Dalvoy Logo
Dalvoy
UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IIIndian PolityPractice question

Autonomy of Constitutional Bodies: ECI and PSCs

"The autonomy of constitutional bodies like the EC and PSC has been questioned in recent political debates". Analyse the role of these institutions in safeguarding democratic governance and discuss measures to ensure their independence.

AnalyseDiscuss~250 words2 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce the context of debates surrounding the autonomy of constitutional bodies like the Election Commission of India (ECI) and Public Service Commissions (PSCs). Analyse their specific roles in upholding democratic processes and merit-based governance. Conclude with actionable measures recommended by commissions and judicial rulings to secure institutional independence.

Model answer

314 words

Introduction

Recent controversies—such as concerns over executive dominance in appointments under the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, and recurrent State Public Service Commission (SPSC) paper-leak scandals—have underscored the urgent necessity of safeguarding constitutional autonomy under Article 324 (ECI) and Article 315 (PSCs).

Role in Safeguarding Democratic Governance

  • Election Commission of India (Representative Democracy): Under Article 324, the ECI ensures free, fair, and periodic elections, enforces the Model Code of Conduct, and exercises crucial quasi-judicial powers, such as arbitrating intra-party disputes and symbol allocations under the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968.
  • Public Service Commissions (Administrative Impartiality): UPSC and SPSCs act as the institutional "watchdogs of merit" under Article 320. By ensuring objective, merit-based recruitment and advising on disciplinary matters, they insulate civil administration from partisan spoils and political patronage.

Measures to Ensure Institutional Independence

  • Bipartisan Selection Mechanisms: Revisit selection panels under the CEC Act, 2023—which substituted the Chief Justice of India with a Union Cabinet Minister—to reflect the collegiate spirit mandated in the Supreme Court's Anoop Baranwal (2023) verdict and mitigate executive hegemony.
  • Fiscal Independence: Bring the operational expenditures and salaries of the ECI under "charged expenditure" on the Consolidated Fund of India, at par with the existing constitutional status enjoyed by the UPSC under Article 322.
  • Equal Removal Protection: Extend constitutional tenure safeguards available to the Chief Election Commissioner (removal akin to a Supreme Court judge under Article 324(5)) to other Election Commissioners, as recommended by the Law Commission in its 255th Report.
  • Depoliticisation of SPSCs: Standardise transparent selection norms, institute mandatory cooling-off periods for members post-retirement, and strictly enforce governance reforms suggested by the Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) to curb recruitment malpractice.

Conclusion

Autonomy is the core pillar of constitutionalism. Upholding the independence of these bodies, envisioned by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar as the indispensable "bulwarks of the Constitution," is critical for sustaining public trust and democratic resilience.

Key facts to remember

case study
Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023)

A Constitution Bench held that the CEC and ECs should be appointed by the President on the advice of a committee comprising the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition, and the Chief Justice of India until Parliament enacted a dedicated law.

quote
“Described independent institutions—specifically the judiciary, the Election Commission, the Comptroller and Auditor General, and the Public Service Commission—as the crucial bulwarks of the Indian Constitution.”
— Dr. B.R. Ambedkar on Constitutional Bulwarks
scheme
Article 322 of the Indian Constitution

Mandates that the administrative expenses of the Union Public Service Commission, including salaries and pensions, are charged directly upon the Consolidated Fund of India, shielding them from parliamentary vote.

Frequently asked questions

Why are expenses of the UPSC and ECI treated differently?

While Article 322 explicitly charges the expenses of the UPSC on the Consolidated Fund of India, the Constitution does not provide an equivalent charged expenditure status for the Election Commission under Article 324, keeping its budget subject to executive voting.

← All questions on this topic (197)