UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-II202415 Marks
Q18.

Explain how mass selection will be of help in a successful breeding program. Elaborate the answer with a suitable example.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of plant breeding methods, specifically mass selection. The answer should define mass selection, explain its process, highlight its advantages and limitations, and then illustrate its application with a concrete example. Structure the answer by first defining mass selection, then detailing the steps involved, followed by its benefits and drawbacks, and finally, providing a well-explained example. Focus on how it contributes to a successful breeding program.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Plant breeding is a crucial aspect of agriculture, aimed at improving crop characteristics like yield, disease resistance, and nutritional value. Among the various breeding methods, mass selection stands out as one of the oldest and simplest techniques. It involves selecting a large number of plants with desirable traits from a mixed population and using their seeds to create the next generation. This method, while basic, can be remarkably effective in improving crop performance, particularly in self-pollinated crops, and forms a foundational step in many successful breeding programs. Understanding its principles and application is therefore essential for aspiring botanists and agricultural scientists.

Understanding Mass Selection

Mass selection is a method of crop improvement where superior plants are chosen from a mixed population based on their overall phenotype (observable characteristics). The seeds collected from these selected plants are then bulked together and used to grow the next generation. This process is repeated over several generations, gradually improving the desired traits in the population. It’s particularly effective when the desired trait is governed by polygenes – multiple genes with small, additive effects.

Steps Involved in Mass Selection

  1. Population Establishment: Begin with a diverse population of the crop species.
  2. Phenotypic Observation: Carefully observe and evaluate individual plants within the population for the desired traits (e.g., yield, disease resistance, grain quality).
  3. Selection of Superior Plants: Identify and select plants exhibiting the most desirable combination of traits. The number of selected plants depends on the population size and the heritability of the traits.
  4. Seed Collection and Bulking: Collect seeds from the selected plants and mix them together to create a composite seed sample.
  5. Repetition: Repeat the process of observation, selection, and seed collection for multiple generations (typically 5-10) to achieve significant improvement.

Advantages of Mass Selection

  • Simplicity: It is a relatively simple and inexpensive method, requiring minimal equipment and expertise.
  • Effectiveness in Self-Pollinated Crops: Highly effective in self-pollinated crops where genetic recombination is limited, preserving the desirable traits.
  • Broad Genetic Base: Maintains a broader genetic base compared to other methods like pedigree selection, reducing the risk of inbreeding depression.
  • Adaptability: Can be easily adapted to local conditions and farmer preferences.

Limitations of Mass Selection

  • Environmental Influence: Phenotypic expression can be influenced by environmental factors, leading to inaccurate selection.
  • Lack of Controlled Crossing: Does not involve controlled crossing, so the genetic gains per generation are relatively slow.
  • Difficulty in Selecting for Multiple Traits: Selecting for multiple traits simultaneously can be challenging, as some traits may be negatively correlated.
  • Ineffective in Cross-Pollinated Crops: Less effective in cross-pollinated crops due to high levels of genetic recombination.

Example: Improving Wheat Yield in India

Historically, mass selection played a vital role in improving wheat varieties in India. In the early 20th century, Indian wheat yields were low due to the presence of numerous local landraces with varying characteristics. Researchers at the Indian Agricultural Research Institute (IARI) initiated mass selection programs using locally adapted wheat varieties. They selected plants with high grain yield, bold seeds, and resistance to common wheat diseases like rust. Over several generations of mass selection, they developed improved wheat varieties like ‘NP 204’ (released in 1963) which contributed significantly to the Green Revolution in India. NP 204, though later superseded by high-yielding semi-dwarf varieties, demonstrated the power of mass selection in enhancing yield potential. The process involved repeatedly selecting the best-performing plants from large populations and using their seeds for subsequent generations. This resulted in a gradual increase in average grain yield and improved adaptation to Indian growing conditions.

Mass Selection vs. Other Breeding Methods

Feature Mass Selection Pedigree Selection Pure Line Selection
Crossing No controlled crossing Controlled crossing followed by selection Selection from homozygous lines
Genetic Recombination Limited High None
Effectiveness Self-pollinated crops Both self & cross-pollinated Self-pollinated crops
Complexity Simple Complex Moderate

Conclusion

Mass selection, despite its simplicity, remains a valuable tool in plant breeding, particularly for initial improvement in self-pollinated crops. While it may not offer the rapid gains of more sophisticated methods, its ease of implementation and ability to maintain genetic diversity make it a crucial first step in many breeding programs. Its historical success, as exemplified by the improvement of wheat varieties in India, underscores its continued relevance in enhancing crop productivity and ensuring food security. Modern breeding programs often integrate mass selection with other techniques to maximize genetic gains.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Phenotype
The observable characteristics of an organism resulting from the interaction of its genotype with the environment.
Polygenes
Genes that contribute to a quantitative trait, each having a small individual effect. Their combined action determines the overall phenotype.

Key Statistics

India's wheat production increased from around 11 million tonnes in 1960 to over 107 million tonnes in 2023.

Source: USDA, 2023 (Knowledge Cutoff: Dec 2023)

The Green Revolution, largely facilitated by improved wheat varieties, increased cereal production in India by over 50% between 1960 and 1980.

Source: Swaminathan, M.S. (1993). Sustainable Agriculture and Food Security.

Examples

Rice Improvement in Japan

In Japan, mass selection was extensively used to improve rice varieties, focusing on traits like grain size, shape, and cooking quality. This led to the development of several popular Japanese rice cultivars.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is mass selection still relevant in modern plant breeding?

Yes, mass selection is still relevant, especially as a preliminary step in breeding programs or for maintaining genetic diversity in local landraces. It can be combined with other techniques like marker-assisted selection for more efficient improvement.