UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II202510 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q17.

Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each: (c) “The First World War did not produce just political consequences, it also had a deep impact on the ways of thinking."

How to Approach

The question asks for a critical examination of how the First World War impacted "ways of thinking." The approach should involve identifying and elaborating on specific intellectual and cultural shifts. It is crucial to move beyond mere political consequences and delve into philosophical, psychological, artistic, and social thought. Structure the answer with an introduction, body paragraphs addressing different spheres of thought, and a conclusion summarizing the profound transformation.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The First World War, lasting from 1914 to 1918, was a cataclysmic event that reshaped not only the political map of Europe but also fundamentally altered societal perceptions and intellectual paradigms across the globe. Often termed "the war to end all wars," its unprecedented scale of destruction, industrialised warfare, and immense loss of life shattered 19th-century optimism and belief in linear progress. This profound trauma led to a deep-seated disillusionment, prompting a critical re-evaluation of established norms, values, and philosophies, thereby instigating significant shifts in the collective consciousness and individual ways of thinking.

The First World War undeniably triggered a seismic shift in human thought, moving beyond immediate political ramifications to instigate fundamental changes in philosophy, psychology, literature, and art.

Philosophical Shifts and Existentialism

  • Undermining Rationalism and Optimism: The war exposed the dark irrationality of human nature and the destructive potential of modern technology, severely challenging Enlightenment ideals of rationalism and inevitable progress. Thinkers questioned the capacity of humanity to make decisions for an "ever-better place to live."
  • Rise of Existentialism and Nihilism: The devastation fostered skepticism towards traditional beliefs, leading to the rise of philosophical movements like existentialism and nihilism. Existentialism emphasized individual freedom, responsibility, and the inherent meaninglessness of existence in a world devoid of inherent purpose, reflecting a broader disillusionment. Philosophers like Ludwig Wittgenstein explored language and logic in new ways.
  • Questioning Traditional Morality: The extreme violence and ethical dilemmas of the war forced a re-evaluation of moral frameworks and the concept of "just war." The idea of the "sanctity of life" gained prominence as the costs of war rose in public perception.

Psychological Impact and Understanding of Trauma

  • Recognition of "Shell Shock": WWI marked the first time that the psychological trauma of warfare was formally recognized, leading to the widespread identification of "shell shock" (now understood as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder or PTSD). This spurred significant changes in psychiatry and the approach to mental health conditions.
  • Shattered Innocence and Alienation: Soldiers returning from the front often experienced profound psychological scars, feeling alienated from a civilian world that could not comprehend their experiences. This led to repressed pain and trauma that impacted future generations.

Literary and Artistic Responses

  • Emergence of Modernism: The disillusionment catalyzed the emergence of modernism in literature and art, characterized by a break with traditional forms, a rejection of romanticism, and a focus on the interior world and fragmented reality. Artists like Marc Chagall remarked that "The war was another plastic work that totally absorbed us, which reformed our forms, destroyed the lines, and gave a new look to the universe."
  • Anti-War Literature: A new genre of anti-war literature emerged, vividly portraying the horrors and futility of conflict, in stark contrast to earlier patriotic narratives. Authors like Wilfred Owen and Erich Maria Remarque (with his novel All Quiet on the Western Front) captured the grim reality.
  • Artistic Movements: Movements like Dadaism and Surrealism, with their rejection of logic and reason, were direct responses to the perceived absurdity and irrationality of the war.

Social Thought and Changing Attitudes

  • Challenging Nationalism and Heroism: The prolonged industrial warfare challenged prevailing notions of nationalism, heroism, and citizenship. The idea of collective sacrifice was re-examined in the face of mass casualties.
  • Rise of Anti-War Movements: The war acted as a catalyst for a widespread belief that the institution of war should be abandoned, leading to increased anti-war agitation and a desire to prevent future large-scale conflicts.
  • Shifts in Gender Roles: While not directly a "way of thinking," the war's demands on society, including women taking on roles traditionally held by men, profoundly influenced perceptions of gender capabilities and equality, strengthening feminist movements.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the First World War was far more than a geopolitical upheaval; it was a crucible that forged new ways of understanding the human condition, society, and the very nature of existence. It shattered deeply held beliefs in progress and rationality, giving rise to existential anxieties and philosophical skepticism that continue to resonate. The war profoundly influenced artistic expression, psychological understanding, and societal attitudes, leaving an indelible mark on intellectual and cultural landscapes that reshaped the 20th century and beyond.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Shell Shock
A term coined during World War I to describe the psychological trauma experienced by soldiers, manifesting in symptoms like fatigue, tremor, confusion, nightmares, and impaired sight and hearing. It is now largely understood as a form of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
Existentialism
A philosophical theory or approach that emphasizes the existence of the individual as a free and responsible agent determining their own development through acts of the will. It rose to prominence after WWI, often exploring themes of meaninglessness, alienation, and individual choice in a chaotic world.

Key Statistics

Over 16 million people, both military and civilian, died in the First World War. In 1919, in France, there were 15 women for every man between the ages of 18 and 30, highlighting the immense loss of a generation of young men.

Source: The Impact of the First World War and Its Implications for Europe Today (2014)

During the interwar period (1920s-1930s), mass communication expanded significantly, with radio becoming commonplace in 60% of American homes by 1930, facilitating the spread of new ideas and cultural trends.

Source: Study.com, "Cultural & Intellectual Trends Between WWI & WWII" (2025)

Examples

Literary Response: All Quiet on the Western Front

Erich Maria Remarque's novel "All Quiet on the Western Front" (1929) famously depicted the extreme physical and mental stress of German soldiers during the war, offering a stark, bleak, and anti-heroic portrayal of combat that profoundly shaped public perception of the conflict.

Artistic Response: Dadaism

The Dada art movement, emerging during WWI in neutral Zurich, was a deliberate reaction against the absurdity and horror of the war. It embraced irrationality, anti-art, and chaos, challenging the traditional artistic and societal values that its proponents believed had led to the conflict.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the First World War influence the rise of psychological studies?

The unprecedented scale of psychological trauma experienced by soldiers, termed "shell shock," brought mental health issues to the forefront. This led to a greater focus on understanding and treating war-related psychological conditions, laying some groundwork for modern psychiatry and the study of trauma.

What was the "Lost Generation" and how was it connected to WWI?

The "Lost Generation" refers to a group of American writers who came of age during WWI, including Ernest Hemingway and T.S. Eliot. Disillusioned by the war's devastation and the perceived moral decay of society, their works often explored themes of emptiness, futility, and a loss of traditional values.

Topics Covered

World HistoryModern HistorySocial SciencesWorld War IPolitical ConsequencesIntellectual HistorySocietal Change