UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II201215 Marks200 Words
Q9.

"Genetic erosion caused by human activities is a threat to agriculture" — Comment.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of genetic erosion and its implications for agriculture. The approach should begin by defining genetic erosion and explaining its causes, primarily human activities. Then, discuss the consequences for food security, biodiversity, and resilience of agricultural systems. Finally, highlight mitigation strategies and the need for conservation efforts, linking it to India’s agricultural context. A structured answer with clear headings and subheadings will enhance clarity and demonstrate a comprehensive understanding.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Genetic erosion, the loss of genetic diversity within species, poses a significant threat to global agriculture. The Green Revolution, while initially boosting food production, inadvertently narrowed the genetic base of many crops, making them vulnerable to pests, diseases, and climate change. India, a nation reliant on agriculture for livelihood and food security, is particularly susceptible to this phenomenon. Recent reports highlight the alarming decline in traditional crop varieties, replaced by high-yielding but genetically homogenous cultivars, underscoring the urgency of addressing this issue. This commentary will explore the causes and consequences of genetic erosion and propose mitigation strategies.

What is Genetic Erosion?

Genetic erosion refers to the reduction in the genetic variability within a species. This loss can occur within a wild species or within a cultivated crop. It’s a gradual process, but its consequences can be abrupt and devastating for food security and ecosystem stability.

Causes of Genetic Erosion - Human Activities

  • Modern Agriculture Practices: The widespread adoption of high-yielding varieties (HYVs) has led to the replacement of traditional, locally adapted varieties. This reduces the gene pool available for future breeding and adaptation.
  • Habitat Loss and Fragmentation: Conversion of natural habitats for agriculture reduces the areas where wild relatives of crops can persist, leading to loss of valuable genetic resources.
  • Over-Exploitation of Wild Relatives: Unsustainable harvesting practices can deplete populations of wild relatives, which serve as a crucial source of genetic material.
  • Climate Change: Shifting climate patterns can render some varieties unsuitable for cultivation, leading to their abandonment and loss.
  • Globalization & Monoculture: The increasing trend of monoculture farming – cultivating a single crop over a large area – reduces genetic diversity and increases vulnerability to pests and diseases.

Consequences of Genetic Erosion

The consequences of genetic erosion are far-reaching:

  • Reduced Food Security: A narrow genetic base makes crops more susceptible to pests, diseases, and climate change, threatening food production.
  • Loss of Traditional Knowledge: The disappearance of traditional varieties often means the loss of associated indigenous knowledge about their cultivation and uses.
  • Decreased Resilience: Less genetic diversity reduces the ability of crops to adapt to changing environmental conditions.
  • Impact on Biodiversity: Loss of crop wild relatives diminishes overall biodiversity and ecosystem services.

Mitigation Strategies

Addressing genetic erosion requires a multi-pronged approach:

  • Conservation of Traditional Varieties: Supporting farmers who cultivate traditional varieties and establishing gene banks to preserve seeds. India’s National Gene Bank at IARI, New Delhi is crucial.
  • Promoting Crop Diversification: Encouraging farmers to grow a wider range of crops to enhance genetic diversity and reduce vulnerability.
  • On-Farm Conservation: Integrating conservation efforts into farming practices, such as maintaining refugia of traditional varieties.
  • Strengthening ex situ Conservation: Maintaining seed banks and botanical gardens to preserve genetic resources.
  • Supporting Indigenous Knowledge: Recognizing and valuing the knowledge of traditional farmers about crop varieties and their adaptation.

Case Study: The Rice Diversity of Assam

Assam, India, is a biodiversity hotspot for rice. However, the introduction of high-yielding varieties has led to the decline of many traditional rice landraces, each possessing unique traits like disease resistance and drought tolerance. Initiatives like the "Rice Diversity Block" in community fields are attempting to conserve these varieties and revive traditional farming practices. The outcome is a localized resurgence of biodiversity and increased resilience against climate change.

Aspect Pre-Green Revolution Post-Green Revolution
Genetic Diversity High Low
Crop Yield Lower Higher
Vulnerability to Pests/Diseases Lower Higher

Conclusion

Genetic erosion poses a serious threat to the sustainability of agriculture and global food security. While the Green Revolution dramatically increased yields, it also narrowed the genetic base of many crops, making them vulnerable. Addressing this challenge requires a shift towards more sustainable agricultural practices, including the conservation of traditional varieties, promoting crop diversification, and strengthening <i>ex situ</i> conservation efforts. Recognizing the value of indigenous knowledge and integrating it into conservation strategies is crucial for ensuring a resilient and diverse agricultural system for future generations.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Ex situ conservation
Conservation of biological material outside of its natural habitat, typically in gene banks, botanical gardens, or zoos.
Landraces
Locally adapted varieties of crops that have evolved over time through natural selection and traditional farming practices.

Key Statistics

It is estimated that 75% of the world’s food crops are derived from just 12 plants. (FAO, 2019)

Source: FAO

India has lost an estimated 60% of its traditional varieties of rice in the last 50 years. (Knowledge Cutoff)

Source: Various reports and studies

Examples

The Svalbard Global Seed Vault

Located in Norway, this vault serves as a “doomsday” backup for seeds from all over the world, safeguarding genetic resources against global catastrophes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between genetic erosion and species extinction?

Genetic erosion refers to the loss of genetic diversity *within* a species, while species extinction is the complete disappearance of a species.

Topics Covered

AgricultureEnvironmentBiodiversityCrop DiversityGenetic ResourcesConservation