UPSC MainsPSYCHOLOGY-PAPER-II202415 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q26.

Discuss the role of media in the present scenario of antisocial behaviour ? Considering Indian context in view suggest some measures to regulate media.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the interplay between media and antisocial behavior, specifically within the Indian context. The answer should begin by defining antisocial behavior and outlining the various ways media can influence it – both positively and negatively. It should then delve into the Indian context, highlighting specific examples and challenges. Finally, it needs to propose concrete, legally and ethically sound measures for media regulation, acknowledging the importance of freedom of speech. A structure of defining the problem, analyzing the Indian context, and proposing solutions is recommended.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Antisocial behavior, encompassing actions that disregard societal norms and potentially harm others, is a growing concern globally and in India. The pervasive influence of media – including television, cinema, social media, and online platforms – plays a significant role in shaping perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors. While media can be a powerful tool for social good, its potential to normalize, glamorize, or even incite antisocial acts is undeniable. Recent incidents of cyberbullying, online radicalization, and the spread of misinformation in India underscore the urgent need to examine the role of media and consider appropriate regulatory measures, balancing freedom of expression with societal safety.

Understanding the Role of Media in Antisocial Behaviour

Media’s influence on antisocial behavior is multifaceted. Several psychological theories explain this connection:

  • Social Learning Theory (Bandura): Individuals learn by observing others, including media characters. Exposure to violent or antisocial behavior can lead to imitation, particularly in vulnerable individuals.
  • Cultivation Theory (Gerbner): Prolonged exposure to media content can shape an individual’s perception of reality, leading them to believe the world is more dangerous and hostile than it actually is.
  • Excitation Transfer Theory: Physiological arousal from media content (e.g., violent scenes) can intensify emotional reactions in real-life situations, potentially leading to aggressive behavior.

Specifically, media can contribute to antisocial behavior through:

  • Exposure to Violence: Graphic depictions of violence can desensitize individuals and increase aggression.
  • Glamorization of Crime: Portraying criminals as heroes or romanticizing criminal lifestyles can normalize antisocial behavior.
  • Cyberbullying and Online Harassment: Social media platforms can facilitate cyberbullying, leading to emotional distress, anxiety, and even suicide.
  • Spread of Misinformation and Hate Speech: False or inflammatory content can incite violence and discrimination.
  • Body Image Issues & Social Comparison: Unrealistic portrayals of beauty and success can lead to dissatisfaction and potentially antisocial behaviors like eating disorders or theft.

The Indian Context: Challenges and Specifics

The Indian media landscape presents unique challenges:

  • High Media Consumption: India has a rapidly growing media consumption rate, particularly among youth, making them highly susceptible to media influence. According to a 2023 report by BARC India, television penetration reached 76% of Indian households.
  • Regional Diversity: The vast linguistic and cultural diversity of India necessitates tailored media regulation strategies. Content that may be acceptable in one region could be offensive or harmful in another.
  • Rise of Social Media: The proliferation of social media platforms, often with limited content moderation, has exacerbated the problem of cyberbullying, hate speech, and misinformation.
  • Influence of Bollywood: Bollywood films often depict violence, crime, and gender inequality, which can have a significant impact on societal attitudes.
  • Lack of Media Literacy: Low levels of media literacy among the population make individuals more vulnerable to manipulation and misinformation.

Examples in India: The spread of communal hatred through WhatsApp during the 2020 Delhi riots, the online harassment of journalists and activists, and the glorification of gangster culture in some films are all examples of how media can contribute to antisocial behavior in India.

Measures to Regulate Media in India

Regulating media requires a delicate balance between protecting freedom of speech and safeguarding societal interests. The following measures are suggested:

  • Strengthening the Press Council of India (PCI): Empowering the PCI with greater authority to enforce ethical standards and investigate complaints against media outlets.
  • Amendments to the Information Technology Act, 2000: Strengthening provisions related to cyberbullying, hate speech, and the spread of misinformation, while ensuring due process and protecting legitimate expression.
  • Self-Regulation by Media Platforms: Encouraging social media platforms to adopt robust content moderation policies and invest in technologies to detect and remove harmful content. The Digital Media Ethics Code, 2021, is a step in this direction, but its implementation needs strengthening.
  • Promoting Media Literacy: Integrating media literacy education into school curricula to equip students with the critical thinking skills needed to evaluate media content.
  • Establishing a Media Monitoring Authority: Creating an independent body to monitor media content and identify potentially harmful trends. This authority should be transparent and accountable.
  • Community-Based Media Regulation: Empowering local communities to participate in media regulation and address issues specific to their context.
  • Clear Guidelines for OTT Platforms: Establishing clear content classification and age-rating guidelines for Over-The-Top (OTT) platforms to protect children and vulnerable individuals.
Regulatory Approach Advantages Disadvantages
Government Regulation Effective in curbing harmful content, ensures accountability Potential for censorship, infringement on freedom of speech
Self-Regulation Promotes media independence, fosters ethical standards May be ineffective in addressing serious violations, lack of transparency
Co-Regulation Combines the benefits of both approaches, balances freedom and responsibility Requires effective collaboration between government and media, potential for conflicts of interest

Conclusion

The media’s role in shaping societal behavior is undeniable, and its potential to contribute to antisocial acts is a serious concern, particularly in the diverse and rapidly evolving Indian context. A multi-pronged approach involving strengthened regulation, enhanced self-regulation by media platforms, and widespread media literacy education is crucial. Balancing freedom of expression with the need to protect societal values requires careful consideration and ongoing dialogue. Ultimately, a responsible and ethical media landscape is essential for fostering a harmonious and progressive society.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Antisocial Behavior
Actions that disregard societal norms and potentially harm others, ranging from minor rule violations to serious criminal offenses.
Media Literacy
The ability to access, analyze, evaluate, and create media in a variety of forms. It empowers individuals to be critical consumers of information and resist manipulation.

Key Statistics

India has over 750 million internet users as of January 2024.

Source: Statista (as of knowledge cutoff - Jan 2024)

Approximately 65% of Indian adults have access to a smartphone (as of 2023).

Source: Newzoo (as of knowledge cutoff - Jan 2024)

Examples

The Nirbhaya Case (2012)

The extensive media coverage of the 2012 Delhi gang rape case, while raising awareness about sexual violence, also led to sensationalism and potentially contributed to victim-blaming narratives.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is censorship the answer to regulating antisocial content in media?

Censorship is generally not the preferred solution, as it can stifle freedom of expression. A more effective approach involves a combination of regulation, self-regulation, and media literacy to promote responsible content creation and consumption.

Topics Covered

SociologyCommunicationMedia EffectsSocial ControlCrime