UPSC MainsPHILOSOPHY-PAPER-I202410 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q12.

What do the existentialist thinkers mean by the slogan “existence precedes essence”? How is human existence related to human freedom according to them? Discuss.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of existentialism, particularly the core tenet of "existence precedes essence." The answer should begin by defining this slogan and contrasting it with traditional philosophical views. It should then elaborate on how existentialist thinkers like Sartre and de Beauvoir link this concept to human freedom and responsibility. The response should demonstrate an understanding of the implications of this freedom – anguish, abandonment, and the need for authentic self-creation. A concise and focused answer is key, given the word limit.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Existentialism, a prominent 20th-century philosophical movement, fundamentally challenges traditional metaphysics. Unlike classical philosophies that posit a pre-defined human nature or ‘essence’ determining existence, existentialists argue that humans are born into existence without inherent purpose. This is encapsulated in the famous slogan “existence precedes essence.” This implies that individuals first exist, and then through their choices and actions, they define their own meaning and create their own essence. This radical freedom, however, is not without its burdens, forming the core of existentialist thought and its implications for human responsibility.

Understanding “Existence Precedes Essence”

Traditionally, philosophy often assumed a pre-existing ‘essence’ – a set of characteristics defining what it means to be human – that dictated our existence. For example, Plato’s Theory of Forms suggests ideal archetypes exist before their earthly manifestations. Aristotle believed in a ‘telos’ or inherent purpose. Existentialism rejects this. Jean-Paul Sartre, a key figure, argued that ‘man is nothing else but what he makes of himself.’

Human Existence and Freedom

For existentialists, the lack of a pre-defined essence means humans are ‘condemned to be free.’ This freedom isn’t a joyous liberation but a source of profound anguish. Because there are no external rules or values to guide us, we are entirely responsible for our choices and their consequences. This responsibility is absolute; we cannot blame God, society, or our genes for our actions.

Sartre’s Concept of Bad Faith

Sartre introduced the concept of ‘bad faith’ (mauvaise foi) to describe the attempt to evade this responsibility. This involves deceiving oneself into believing one is determined by external factors, thereby denying one’s freedom. For example, a waiter who over-identifies with his role, acting as a caricature of a waiter, is engaging in bad faith, denying his capacity for choice and self-definition.

De Beauvoir and Existential Feminism

Simone de Beauvoir extended existentialist principles to feminist thought. In The Second Sex (1949), she argued that ‘one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.’ This means that femininity is not a biological destiny but a social construct imposed upon women, limiting their freedom and preventing them from fully realizing their potential. Women, like men, must actively create their own essence through their choices.

The Implications of Freedom: Anguish and Abandonment

  • Anguish (angoisse): The awareness of our absolute freedom and responsibility.
  • Abandonment (délaissement): The realization that there is no God or objective moral authority to guide us.
  • Despair (désespoir): Acknowledging that we can only rely on what is within our power to change.

Authenticity as a Response

Existentialists advocate for ‘authenticity’ – living in accordance with one’s own freely chosen values and taking full responsibility for one’s actions. This requires confronting the anguish and abandonment inherent in human existence and embracing the freedom to create one’s own meaning. Authenticity is not a state to be achieved but a continuous process of self-creation.

Conclusion

In essence, the existentialist slogan “existence precedes essence” signifies a radical shift in philosophical thought, placing the onus of meaning-making squarely on the individual. Human freedom, while liberating, is also a source of profound responsibility and anguish. By acknowledging this freedom and striving for authenticity, individuals can overcome the inherent absurdity of existence and create a meaningful life, even in the absence of pre-ordained purpose. This emphasis on individual agency continues to resonate in contemporary ethical and political debates.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Essence
In traditional philosophy, essence refers to the inherent nature or defining characteristics of a thing, what makes it what it is. It's the 'whatness' of a being, preceding its existence.
Authenticity
In existentialism, authenticity refers to the state of living in accordance with one's own freely chosen values and taking full responsibility for one's actions, rather than conforming to societal expectations or deceiving oneself about one's freedom.

Key Statistics

A 2017 Pew Research Center study found that 22% of U.S. adults identify as religiously unaffiliated, a significant increase from 16% in 2007. This trend reflects a growing questioning of traditional sources of meaning and authority, aligning with existentialist themes.

Source: Pew Research Center, "America’s Changing Religious Landscape," 2017

Globally, the number of people experiencing anxiety and depression increased by more than 25% in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic (WHO, 2022). This surge in mental health challenges underscores the existential anxieties related to uncertainty, isolation, and the search for meaning in a crisis.

Source: World Health Organization (WHO), 2022

Examples

Viktor Frankl’s Logotherapy

Viktor Frankl, a Holocaust survivor, developed Logotherapy, a school of psychotherapy based on existentialist principles. He argued that the primary human drive is not pleasure (as Freud believed) but the search for meaning in life, even in the face of suffering. His experiences in concentration camps demonstrated the power of finding meaning to endure unimaginable hardship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is existentialism inherently pessimistic?

While existentialism acknowledges the inherent absurdity and anguish of existence, it is not necessarily pessimistic. It emphasizes the power of individual agency and the possibility of creating meaning, even in a meaningless world. It’s more accurate to describe it as realistic and challenging.

Topics Covered

PhilosophyExistentialismExistenceFreedomHuman Nature