UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-II202410 Marks
Q3.

North-Eastern States of India are geopolitically sensitive and strategically significant. Explain.

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer, drawing from geography, polity, and international relations. The approach should be to first define geopolitical sensitivity and strategic significance in the context of the North-Eastern states. Then, elaborate on the geographical factors, ethnic diversity, border disputes, socio-economic challenges, and external influences that contribute to this sensitivity and significance. Finally, discuss the implications for India’s security and regional cooperation. Structure the answer into sections covering geographical vulnerabilities, political complexities, strategic importance, and recent developments.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The North-Eastern States (NES) of India, comprising Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, and Tripura, occupy a unique position in the country. Characterized by complex topography, ethnic diversity, and porous borders, the region is both geopolitically sensitive and strategically significant for India. Recent developments like the ongoing border disputes with China, the influx of refugees from Myanmar, and the rise of insurgent groups underscore the region’s vulnerability. Understanding the interplay of geographical, political, and socio-economic factors is crucial to appreciating the region’s importance in India’s national security and its role in regional connectivity.

Geographical Vulnerabilities

The NES are geographically vulnerable due to their terrain and location:

  • Difficult Terrain: The region is largely mountainous and covered with dense forests, making it difficult for security forces to operate and control. This terrain also facilitates cross-border movement of insurgents and illegal migrants.
  • ‘Chicken’s Neck’ (Siliguri Corridor): A narrow land strip connecting the NES to the rest of India, the Siliguri Corridor is strategically vulnerable. Disruption of this corridor could isolate the region.
  • Porous Borders: The NES share borders with Bangladesh, Myanmar, China, and Bhutan. These borders are largely unfenced and porous, facilitating illegal activities like smuggling, arms trafficking, and infiltration.
  • Seismic Activity: The region is prone to earthquakes, adding to its vulnerability and hindering development.

Political Complexities

The political landscape of the NES is marked by several complexities:

  • Ethnic Diversity & Insurgency: The region is home to numerous ethnic groups, many of whom have historically felt marginalized. This has led to the rise of various insurgent groups demanding greater autonomy or secession. (e.g., NSCN-IM in Nagaland, ULFA in Assam).
  • Inter-State Disputes: Boundary disputes between the NES themselves are a major source of tension and conflict. (e.g., Assam-Meghalaya border dispute, Assam-Nagaland border dispute).
  • Illegal Immigration: Influx of illegal immigrants, particularly from Bangladesh, has altered the demographic profile of some states, leading to social and political tensions.
  • Governance Challenges: Remote location, poor infrastructure, and limited capacity of state governments pose challenges to effective governance.

Strategic Importance

Despite the challenges, the NES hold immense strategic importance for India:

  • Border Security: The region is crucial for securing India’s borders with China, Myanmar, and Bangladesh.
  • Act East Policy: The NES are the gateway to Southeast Asia, making them vital for India’s ‘Act East’ Policy, aimed at enhancing economic and strategic ties with the region.
  • Connectivity Hub: The region has the potential to become a major connectivity hub, linking India to Southeast Asia through road, rail, and riverine routes. (e.g., Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project).
  • Resource Rich: The NES are rich in natural resources, including oil, natural gas, coal, and hydropower.
  • Counter-Terrorism: The region is a potential base for terrorist groups operating in South Asia.

Recent Developments & External Influences

Recent developments have further heightened the geopolitical sensitivity of the region:

  • China’s Growing Influence: China’s increasing economic and political influence in Myanmar and Bangladesh raises concerns about its potential to destabilize the region.
  • Myanmar Crisis: The political crisis in Myanmar has led to a large influx of refugees into the NES, particularly Mizoram, posing humanitarian and security challenges.
  • Border Infrastructure Development: India is accelerating infrastructure development along its borders with China, including roads, bridges, and airfields, to improve connectivity and enhance security.
  • Peace Talks with Insurgent Groups: The government is engaged in peace talks with several insurgent groups, aiming to bring lasting peace and stability to the region. (e.g., Naga peace talks).
State Bordering Countries Key Issues
Arunachal Pradesh China, Myanmar Border disputes with China, infrastructure development
Nagaland Myanmar, India (Assam, Manipur) Naga insurgency, peace talks, inter-state disputes
Manipur Myanmar, India (Nagaland, Mizoram) Insurgency, ethnic conflicts, drug trafficking

Conclusion

The North-Eastern States of India are undeniably geopolitically sensitive and strategically significant. Their unique geographical location, ethnic diversity, and porous borders present both challenges and opportunities. Addressing the socio-economic grievances of the local population, strengthening border security, fostering regional cooperation, and pursuing a balanced approach towards China are crucial for ensuring peace, stability, and prosperity in the region. A holistic and integrated approach, combining security measures with development initiatives, is essential to unlock the full potential of the NES and integrate them more effectively into the Indian mainstream.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Geopolitical Sensitivity
Refers to a region's vulnerability to political instability due to its strategic location, complex internal dynamics, and external influences. It implies a high degree of risk and potential for conflict.
Act East Policy
India’s policy focused on strengthening economic and strategic ties with countries in Southeast Asia, aiming to promote connectivity, trade, and cultural exchange.

Key Statistics

As of 2023, approximately 3.5 million internally displaced persons (IDPs) were reported in Myanmar, many of whom sought refuge in the North-Eastern states of India, particularly Mizoram.

Source: UNHCR (as of knowledge cutoff - Sept 2023)

The total length of the India-Myanmar border is approximately 1,643 km, and a significant portion of it remains unfenced as of 2023.

Source: Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (as of knowledge cutoff - Sept 2023)

Examples

Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project

This project, jointly undertaken by India and Myanmar, aims to connect the Indian mainland to the Sittwe port in Myanmar, providing an alternative route for trade and transportation to the NES, bypassing the Siliguri Corridor.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the Naga peace accord?

The Naga peace accord aims to resolve the decades-long Naga insurgency by granting greater autonomy to the Naga people. However, disagreements over issues like territorial integration and a separate Naga flag have stalled the finalization of the accord.

Topics Covered

PolityGeographyInternational RelationsIndian PolityRegional GeographyBorder Security