UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IInternational RelationsPractice question

BRICS and Global Governance Reform via 4Ps

"BRICS has the potential to become a powerful instrument of reforming global governance and promoting inclusive development." Discuss how the 4P's framework - Peace, Opportunity, Well-being, Environmental Resilience - can help BRICS address contemporary global challenges. Also examine the major challenges to its effective implementation.

DiscussExamine~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Begin by contextualising the expanded BRICS bloc as a key voice of the Global South representing significant global population and GDP. Systematically discuss the 4P framework (Peace, Opportunity, Well-being, Environmental Resilience) in addressing global challenges, followed by an examination of internal and external challenges, concluding with a forward-looking roadmap for institutional reform.

Model answer

423 words

Introduction

Representing nearly 45% of the world's population and around 35% of global GDP in purchasing power parity terms, the expanded BRICS grouping has emerged as a cornerstone of the emerging multipolar world order. By articulating the interests of the Global South, the bloc possesses substantial leverage to reform anachronistic global governance architectures and drive inclusive socioeconomic development.

Addressing Contemporary Challenges through the 4P's Framework

The 4P paradigm provides a comprehensive roadmap for BRICS to deliver reformed multilateralism across critical global domains:

  • Peace (Global Order and Security): BRICS advocates for the long-pending restructuring of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) to reflect contemporary geopolitical realities. It champions peaceful dispute resolution, dialogue-based diplomacy, and resistance against unilateral coercive measures and economic sanctions that bypass multilateral legitimacy.
  • Opportunity (Economic and Financial Architecture): The bloc fosters financial multipolarity to hedge against dollar hegemony and unilateral sanctions. Initiatives such as local-currency settlement mechanisms, the Contingent Reserve Arrangement (CRA), and development financing via the New Development Bank (NDB) provide alternative liquidity without onerous Western-style conditionalities.
  • Well-being (Equitable Human Development): BRICS addresses structural vulnerabilities in basic human needs by advancing health and food sovereignty. Initiatives such as the BRICS Vaccine R&D Centre facilitate shared pharmaceutical capacity, while the proposed BRICS Grain Exchange aims to ensure food security across developing nations.
  • Environmental Resilience (Climate Justice): Championing the principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC), BRICS presses advanced economies for predictable climate finance and affordable green technology transfer, balancing industrial development with decarbonisation.

Major Challenges to Effective Implementation

Despite its potential, BRICS faces considerable structural impediments that constrain its institutional efficacy:

  • Internal Geopolitical Frictions: Bilateral disputes among key member states—such as the India-China border standoff and Egypt-Ethiopia differences over the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD)—frequently dilute collective consensus.
  • Economic and Power Asymmetry: China accounts for over 60% of the bloc's aggregate GDP, stoking apprehension among member states regarding Chinese hegemony within institutional mechanisms like the NDB.
  • Divergent Strategic Orientations: There is an ideological divide between states seeking anti-Western revisionism (such as Russia and Iran) and those pursuing non-aligned reformism aimed at strategic autonomy and reformed multilateralism (such as India and Brazil).
  • Heterogeneity and Lack of Institutionalisation: The diverse political systems, varying economic models, and absence of a permanent secretariat make operational coordination complex and slow.

Conclusion

To realise its vision as an engine of inclusive global governance, BRICS must operate as a consensus-driven platform for the Global South rather than an adversarial anti-Western alliance. Emphasising functional cooperation in trade, technology, and climate action will be essential to sustain multipolar multilateralism.

Key facts to remember

statistic

Following its expansion, BRICS represents approximately 45% of the world's population and accounts for nearly 35% of global GDP measured in purchasing power parity (PPP).

definition
4Ps Framework in Multilateralism

A developmental and security matrix comprising Peace (conflict prevention and reformed security), Opportunity (financial and trade access), Well-being (public health and food security), and Environmental Resilience (sustainable development and climate adaptation).

scheme
BRICS New Development Bank (NDB)

A multilateral development bank established by BRICS states in 2014 to mobilise resources for infrastructure and sustainable development projects in emerging markets and developing countries without political conditionality.

Frequently asked questions

How does the strategic vision of BRICS members diverge?

While members like Russia and Iran often seek to leverage BRICS as an anti-Western geopolitical counterbalance, nations such as India and Brazil advocate non-aligned reformism, focusing on strategic autonomy, multipolarity, and reformed multilateral institutions.