UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-I202315 Marks
Q13.

Differentiate between the characteristics of organic horizons and mineral horizons in a generalised soil profile.

How to Approach

This question requires a comparative analysis of organic and mineral horizons within a soil profile. The answer should begin by defining soil horizons and then systematically differentiate between the two types, focusing on their composition, formation, characteristics, and significance. A tabular format will be useful for highlighting the key differences. The answer should demonstrate an understanding of pedology and soil science principles.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Soil, a vital natural resource, is not a homogenous mass but a layered structure known as a soil profile. This profile consists of distinct horizontal layers called horizons. These horizons are formed through processes of weathering, leaching, and accumulation over time. Broadly, soil horizons are categorized into organic and mineral horizons. Organic horizons are primarily composed of decomposing organic matter, while mineral horizons are dominated by weathered rock particles. Understanding the characteristics of these horizons is crucial for assessing soil fertility, water-holding capacity, and overall soil health, impacting agricultural productivity and ecosystem functioning.

Organic Horizons (O, A)

Organic horizons are found at the surface of the soil profile and are characterized by a high content of organic matter in various stages of decomposition. They are typically darker in color due to the presence of humus. These horizons are crucial for nutrient cycling and soil structure.

Types of Organic Horizons:

  • O Horizon: This is the uppermost layer, consisting of relatively undecomposed organic material like leaves, twigs, and dead organisms. It’s often found in forests and undisturbed ecosystems.
  • A Horizon: Also known as topsoil, this horizon is a mixture of mineral particles and humus. It’s typically dark-colored, fertile, and supports plant growth.

Characteristics of Organic Horizons:

  • Composition: Primarily composed of organic matter (humus, partially decomposed organisms), with some mineral particles.
  • Color: Dark brown to black due to the presence of humus.
  • Structure: Loose and granular, providing good aeration and drainage.
  • Nutrient Content: High in essential plant nutrients like nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium.
  • Water Holding Capacity: Excellent due to the high organic matter content.

Mineral Horizons (E, B, C, R)

Mineral horizons are formed from weathered rock material and are classified based on their composition and characteristics. They lie beneath the organic horizons and represent different stages of weathering and soil development.

Types of Mineral Horizons:

  • E Horizon: An eluvial horizon, characterized by the leaching of clay, iron, and aluminum oxides, resulting in a light-colored layer. Often found beneath the A horizon in acidic soils.
  • B Horizon: Also known as the subsoil, this horizon is a zone of accumulation where materials leached from the E horizon are deposited. It often has a reddish or brownish color due to the accumulation of iron and aluminum oxides.
  • C Horizon: The parent material horizon, consisting of partially weathered bedrock. It shows evidence of weathering but retains the characteristics of the original rock.
  • R Horizon: The bedrock horizon, representing the unweathered parent material.

Characteristics of Mineral Horizons:

  • Composition: Primarily composed of weathered rock particles (sand, silt, clay) and mineral oxides.
  • Color: Varies depending on the mineral composition, ranging from light gray to reddish-brown.
  • Structure: Can be granular, blocky, prismatic, or platy, depending on the particle size and degree of weathering.
  • Nutrient Content: Generally lower than organic horizons, but can vary depending on the parent material.
  • Water Holding Capacity: Lower than organic horizons, but varies with particle size and structure.

Comparative Table: Organic vs. Mineral Horizons

Feature Organic Horizons (O, A) Mineral Horizons (E, B, C, R)
Composition High organic matter (humus), some minerals Weathered rock particles (sand, silt, clay), mineral oxides
Color Dark brown to black Light gray to reddish-brown (variable)
Structure Loose, granular Granular, blocky, prismatic, platy (variable)
Nutrient Content High Low to moderate (variable)
Water Holding Capacity Excellent Moderate to low (variable)
Location Surface layers Beneath organic horizons

Conclusion

In conclusion, organic and mineral horizons represent distinct stages in soil development and possess unique characteristics. Organic horizons are rich in nutrients and support plant growth, while mineral horizons provide the structural foundation and contribute to the overall soil profile. Understanding the differences between these horizons is fundamental to comprehending soil processes, assessing soil quality, and managing land resources sustainably. The interplay between these horizons dictates the soil’s ability to support life and function as a critical component of the Earth’s ecosystems.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Humus
Humus is the dark, organic material in soil that is formed by the decomposition of plant and animal matter. It is a stable, complex substance that improves soil structure, water-holding capacity, and nutrient availability.
Pedology
Pedology is the study of soils in their natural environment, encompassing their formation, classification, and properties.

Key Statistics

Approximately 95% of plant nutrients are derived from the soil, highlighting its critical role in food production. (FAO, 2015 - Knowledge Cutoff)

Source: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO)

Globally, approximately one-third of the world’s soils are degraded, impacting food security and ecosystem services. (UNCCD, 2018 - Knowledge Cutoff)

Source: United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD)

Examples

Chernozem Soils

Chernozem soils, found in regions like Russia and Ukraine, are characterized by a thick, dark A horizon rich in humus, making them exceptionally fertile for agriculture.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the E horizon?

The E horizon indicates intensive weathering and leaching, often in humid climates. Its presence suggests that the soil is relatively young or has undergone significant alteration, impacting its fertility and water-holding capacity.

Topics Covered

GeographyAgricultureEnvironmentSoil ScienceSoil CompositionPedology