UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-II202520 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q12.

What is organic evolution? Discuss in detail the indirect evidences of organic evolution with suitable examples.

How to Approach

The answer should begin by defining organic evolution. Then, it needs to delve into the various indirect evidences, providing a detailed explanation of each with suitable examples. The structure should involve clear subheadings for each type of evidence, facilitating a comprehensive and organized presentation of facts, ensuring all parts of the question are addressed.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Organic evolution, often summarized as "descent with modification" by Charles Darwin, is the fundamental theory explaining the gradual transformation of living organisms over successive generations. It posits that all life forms on Earth share common ancestors and have diversified over millions of years through genetic and phenotypic changes. These modifications, driven by processes like natural selection, enable species to adapt to changing environments, ensuring their survival and reproduction, and ultimately leading to the emergence of new species. While direct observation of large-scale evolution is challenging due to the immense timescales involved, a wealth of indirect evidence from various scientific disciplines strongly supports this theory.

What is Organic Evolution?

Organic, or biological, evolution refers to the cumulative genetic and phenotypic changes that occur in living organisms across multiple generations. This process is distinct from other forms of evolution, such as chemical or cultural evolution. It encompasses two primary processes:

  • Anagenesis: The gradual evolution of a species that continues to exist as an interbreeding population.
  • Cladogenesis: The branching or splitting of a lineage, leading to two or more separate species.

The core principle is that present-day complex life forms have originated from simpler, pre-existing forms through a continuous series of modifications. These changes, arising from adaptations to environmental conditions, make newly formed species typically better adapted than their ancestors.

Indirect Evidences of Organic Evolution

The evidence for organic evolution is vast and comes from numerous scientific fields. While direct observation of macroevolutionary changes is difficult, indirect evidences provide compelling support for the theory. These include:

1. Palaeontological Evidence (Fossil Record)

Fossils are the preserved remains or traces of ancient organisms found in rock strata. The fossil record provides a chronological sequence of life forms, demonstrating a progression from simpler to more complex organisms over geological time. This record serves as a direct window into Earth's biological past.

  • Progression of Forms: Fossils show that life on Earth was once different from what it is today. Older rock layers typically contain simpler organisms, while newer layers reveal more complex forms. For example, undisturbed strata with simple unicellular organisms predate those with multicellular organisms, and invertebrates precede vertebrates.
  • Transitional Forms: The discovery of transitional fossils provides crucial links between different groups of organisms, illustrating evolutionary pathways. These fossils possess characteristics of both ancestral and descendant groups.
  • Examples:
    • Archaeopteryx: A famous transitional fossil exhibiting features of both reptiles (e.g., teeth, long bony tail) and birds (e.g., feathers), indicating the evolutionary link between these two classes.
    • Evolution of Horses: The fossil record of horses shows a clear lineage from small, multi-toed ancestors (like Eohippus) to the larger, single-toed modern horse (Equus), demonstrating gradual changes in size, limb structure, and teeth over millions of years.

2. Comparative Anatomy and Morphology

This field examines the similarities and differences in the anatomical structures of different species, revealing common ancestry and adaptive changes.

  • Homologous Organs: These are organs that have a similar underlying anatomical structure and embryonic origin but perform different functions due to adaptation to different environments. They suggest divergence from a common ancestor.
    • Examples: The forelimbs of humans, bats, whales, and cats. All possess the same basic bone arrangement (humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, metacarpals, phalanges), but they are modified for different functions like grasping, flying, swimming, and walking, respectively.
  • Analogous Organs: These are organs that have different anatomical structures and embryonic origins but perform similar functions due to convergent evolution in similar environments. They do not indicate common ancestry but rather similar adaptive pressures.
    • Examples: The wings of insects and birds. Both are used for flight but have entirely different structural compositions. Insect wings are membranous extensions supported by chitinous nervures, while bird wings are supported by bones and covered with feathers.
  • Vestigial Organs: These are rudimentary, non-functional organs present in an organism that were functional in its ancestors. Their presence indicates evolutionary history.
    • Examples: In humans, the vermiform appendix (reduced digestive function in ancestors), coccyx (tailbone, remnant of a tail), and wisdom teeth (functional in ancestors with larger jaws). In whales, the presence of pelvic bones and hindlimb remnants suggests descent from four-legged terrestrial ancestors.

3. Embryological Evidence

The study of embryonic development in different organisms reveals striking similarities during early stages, suggesting common ancestry.

