In five flats, one above the other, live five professionals. The professor has to go up to meet his IAS officer friend. The doctor is equally friendly to all, and has to go up as frequently as go down. The engineer has to go up to meet his MLA friend above whose flat lives the professor's friend. From the ground floor to the top floor, in what order do the five professionals live?
- AEngineer, Professor, Doctor, IAS officer, MLA
- BProfessor, Engineer, Doctor, IAS officer, MLA
- CIAS officer, Engineer, Doctor, Professor, MLA
- DProfessor, Engineer, Doctor, MLA, IAS officerCorrect
Explanation
Here's a step-by-step deduction:
-
Doctor's position: "The doctor is equally friendly to all, and has to go up as frequently as go down." This implies the Doctor lives in the middle flat. In a 5-flat building, the middle flat is the 3rd flat. Order so far: _, _, Doctor, _, _
-
Professor and IAS officer: "The professor has to go up to meet his IAS officer friend." This means the Professor lives below the IAS officer (P < IAS).
-
Engineer, MLA, and IAS officer: "The engineer has to go up to meet his MLA friend above whose flat lives the professor's friend."
- "The engineer has to go up to meet his MLA friend": Engineer lives below MLA (E < MLA).
- "above whose flat lives the professor's friend": "Whose" refers to the MLA. "Professor's friend" is the IAS officer. This means the IAS officer lives above the MLA's flat (MLA < IAS).
-
Combining the relationships: From E < MLA and MLA < IAS, we get the sequence E < MLA < IAS. We also have P < IAS.
-
Placing the professionals:
-
Doctor is at flat 3.
-
From E < MLA < IAS, and with Doctor at 3, the only way to arrange these three in ascending order is for IAS to be at flat 5 and MLA at flat 4. (IAS must be the highest among them, and MLA below IAS). Order so far: _, _, Doctor, MLA, IAS officer. (Flats 1, 2, 3, 4, 5)
-
Now, Engineer (E) and Professor (P) are left for flats 1 and 2.
-
We need to satisfy P < IAS (P < 5) and E < MLA (E < 4).
-
If Professor is at flat 1 and Engineer is at flat 2: Order: Professor, Engineer, Doctor, MLA, IAS officer. (Flats: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5) Let's check the conditions:
- P < IAS (1 < 5): Yes.
- E < MLA (2 < 4): Yes.
- MLA < IAS (4 < 5): Yes.
- Doctor is at 3: Yes. This order satisfies all conditions.
-
This order matches Option D.
The final order from ground floor to top floor is: Professor, Engineer, Doctor, MLA, IAS officer.
The final answer is D

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Three people A, B and C wore shirts of black, blue and orange colours (not necessarily in that order) and pants of green, yellow and orange colours (not necessarily in that order). No person wore a sh…
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Four political parties W, X, Y and Z decided to set up a joint candidate for the coming parliamentary elections. The formula agreed by them was the acceptance of a candidate by most of the parties. Fo…
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Examine the information given in the following paragraph and answer the items that follow: Guest lectures on five subjects viz., Economics, History, Statistics, English and Mathematics have to be arra…
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Examine the information given in the following paragraph and answer the items that follow: Guest lectures on five subjects viz., Economics, History, Statistics, English and Mathematics have to be arra…
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Examine the information given in the following paragraph and answer the items that follow: Guest lectures on five subjects viz., Economics, History, Statistics, English and Mathematics have to be arra…
- Prelims 2012CSATLogical Reasoning
Examine the information given in the following paragraph and answer the items that follow: Guest lectures on five subjects viz., Economics, History, Statistics, English and Mathematics have to be arra…