UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II202510 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q11.

"The emergence of Gandhi signified the Indianization of the national movement." Analyze with reference to his early movements between 1917-1922.

How to Approach

The question asks for an analysis of how Gandhi's early movements (1917-1922) "Indianized" the national movement. The approach should define "Indianization" in this context and then systematically analyze how each of Gandhi's key early movements (Champaran, Ahmedabad, Kheda, Rowlatt Satyagraha, Non-Cooperation Movement) contributed to this process. Focus on aspects like mass mobilization, indigenous methods, connecting with local grievances, and cultural resonance.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Before Mahatma Gandhi's arrival on the Indian political scene in 1915, the Indian national movement was largely confined to the educated elite, primarily advocating for reforms through constitutional methods. Its reach was limited, often failing to resonate with the vast majority of the Indian populace, especially the rural masses. The period between 1917 and 1922, marked by Gandhi's initial experiments in India, fundamentally transformed this landscape. His unique approach, characterized by 'Satyagraha' and an understanding of the Indian ethos, broadened the movement's base, brought in diverse sections of society, and infused it with distinctly Indian characteristics, thereby leading to its "Indianization."

The term "Indianization of the national movement" signifies a profound shift from an elite-driven, Western-oriented political struggle to a mass-based movement rooted in Indian cultural values, socio-economic realities, and indigenous methods of protest. Gandhi's early movements laid the groundwork for this transformation, making the struggle for independence truly representative of the Indian people.

Key Aspects of Indianization through Early Movements (1917-1922)

1. Connecting with the Masses: Addressing Local Grievances

Gandhi’s initial movements were not abstract political demands but directly addressed the localized economic and social injustices faced by ordinary Indians. This approach made the national movement tangible and relatable for millions.

  • Champaran Satyagraha (1917): This was Gandhi's first experiment with Satyagraha in India. He championed the cause of indigo farmers (ryots) in Champaran, Bihar, who were exploited under the oppressive "Tinkathia system" by European planters. By personally investigating their plight, collecting testimonies, and defying official orders to leave, Gandhi demonstrated solidarity with the rural poor. The success, leading to the abolition of the Tinkathia system and compensation for farmers, brought agrarian distress into national discourse and established Gandhi as a leader who could deliver results for the common people.
  • Ahmedabad Mill Strike (1918): Here, Gandhi intervened in a dispute between textile mill owners and workers in Ahmedabad over plague bonuses and wage increases. He adopted a hunger strike to support the workers' demands for a 35% wage hike. This movement introduced the urban working class into the national movement, showcasing that non-violent collective bargaining could be effective in industrial disputes. The successful resolution brought a new dimension to labor activism.
  • Kheda Satyagraha (1918): In Kheda, Gujarat, farmers faced severe crop failure due to drought but were still compelled to pay full land revenue. Gandhi, along with local leaders like Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, led a non-cooperation movement, urging peasants to withhold revenue payments. The government eventually conceded, suspending taxes for the poorest farmers. This movement cemented Gandhi's reputation among the peasantry and demonstrated the power of disciplined non-violent resistance against unjust government policies, strengthening the Congress's base in rural areas.

2. Introduction of Indigenous Methods: Satyagraha and Ahimsa

Gandhi replaced the petitions and resolutions of the moderates, and the revolutionary violence of the extremists, with a distinctly Indian method of protest – Satyagraha, based on truth and non-violence (Ahimsa).

  • Satyagraha as a Philosophy: Satyagraha, meaning 'truth-force' or 'soul-force,' was a moral weapon that appealed to the conscience of the oppressor rather than resorting to violence or passive resistance. This philosophy resonated deeply with Indian spiritual traditions and cultural values.
  • Mass Civil Disobedience: Gandhi actively encouraged civil disobedience, which involved open defiance of unjust laws while accepting the consequences. This was a radical departure from previous methods and required immense moral courage from participants.

3. Broadening the Social Base and Inclusivity

Gandhi's movements effectively transcended traditional social barriers, drawing in segments of society previously marginalized or untouched by the political struggle.

  • Inclusion of Peasants and Workers: As seen in Champaran, Kheda, and Ahmedabad, Gandhi actively brought peasants and industrial workers into the political fold, integrating their specific grievances into the broader nationalist agenda.
  • Women's Participation: The non-violent nature of Satyagraha made it acceptable for women to participate actively, particularly in public demonstrations, picketing, and constructive programs.
  • Hindu-Muslim Unity (Early Phase): Gandhi recognized the importance of Hindu-Muslim unity for a strong national movement. His leadership during the Khilafat Movement (1919-1924) alongside the Ali brothers, where he supported the cause of Indian Muslims regarding the Ottoman Caliphate, aimed to forge a united front against British rule, though this unity proved fragile later.

4. From Regional to National Mass Mobilization

While the initial movements were localized, they provided Gandhi with valuable experience and laid the foundation for nationwide agitation.

