. (2015). Loneliness and social isolation as predictors of mortality.

Examples

The Statue of Liberty

The Statue of Liberty, while a symbol of freedom, can also be seen as a 'stone' in the context of the stanza – a fixed, unchanging monument observing the 'living stream' of immigrants passing by.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does "enchanted" mean in this context?

“Enchanted” doesn’t imply a positive spell, but rather a captivated or spellbound state, suggesting a loss of free will and a surrender to a fixed condition. It’s a passive state, not one of joyful magic.