  • Similarities in Early Development: Embryos of different vertebrates (fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds, mammals) exhibit remarkable resemblances in their early developmental stages. For instance, all vertebrate embryos temporarily possess gill slits and a tail, even if these structures are not present in the adult form.
    • Examples: Human embryos develop gill slits and a tail, which are later reabsorbed or modified (the tail becomes the coccyx). This pattern indicates that all vertebrates stem from a common ancestor that developed in a similar manner.
  • Hox Genes: These genes control the development of an organism from head to tail and are remarkably similar across most multicellular eukaryotes, even between insects and humans. Small changes in Hox gene DNA can indicate where species diverged from their common ancestor.

4. Biogeographical Evidence

Biogeography is the study of the geographical distribution of organisms. Patterns of species distribution across the globe provide strong evidence for evolution and continental drift.

  • Distribution of Species: Closely related species tend to be found in geographically continuous areas, while isolated landmasses often host unique species that have evolved in isolation from continental forms.
  • Adaptive Radiation on Islands: Remote oceanic islands, like the Galapagos, are often home to unique species (endemics) that are closely related to species on the nearest mainland but have diversified to fill various ecological niches.
    • Examples:
    • Darwin's Finches: On the Galapagos Islands, Darwin observed various finch species, each adapted to different food sources (beak shapes), all descended from a common ancestral finch that arrived from the South American mainland.
    • Marsupials in Australia: The high diversity of marsupial mammals in Australia, in contrast to the prevalence of placental mammals elsewhere, is explained by Australia's long isolation after the breakup of the supercontinent Gondwana.

5. Molecular Biology and Biochemistry

The comparison of molecular components like DNA, RNA, and proteins among different species reveals fundamental similarities that reflect evolutionary relationships at a genetic level.

  • Genetic Code Universality: All known life forms on Earth use essentially the same genetic code (triplets of DNA/RNA bases coding for specific amino acids), suggesting a single common ancestor.
  • DNA and Protein Sequence Homology: The more closely related two species are, the more similarities they exhibit in their DNA sequences and protein structures. Differences accumulate over evolutionary time.
    • Examples: Humans and chimpanzees share approximately 98% of their DNA sequences, indicating a recent common ancestor. The hemoglobin protein, responsible for oxygen transport, has very similar amino acid sequences across all mammals, with slight variations reflecting their evolutionary divergence.
  • Molecular Clock: By assuming a relatively constant rate of mutation in certain genes, scientists can estimate the time since two species diverged from a common ancestor by comparing their molecular differences.

Conclusion

Organic evolution, the gradual modification of life forms over generations, is a cornerstone of modern biology. The intricate web of indirect evidences from palaeontology, comparative anatomy, embryology, biogeography, and molecular biology provides an overwhelming and consistent picture of life's history. These diverse lines of evidence, when viewed together, paint a compelling narrative of common ancestry, diversification, and adaptation, reinforcing the understanding that all living organisms are interconnected through a shared evolutionary past. This holistic understanding continues to be refined with ongoing scientific discoveries.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Organic Evolution
The gradual process by which existing species of plants and animals undergo genetic and phenotypic changes over successive generations, leading to the development of new and often more complex forms from pre-existing ones.
Homologous Organs
Structures in different species that have a similar basic anatomical plan and embryonic origin, inherited from a common ancestor, but have evolved to perform different functions.

Key Statistics

Humans and chimpanzees share approximately 98% of their DNA sequences, highlighting their close evolutionary relationship and a relatively recent common ancestor, estimated to be between 5 to 8 million years ago.

Source: Khan Academy, Study.com

The oldest known animal fossils date back approximately 700 million years (Ediacara fauna), while the earliest fossils resembling bacteria and cyanobacteria are found in rocks 3.5 billion years old, providing a timeline for early life forms.

Source: Britannica, FuseSchool

Examples

Evolution of the Vertebrate Eye

The vertebrate eye, despite its complexity, shows a stepwise evolutionary progression through various animal groups, starting from simple light-sensitive spots to the highly complex camera-type eye. While the final structure is intricate, intermediate forms observed in different species demonstrate how such an organ could have evolved gradually.

Antibiotic Resistance in Bacteria

A contemporary and directly observable example of evolution. Bacteria rapidly evolve resistance to antibiotics, demonstrating natural selection in action. Those bacteria with mutations allowing them to survive antibiotic treatment reproduce, passing on their resistance, leading to resistant strains within a short period.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between direct and indirect evidence of evolution?

Direct evidence typically refers to observable evolutionary changes occurring within shorter timescales, such as bacterial resistance to antibiotics or changes in population genetics. Indirect evidence, which forms the bulk of the support for macroevolution, comes from comparisons across species and historical records (like fossils) that infer evolutionary relationships and changes over long geological periods.

Topics Covered

BiologyEvolutionOrganic evolutionEvidences of evolutionNatural selectionPaleontology