UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II201215 Marks200 Words
Q10.

Differentiate between seed vigour and viability. How are the two assessed in a seed testing programme?

How to Approach

This question tests the understanding of fundamental seed quality parameters. A direct differentiation between vigor and viability is crucial. The answer should define each term clearly, explain the underlying physiological processes, and detail the standard assessment methods employed in seed testing laboratories, referencing ISTA guidelines where appropriate. A tabular comparison would be beneficial for clarity. Structuring the answer around definitions, differences, and assessment methods will ensure comprehensive coverage.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Seed quality is paramount for successful crop establishment and yield. While a seed may appear physically sound, its ability to germinate and produce a healthy seedling depends on several factors. Two critical components of seed quality are viability and vigour. Recent advancements in seed technology, including hybrid seed production and genetic engineering, have highlighted the importance of accurately assessing these qualities to ensure optimal crop performance and minimize yield losses. This answer will differentiate between seed vigour and viability, and outline the assessment methods used in a seed testing program.

Defining Seed Viability and Vigour

Seed Viability refers to the ability of a seed to germinate. It is an all-or-nothing characteristic; a viable seed either germinates or it doesn't. It primarily depends on the integrity of the embryo and the surrounding endosperm. A seed is considered viable if it has the potential to germinate under suitable conditions. Viability is largely determined by the structural integrity of the seed components, particularly the embryo.

Seed Vigour, on the other hand, is a more complex characteristic representing the overall seed quality, encompassing its potential for rapid, uniform, and friendly emergence. It reflects the seed’s ability to germinate and produce normal seedlings under less-than-ideal conditions. Vigour is influenced by factors like seed age, storage conditions, and the physiological status of the embryo and endosperm. A vigorous seed will germinate quickly and uniformly, even under stress conditions (e.g., low moisture, high temperature).

Key Differences Between Viability and Vigour

Feature Viability Vigour
Definition Ability to germinate Seedling density & uniformity under stress
Nature Binary (yes/no) Graded (high, medium, low)
Physiological Basis Structural integrity of embryo Metabolic activity, reserve food mobilization
Assessment Germination tests Germination tests under stress, seedling growth parameters
Influence of Environment Less affected by environmental stress Highly affected by environmental stress

Assessment Methods in a Seed Testing Programme

Seed testing programs typically follow guidelines established by organizations like the International Seed Testing Association (ISTA). The assessment involves both viability and vigour tests:

Viability Assessment

  • Germination Test (ISTA Procedures): This is the primary method. Seeds are placed on a suitable substrate (e.g., filter paper, sand) under controlled temperature and moisture conditions. Germination is monitored over a specific period (usually 7-14 days). The percentage of seeds that germinate is recorded as the germination percentage, indicating viability.
  • Tetrazolium Test (TZ): This is a rapid viability test, especially useful for small seeds or seeds that are difficult to germinate. Seeds are immersed in a tetrazolium solution, which stains the living tissues (embryo) red. The extent of staining indicates viability.

Vigour Assessment

  • Rapid Emergence Test (RET): Seeds are placed between filter paper and a porous membrane, and emergence is measured over a short period (e.g., 72 hours). Faster emergence indicates higher vigour.
  • Seedling Growth Potential (SGP): Seeds are germinated under controlled conditions, and seedling growth parameters (root length, shoot length, dry weight) are measured. Larger, healthier seedlings indicate higher vigour.
  • Cold Germination Test: Seeds are germinated at low temperatures (e.g., 5°C) to assess their ability to germinate under cold stress.
  • Electrical Conductivity Test: This test measures the leakage of ions from seeds. Higher leakage indicates lower vigour, as it suggests damage to cell membranes.

The ISTA Seed Testing Regulations (currently in its 2020 edition) provide detailed protocols for these tests.

Example: Assessing Rice Seed Quality

In rice seed production, vigour is particularly important due to the relatively long germination time and susceptibility to environmental stress. The RET and SGP tests are routinely used to differentiate between lots of rice seeds, ensuring farmers receive high-quality seeds that establish quickly and uniformly.

Case Study: Hybrid Maize Seed Quality Control

Hybrid maize seed production involves complex genetic crosses. Seed companies utilize vigour tests like RET and SGP to ensure the hybrid seeds possess adequate vigour to overcome the challenges of field conditions and provide consistent germination and seedling establishment. Failure to do so can lead to significant yield losses for farmers.

Conclusion

In essence, viability defines whether a seed *can* germinate, while vigour determines *how well* it germinates under varying conditions. Both are crucial for ensuring successful crop establishment. Seed testing programs utilize a combination of tests, with ISTA guidelines providing a standardized framework for assessment. Increasing awareness and stringent quality control measures are vital to ensure farmers receive seeds with both high viability and vigour, contributing to food security and sustainable agriculture.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

ISTA
International Seed Testing Association: A global organization that develops and publishes standardized seed testing procedures.
Tetrazolium Chloride
A dye used in the Tetrazolium Test. It stains living tissues red, allowing assessment of embryo viability without germination.

Key Statistics

Seed losses due to poor seed quality can account for up to 20% of crop yield globally (FAO, 2018 - Knowledge cutoff).

Source: FAO

Electrical Conductivity test can predict germination percentage with an accuracy of 80-90% (ISTA, Knowledge cutoff).

Source: ISTA

Examples

Cold Germination Test in Wheat

Wheat seeds are often tested for cold germination ability, particularly in regions with late springs or early frosts. This test assesses their ability to germinate under low-temperature stress, ensuring successful emergence even if the soil remains cold.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can seed vigour be improved?

Yes, vigour can be improved through proper seed handling, storage under optimal conditions (low temperature, low moisture), and selecting parent plants with inherently high vigour.

Topics Covered

AgricultureSeed TechnologyPlant BreedingSeed QualityGerminationSeed Testing