UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II202320 Marks
Q26.

Discuss the causes of various seismic discontinuities in the upper mantle.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of the Earth's internal structure, specifically the upper mantle, and the geophysical phenomena causing seismic discontinuities. The answer should focus on explaining the causes – compositional changes, phase transitions, and thermal variations – behind these discontinuities. A structured approach, detailing each discontinuity (Mohorovičić, Lehmann, Gutenberg, etc.) and its associated cause, is recommended. Include relevant geophysical evidence supporting these causes.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Seismic discontinuities represent abrupt changes in seismic wave velocities within the Earth’s interior. These changes provide crucial insights into the layering and composition of our planet. The upper mantle, extending from the base of the crust (Mohorovičić discontinuity) to approximately 660 km depth, exhibits several such discontinuities. These are not sharp boundaries but rather transition zones where physical and chemical properties change significantly. Understanding the causes of these discontinuities is fundamental to deciphering the dynamic processes occurring within the Earth, including mantle convection and plate tectonics.

Causes of Seismic Discontinuities in the Upper Mantle

The upper mantle exhibits several key seismic discontinuities, each arising from distinct causes. These can be broadly categorized into compositional changes, phase transitions, and thermal variations.

1. Mohorovičić Discontinuity (Moho) – ~30-70 km depth

This is the boundary between the Earth’s crust and the mantle. The primary cause is a change in composition. The crust, being largely composed of lighter silicate minerals (granitic and basaltic rocks), overlies the denser peridotite mantle. This compositional contrast leads to a significant increase in seismic wave velocity as waves enter the mantle.

2. Lehmann Discontinuity – ~220 km depth

This discontinuity is less pronounced and its existence is debated. It’s thought to be caused by a phase transition in olivine, the dominant mineral in the upper mantle. At this depth, increasing pressure and temperature cause olivine to transform from α-olivine to β-olivine. This phase change results in a slight increase in density and seismic velocity.

3. Gutenberg Discontinuity – ~660 km depth

This is a major discontinuity marking the boundary between the upper and lower mantle. The primary cause is a phase transition. At this depth, the mineral ringwoodite (a high-pressure polymorph of olivine) undergoes a further phase transition to perovskite and magnesiowüstite. This transition is accompanied by a substantial increase in density and seismic velocity. The endothermic nature of this transition (requiring energy input) also plays a role in mantle dynamics.

4. Discontinuities at ~410 km depth

This discontinuity is caused by the phase transition of olivine to wadsleyite. Similar to the Lehmann discontinuity, this transition is driven by increasing pressure and temperature. Wadsleyite is denser than olivine, leading to an increase in seismic wave velocity. This discontinuity is more consistently observed than the Lehmann discontinuity.

5. Other Minor Discontinuities

  • Thermal Variations: Localized temperature anomalies, such as those associated with mantle plumes or subducting slabs, can cause smaller-scale discontinuities.
  • Partial Melting: The presence of even small amounts of partial melt in the asthenosphere (a partially molten layer within the upper mantle) can significantly reduce seismic wave velocities, creating a discontinuity.
  • Water Content: The presence of water in mantle minerals can also affect their physical properties and contribute to discontinuities. Water lowers the temperature of phase transitions.

Geophysical Evidence: These discontinuities are identified through the analysis of seismic wave travel times and amplitudes. Sudden changes in these parameters indicate a change in the properties of the Earth’s interior. Seismic tomography, which uses seismic waves to create 3D images of the Earth’s interior, provides further evidence for the existence and characteristics of these discontinuities.

Discontinuity Depth (km) Primary Cause Mineralogical Change
Mohorovičić 30-70 Compositional Change Crust (Granite/Basalt) to Mantle (Peridotite)
Lehmann 220 Phase Transition α-Olivine to β-Olivine
~410 410 Phase Transition Olivine to Wadsleyite
Gutenberg 660 Phase Transition Ringwoodite to Perovskite + Magnesiowüstite

Conclusion

Seismic discontinuities in the upper mantle are vital indicators of the Earth’s internal structure and dynamics. They are primarily caused by compositional changes and, more significantly, by phase transitions in mantle minerals due to increasing pressure and temperature. These discontinuities influence mantle convection, plate tectonics, and the overall evolution of our planet. Further research, utilizing advanced seismic techniques and laboratory experiments, is crucial for refining our understanding of these complex phenomena and their role in Earth’s processes.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Seismic Discontinuity
An abrupt change in the velocity or density of seismic waves as they travel through the Earth’s interior, indicating a change in the composition or physical state of the material.
Endothermic Phase Transition
A phase transition that requires the absorption of heat to occur. The Gutenberg discontinuity involves an endothermic transition, meaning it absorbs heat from the surrounding mantle, potentially influencing mantle convection patterns.

Key Statistics

The Gutenberg discontinuity at 660 km depth is associated with a ~3-5% increase in seismic wave velocity.

Source: Lay, T., & Wallace, T. C. (1995). *Modern Global Seismology*.

Approximately 70% of the Earth’s volume is composed of minerals that undergo phase transitions within the upper mantle.

Source: Knowledge cutoff: 2023

Examples

Iceland Plume

The Iceland plume, a mantle upwelling, causes localized thermal anomalies and variations in seismic wave velocities, resulting in observable discontinuities in the upper mantle beneath Iceland.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do phase transitions affect seismic wave velocity?

Phase transitions typically involve changes in density. Denser materials generally lead to higher seismic wave velocities, as the waves travel more efficiently through them. The specific change in velocity depends on the magnitude of the density change and the type of seismic wave.

Topics Covered

GeologyGeophysicsEarth StructureSeismologyMantle Dynamics