UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IVEthicsPractice question

Role of Ethical Values in International Relations

National interest remains the primary driver of international relations. However, ethical considerations cannot be completely ignored. Discuss the role of ethical values in shaping international relations. Illustrate your answer with suitable examples.

DiscussIllustrate~250 words2 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce by contrasting the realist view of national interest with ethical imperatives in international relations. In the body, systematically discuss how ethical values such as equity, compassion, duty, and shared stewardship shape global diplomacy, illustrating each point with recent international examples. Conclude by reconciling national interest with ethical multilateralism using philosophical frameworks like Kant's Perpetual Peace and Panchsheel.

Model answer

273 words

Introduction

While classical realists like Hans Morgenthau argue that pure self-interest and power dictate international relations, an entirely amoral approach breeds conflict and systemic instability. Ethical values serve as essential guardrails, aligning sovereign national interests with collective welfare and long-term global stability.

Role of Ethical Values in Shaping International Relations

  • Equity and Justice: Ethical considerations elevate diplomacy beyond transactional or extractive engagements toward shared historical responsibility. For instance, the operationalisation of the Loss and Damage Fund (COP28, 2023) ethically obligates developed nations to support climate-vulnerable countries, operationalising the principle of climate justice.
  • Compassion and Global Kinship: Humanitarian aid offered unconditionally generates moral capital and soft power, even in the presence of bilateral tensions. For example, guided by the ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, India launched Operation Dost (2023) to deliver immediate earthquake relief to Turkey despite lingering geopolitical frictions.
  • Duty and Moral Restraint: Ethical frameworks constrain raw power dynamics, enforcing accountability, human rights protections, and non-aggression. Adherence to Just War Theory and the Geneva Conventions imposes moral obligations on nations to protect civilians and critical civilian infrastructure during hostilities, such as in the Gaza and Ukraine conflicts.
  • Ethical Stewardship of Global Commons: Ethical norms foster multilateral collaboration over zero-sum exploitation of shared planetary resources. This is reflected in frameworks like the Montreal Protocol and the adoption of the High Seas Treaty (BBNJ, 2023), which mandate equitable protection of marine biodiversity beyond national jurisdictions.

Conclusion

As envisaged in Immanuel Kant's idea of 'Perpetual Peace' and India's Panchsheel doctrine, sustainable national interest cannot be divorced from universal ethical duties. A rules-based, just, and cooperative world order ultimately remains the most effective safeguard for sovereign state security.

Key facts to remember

definition
Realism vs. Idealism in International Relations

Realism posits that states operate purely on national interest and power calculations, whereas Idealism (or Liberal Internationalism) contends that universal ethical values, law, and shared morality should guide state behavior.

example
Operation Dost (2023)

India dispatched search-and-rescue teams, field hospitals, and relief supplies to Turkey and Syria following the devastating February 2023 earthquake, exemplifying humanitarian diplomacy transcending diplomatic disputes.

scheme
Loss and Damage Fund (COP28, 2023)

A multilateral financial mechanism established to assist vulnerable nations facing severe climate impacts, rooted in the ethical premise of historical climate responsibility.

quote
Kant argued that true world peace can only emerge through a federation of free states bound by moral laws, civil constitutions, and universal hospitality rather than transient balances of power.
Immanuel Kant on Perpetual Peace

Frequently asked questions

Can a nation compromise its national interest for international ethics?

Rather than a compromise, ethical behavior often reinforces enlightened national interest by generating trust, enhancing soft power, and maintaining a stable, rules-based international system that ultimately preserves national sovereignty.