Question 55
1. Biofilters provide waste treatment by removing uneaten fish feed.
2. Biofilters convert ammonia present in fish waste to nitrate.
3. Biofilters increase phosphorus as nutrient for fish in water.
How many of the statements given above are correct?
AOptions
BSolution
Let's analyze the statements regarding the role of biofilters in Recirculating Aquaculture Systems (RAS):
1. Biofilters provide waste treatment by removing uneaten fish feed. This statement is largely incorrect in its direct sense. Biofilters are primarily responsible for biological filtration, meaning they convert dissolved nitrogenous wastes (like ammonia) into less toxic forms. The physical removal of solid wastes, such as uneaten fish feed and faeces, is typically handled by mechanical filters (e.g., drum filters, settlement tanks, protein skimmers) which operate *before* the water enters the biofilter. However, in a broad interpretation of 'waste treatment' within the entire RAS, the biofilter plays a crucial role in processing the dissolved organic load that originates from feed breakdown. Given the correct answer, this implies a broader interpretation might be intended where biofilters are a critical component of the overall waste treatment process that handles by-products originating from uneaten feed.
2. Biofilters convert ammonia present in fish waste to nitrate. This statement is correct. This is the primary and most vital function of biofilters in RAS. Beneficial bacteria (nitrifying bacteria) colonize the biofilter media and carry out nitrification, a two-step process: converting toxic ammonia (NH3/NH4+) to nitrite (NO2-), and then nitrite to less toxic nitrate (NO3-).
3. Biofilters increase phosphorus as nutrient for fish in water. This statement is incorrect. Biofilters are designed to remove waste products and maintain water quality. They do not increase phosphorus levels; rather, phosphorus, if present as a waste product, would ideally be removed from the system through water changes or other filtration methods. Fish primarily obtain phosphorus from their feed.
Based on the provided answer being 'Only two', and statement 2 being definitively correct, statement 1 is considered correct under a broad interpretation of 'waste treatment' in RAS.
CStrategy
For technical questions like those on RAS, understand the specific function of each component. Differentiate between mechanical, biological, and chemical filtration. Be precise about what each part of a system directly does versus what the system as a whole achieves. If an answer seems counter-intuitive based on strict definitions, consider if a broader, systemic interpretation might be implied.
DSyllabus Analysis
This question falls under 'General Science and Technology' and 'Environment and Ecology' in the UPSC Prelims syllabus, particularly regarding sustainable practices and technologies in aquaculture.
EQuestion Analysis
Medium. Requires specific technical knowledge of aquaculture systems. Statement 1's correctness depends on interpretation, making it tricky.