UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-I202415 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q24.

What is Transnationalism? Why has the scale and scope of transnational linkages of diaspora multiplied in recent times?

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of transnationalism and the factors driving increased diaspora linkages. The answer should begin by defining transnationalism, differentiating it from traditional migration patterns. Then, it should explore the reasons for the increased scale and scope of these linkages, focusing on globalization, technological advancements, political and economic factors, and the evolving identities of diasporas. A structured approach, dividing the answer into sections addressing each factor, will be most effective. Examples of specific diasporas and their linkages should be included to illustrate the points.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Transnationalism, in its broadest sense, refers to the processes by which immigrants forge and sustain simultaneous multiple ties to their home and host societies. It moves beyond the traditional assimilation model of migration, emphasizing the maintenance of cross-border connections and the creation of social fields that transcend national boundaries. In recent decades, the scale and scope of these transnational linkages, particularly those involving diasporas, have dramatically increased. This surge is not merely a quantitative expansion of migration flows but a qualitative shift in the nature of diaspora engagement, driven by a confluence of globalizing forces and evolving socio-political dynamics.

Understanding Transnationalism

Traditionally, migration was often viewed as a one-way process leading to assimilation into the host country. Transnationalism challenges this view, highlighting the sustained connections migrants maintain with their countries of origin. These connections manifest in various forms, including remittances, return migration, political activism, cultural exchange, and the creation of transnational social networks. It’s important to distinguish transnationalism from simple international interaction; it specifically refers to the sustained, reciprocal relationships maintained *by* migrants across borders.

Factors Multiplying Diaspora Linkages

1. Globalization and Economic Interdependence

Globalization has significantly lowered the costs of communication and transportation, making it easier and cheaper for diasporas to maintain ties with their homelands. Increased trade and investment flows between countries also create economic incentives for diaspora engagement. For example, the Indian diaspora’s significant role in funding Indian startups and contributing to India’s economic growth demonstrates this economic interdependence. Remittances, a key component of transnational linkages, have increased exponentially. According to the World Bank, global remittances reached $838 billion in 2022 (as of knowledge cutoff 2023).

2. Technological Advancements

The proliferation of information and communication technologies (ICTs), such as the internet, mobile phones, and social media, has revolutionized diaspora linkages. These technologies enable instant communication, facilitate the sharing of information and cultural practices, and foster a sense of community among diaspora members regardless of geographical distance. Social media platforms like Facebook and WhatsApp are frequently used by diasporas to organize events, share news, and maintain social connections.

3. Political Factors and Diaspora Activism

Political instability, conflict, and persecution in home countries often motivate diasporas to become politically active in their host countries, advocating for policy changes and providing support to their communities back home. Diasporas can also play a crucial role in post-conflict reconstruction and peacebuilding efforts. The Tamil diaspora’s involvement in advocating for human rights in Sri Lanka and providing humanitarian assistance is a notable example. Furthermore, dual citizenship policies, adopted by many countries, facilitate political participation and strengthen transnational ties.

4. Evolving Identities and Transnational Social Fields

Diaspora identities are increasingly becoming fluid and multifaceted, encompassing both their heritage and their experiences in the host country. This leads to the creation of transnational social fields – networks of social relations that link migrants to both their home and host societies. These fields provide emotional, social, and economic support, and facilitate the exchange of ideas and cultural practices. The Cuban-American community in Miami, maintaining strong cultural and economic ties with Cuba despite political tensions, exemplifies this phenomenon.

5. Increased Migration Flows & Diversification of Destinations

The sheer increase in the number of international migrants has naturally led to larger and more diverse diasporas. Furthermore, migration patterns are no longer limited to traditional destinations. The rise of new economic hubs and opportunities in countries like the UAE, Singapore, and Canada has attracted migrants from diverse backgrounds, creating new diaspora communities and expanding the scope of transnational linkages.

Examples of Strong Transnational Linkages

  • Chinese Diaspora: Plays a significant role in China’s economic development through investment, trade, and technology transfer.
  • Indian Diaspora: A major source of remittances and foreign investment for India, also actively involved in philanthropy and cultural exchange.
  • Lebanese Diaspora: Historically played a crucial role in financing and supporting Lebanon’s economy and political landscape.
  • Irish Diaspora: Strong cultural and political ties with Ireland, contributing significantly to Irish identity and influencing US-Ireland relations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the multiplication of transnational linkages of diaspora in recent times is a complex phenomenon driven by the forces of globalization, technological advancements, political factors, and evolving identities. These linkages are not merely about maintaining ties to the past but about actively shaping the present and future of both home and host societies. Understanding the dynamics of transnationalism is crucial for policymakers seeking to harness the potential of diasporas for economic development, political engagement, and cultural exchange. Further research is needed to explore the long-term implications of these trends and to develop policies that promote inclusive and mutually beneficial transnational relationships.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Diaspora
A diaspora refers to a scattered population living outside their original homeland, often maintaining a sense of collective identity and connection to their ancestral territory.

Key Statistics

In 2020, the number of international migrants worldwide reached 281 million, representing 3.6% of the global population.

Source: United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2020)

India received $89.129 billion in remittances in 2021, making it the top recipient globally.

Source: World Bank (2022)

Examples

Kerala and the Gulf Diaspora

The state of Kerala in India is heavily reliant on remittances from its diaspora working in the Gulf countries. These remittances contribute significantly to Kerala’s economy and have played a crucial role in improving the state’s social indicators.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does transnationalism differ from assimilation?

Assimilation implies a complete absorption into the host society, often leading to the abandonment of original cultural practices and identities. Transnationalism, on the other hand, emphasizes the maintenance of multiple ties and identities, fostering a sense of belonging to both home and host societies.

Topics Covered

GeographyHuman GeographyMigrationGlobalizationDiaspora