  • Rowlatt Satyagraha (1919): In response to the draconian Rowlatt Act, which allowed detention without trial, Gandhi called for a nationwide 'hartal' (strike) and civil disobedience. This was the first all-India protest against the British, demonstrating the potential for mass mobilization across diverse regions. Though it turned violent in some places (culminating in the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre), it proved that ordinary Indians were ready to defy the British.
  • Non-Cooperation Movement (1920-1922): This movement marked the culmination of Gandhi's early efforts to Indianize the national struggle. It was a comprehensive program of non-violent non-cooperation aimed at withdrawing Indian support from all British institutions.

Impact of Non-Cooperation Movement on Indianization:

Aspect of Indianization Details of Non-Cooperation Movement's Contribution
Mass Participation Students boycotted schools and colleges; lawyers like Motilal Nehru and C.R. Das gave up their practices; peasants, tribals, and women participated on an unprecedented scale. This made it a true 'people's movement'.
Cultural and Symbolic Emphasis on Khadi (homespun cloth) as a symbol of self-reliance and national pride; boycott of foreign goods; use of vernacular languages in political discourse, replacing English, which further connected with the masses.
Constructive Programme Promotion of Hindu-Muslim unity, abolition of untouchability, promotion of cottage industries, and national education institutions. These initiatives aimed at internal societal reform alongside political liberation, embodying an Indian vision of Swaraj.
Decentralization The movement decentralized political activity, with local grievances finding expression within the broader national framework, empowering local leadership and participation.

5. Simplification and Accessibility of Leadership

Gandhi's personal lifestyle, attire, and communication style significantly contributed to the Indianization of leadership.

  • Simple Living: His adoption of a simple dhoti and charkha (spinning wheel) made him relatable to the poorest farmer and worker. This stood in stark contrast to the Westernized attire of earlier nationalist leaders.
  • Vernacular Communication: Gandhi consistently used vernacular languages to communicate with the masses, making political ideas accessible to those unfamiliar with English.

Conclusion

The period between 1917 and 1922 unequivocally marked the Indianization of the national movement. Through his early experiments in Champaran, Ahmedabad, and Kheda, Gandhi developed and perfected the technique of Satyagraha, linking the national struggle to the everyday grievances of ordinary Indians. The Rowlatt Satyagraha and, most significantly, the Non-Cooperation Movement, transformed the Congress from an elite platform into a truly mass organization. By adopting indigenous methods, symbols like Khadi, and inclusive strategies, Gandhi not only broadened the movement's social base but also instilled a sense of self-respect and courage, making the fight for independence a truly Indian people’s struggle.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Indianization of National Movement
This refers to the transformation of the Indian freedom struggle from an elite-dominated, constitutionally-oriented movement to a mass-based, culturally resonant, and indigenous struggle, reflecting the values, grievances, and participation of the broader Indian populace.
Satyagraha
A philosophy and practice of non-violent resistance developed by Mahatma Gandhi. It literally means "holding firmly to truth" or "truth-force," advocating for moral persuasion and suffering rather than physical force to achieve justice.

Key Statistics

The Champaran Agrarian Bill, passed in 1918, protected the interests of peasants and provided relief to indigo cultivators. Gandhi persuaded authorities to abolish the tinkathia system and ensured peasants received a 25% refund of unfair dues.

Source: Champaran Satyagraha (1917): Gandhi’s First Civil Disobedience Movement, Studento

The Ahmedabad Mill Strike (1918) successfully secured a 35% wage increase for textile workers, marking a significant victory for labor rights and demonstrating the power of non-violent protest in industrial disputes.

Source: Ahmedabad Mill Strike (1918) – Modern India History Notes, Prepp

Examples

Symbolism of Khadi

During the Non-Cooperation Movement, Mahatma Gandhi actively promoted Khadi, hand-spun and hand-woven cloth, as a symbol of self-reliance, economic independence, and national pride. The boycott of foreign cloth and the adoption of Khadi became a powerful visual and economic statement against British economic exploitation, directly involving millions in the movement by encouraging them to spin and wear indigenous clothing.

Renunciation of Titles

As part of the Non-Cooperation Movement's program, many prominent Indians renounced titles and honorary positions conferred by the British government. Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore, for instance, famously renounced his knighthood in protest against the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre, a prelude to the Non-Cooperation Movement.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the "Tinkathia system" that Gandhi opposed in Champaran?

The "Tinkathia system" was an oppressive practice prevalent in Champaran, Bihar, where European planters forced Indian peasants to cultivate indigo on 3/20th of their land holdings (teen-kathia) without adequate remuneration. When the demand for natural indigo declined due to German synthetic dyes, planters still extracted high rents and illegal dues, leading to severe exploitation of the farmers.

Why did Gandhi withdraw the Non-Cooperation Movement in 1922?

Gandhi withdrew the Non-Cooperation Movement in February 1922 following the Chauri Chaura incident. In Chauri Chaura, Uttar Pradesh, a violent mob set fire to a police station, killing 22 policemen. Gandhi, a staunch believer in non-violence, felt that the movement was turning violent and that the masses were not yet adequately trained for non-violent civil disobedience. He believed that such violence would undermine the moral authority of the movement.

Topics Covered

Indian HistoryModern Indian HistorySocial MovementsMahatma GandhiNational MovementIndianizationEarly Movements