Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
John Stuart Mill, a prominent 19th-century British philosopher, political economist, and liberal thinker, integrated his understanding of equality within his overarching utilitarian and liberal philosophies. While he did not provide a systematic treatise solely on equality, his writings, particularly "The Subjection of Women" and "On Liberty," extensively explore its various dimensions. For Mill, equality was not merely an abstract ideal but a practical necessity for individual self-development and the collective advancement of society towards the greatest happiness. He viewed systemic inequalities as hindrances to human improvement and championed a progressive vision of a society where individuals could thrive based on their merits, free from arbitrary social and legal barriers.
Salient Features of Equality according to J.S. Mill
J.S. Mill's concept of equality is deeply intertwined with his advocacy for individual liberty and the utilitarian principle of maximizing overall happiness. His views on equality can be understood through several key features:
- Equality of Opportunity, Not Outcomes: Mill emphasized an equality of opportunity, believing that all individuals should have an equal chance to develop their capabilities and contribute to society. He did not advocate for an equality of outcomes, acknowledging natural differences in capabilities, but insisted that social structures should not impede anyone's potential due to birth or circumstance. He argued that freedom of individual choice is essential for the adoption of the best processes and for individuals to contribute effectively.
- Gender Equality as a Moral Imperative: A cornerstone of Mill's egalitarian thought is his passionate advocacy for gender equality, articulated powerfully in "The Subjection of Women" (1869). He deemed the legal subordination of one sex to the other "wrong in itself" and a significant barrier to human improvement. Mill argued for equal rights, including suffrage, education, and access to professions for women, believing that their emancipation would benefit both individuals and society by unlocking untapped talent and promoting a more just social order. He understood that equality in marriage would lead to broader societal equality.
- Impartiality and Equal Consideration of Interests: Grounded in his utilitarianism, Mill's concept of equality implies strict impartiality. The "Greatest Happiness Principle" requires that "as between his own happiness and that of others, utilitarianism requires him to be as strictly impartial as a disinterested and benevolent spectator." This means that every individual's happiness and interests count equally in moral and political calculations, without prejudice based on social status, gender, or other arbitrary distinctions.
- Equality Before the Law: Mill strongly supported the principle of equality before the law, advocating for the removal of all legal disabilities and privileges that create unequal treatment. He believed that customs should not "ordain that to be born a girl instead of a boy... shall decide the person's position through all life." This legal equality was seen as foundational for achieving justice in all spheres of social and political life.
- Role of Education in Promoting Equality: Mill believed that widespread public education was crucial for developing the faculties of all individuals, particularly the working class, enabling them to guide their own destiny and participate effectively in society. Education was seen as a tool to overcome inherent disadvantages and foster a more equal society.
- Limitations on State Interference for Individual Liberty: While advocating for equality, Mill also maintained his "harm principle," asserting that the only legitimate reason for society to interfere with individual liberty is to prevent harm to others. This principle, outlined in "On Liberty" (1859), ensures that efforts towards equality do not infringe upon fundamental individual freedoms.
Conclusion
In essence, J.S. Mill envisioned equality primarily as an equality of opportunity and an equal consideration of interests, particularly emphasizing gender equality as fundamental for human progress. His liberal and utilitarian framework drove him to dismantle arbitrary barriers, especially those enshrined in law and custom, that prevented individuals from realizing their full potential. While not advocating for an equality of outcomes, Mill's robust egalitarianism sought a society where merit, not birth or gender, determined one's place, contributing to both individual flourishing and the collective good. His ideas remain highly influential in contemporary discussions on social justice and equal rights.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.