UPSC MainsPolitical Science (Optional)Indian PolityPractice question

Marxist Theory of Origin of State

According to the Marxist theory of the origin of the state, how is the state a product of class struggle? Explain in the light of Engels' book 'The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State'.

Explain~250 words2 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce the Marxist perspective by defining the state as a historical construct emerging from material conditions and class conflict. Detail Friedrich Engels' historical analysis from primitive communism through the emergence of private property, the patriarchal family, and the state as an instrument of class rule. Conclude with the teleological Marxist projection regarding the withering away of the state in a classless society.

Model answer

317 words

Introduction

According to the Marxist framework, the state is neither a natural nor an ethical institution, but a historical construct rooted in material conditions. In his foundational work, 'The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State' (1884), Friedrich Engels demonstrated that the state arose directly out of irreconcilable class antagonisms that accompanied the breakdown of primitive society and the division of society into exploiting and exploited classes.

Engels' Historical Analysis of the Origin of the State

Engels traced human social evolution to demonstrate how material changes in production transformed communal kinship groups into class-divided societies requiring a coercive apparatus.

  • Primitive Communism and the 'Gens' System: Early human societies functioned through matrilineal kinship clans (gens) characterized by collective ownership of resources and egalitarian social relations. In the absence of private property, surplus production, and opposing economic interests, no coercive public power or state machinery was necessary to maintain order.
  • Surplus, Private Property, and the Monogamous Family: Technological developments in pastoralism, agriculture, and metalworking generated an economic surplus, bringing about the accumulation of private property. To ensure legitimate heirs for property inheritance, the patriarchal monogamous family displaced the matrilineal system, an epochal shift Engels identified as the 'world historical defeat of the female sex.'
  • The State as an Instrument of Class Domination: As society split into property owners and propertyless labourers, conflict between these hostile economic interests threatened perpetual warfare. To prevent self-destruction while securing the privileges of the ruling class, an authority emerged that appeared to stand above society, but in reality functioned to hold class antagonisms in check and enforce the subjugation of the exploited.

Conclusion

Engels firmly established that the state is an artificial apparatus linked to private property, patriarchy, and economic exploitation. Because the state was established solely to manage irreconcilable class conflicts, Marxist political theory maintains that the abolition of private property and classes will inevitably cause the coercive state machinery to wither away.

Key facts to remember

definition
Irreconcilable Class Antagonisms

The fundamental contradiction of economic interests between the propertied and propertyless classes that cannot be peacefully resolved within existing property relations, necessitating a coercive state.

quote
'The overthrow of mother-right was the world historical defeat of the female sex,' marking the transition from matrilineal egalitarianism to the patriarchal monogamous family aimed at securing property inheritance.
Friedrich Engels on the Subjugation of Women
definition
The Gens System

A pre-state clan structure based on matrilineal kinship and collective ownership, which maintained social order without standing armies, police, or coercive legal machinery.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the state 'wither away' in Marxist theory?

Because the state exists solely as an instrument of class rule, the dissolution of private property and class antagonisms renders the coercive public authority obsolete, causing it to naturally wither away.