UPSC MainsANTHROPOLOGY-PAPER-I201415 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q22.

What are the stresses at high altitudes? How do better cardio-respiratory functions help the native highlanders in combating low environmental pressure?

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of human physiological adaptation. The approach should be to first outline the stresses associated with high altitude environments. Then, detail the cardio-respiratory adaptations observed in native highlanders. Finally, explain how these adaptations mitigate the stresses and enable survival. Structure the answer around these three core areas, using examples of specific populations and physiological mechanisms. A table comparing adaptations in lowland vs. highland populations could enhance clarity.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

High-altitude environments, characterized by reduced atmospheric pressure and lower partial pressure of oxygen (hypoxia), present significant physiological challenges to humans. The Himalayas, Andes, and Ethiopian Highlands are prime examples of regions where human populations have thrived for millennia, demonstrating remarkable adaptive capabilities. Initial exposure to high altitude results in acute mountain sickness (AMS) and other physiological stressors. However, indigenous populations have evolved genetic and physiological mechanisms to counteract these effects. This response will explore the stresses encountered at high altitude and how enhanced cardio-respiratory functions contribute to the survival of native highlanders.

Stresses at High Altitudes

The primary stressor at high altitude is hypoxia, but this triggers a cascade of secondary stresses. These can be broadly categorized as:

  • Hypoxia: Reduced oxygen availability impacts cellular respiration and overall metabolic function. The partial pressure of oxygen decreases by approximately 10% for every 1000 meters increase in altitude.
  • Barometric Pressure: Lower atmospheric pressure leads to increased water loss through respiration and skin, contributing to dehydration.
  • Cold Stress: High altitudes are often associated with colder temperatures, increasing the risk of hypothermia.
  • Increased UV Radiation: The thinner atmosphere offers less protection from harmful ultraviolet radiation.
  • Changes in Diet & Lifestyle: Limited food availability and unique cultural practices can also be stressors.

Cardio-Respiratory Adaptations in Native Highlanders

Native highlanders, through generations of adaptation, exhibit several physiological modifications that mitigate the effects of hypoxia. These can be divided into short-term acclimatization and long-term evolutionary adaptations:

Short-Term Acclimatization (within weeks/months)

  • Increased Ventilation: A faster breathing rate (hyperventilation) increases oxygen uptake.
  • Increased Heart Rate: A higher heart rate increases oxygen delivery to tissues.
  • Erythropoiesis: Increased production of red blood cells (RBCs) leads to higher hemoglobin levels, enhancing oxygen carrying capacity.
  • Increased 2,3-DPG: This molecule shifts the oxygen dissociation curve, facilitating oxygen release to tissues.

Long-Term Evolutionary Adaptations (over generations)

  • Larger Lung Volumes: Some populations (e.g., Tibetans) exhibit increased lung volumes compared to lowland populations.
  • Higher Capillary Density: Increased capillary density in tissues improves oxygen diffusion.
  • Mitochondrial Adaptations: Enhanced efficiency of mitochondrial oxygen utilization.
  • Genetic Adaptations: Specific gene variants related to oxygen transport and utilization are more prevalent in highlander populations. For instance, the EPAS1 gene (also known as HIF-2α) variant is common in Tibetans and is linked to reduced hemoglobin levels, preventing excessive RBC production and the associated risks of blood viscosity.

How Cardio-Respiratory Functions Combat Low Environmental Pressure

The combined effect of these adaptations allows native highlanders to thrive in hypoxic environments. Let's consider how each contributes:

  • Enhanced Oxygen Uptake & Transport: Increased ventilation and higher hemoglobin levels ensure sufficient oxygen delivery to tissues despite the lower partial pressure.
  • Improved Oxygen Diffusion: Higher capillary density minimizes the diffusion distance, optimizing oxygen transfer from blood to cells.
  • Efficient Oxygen Utilization: Mitochondrial adaptations and genetic variations optimize oxygen consumption at the cellular level, minimizing the impact of hypoxia.
  • Reduced Physiological Strain: The EPAS1 variant in Tibetans, for example, prevents excessive erythrocytosis, reducing the workload on the heart and minimizing the risk of pulmonary hypertension.
Characteristic Lowland Populations (at Sea Level) Highland Populations (at High Altitude)
Hemoglobin Levels ~15 g/dL ~18-22 g/dL (varies by population)
Ventilation Rate (at rest) ~12 breaths/min ~20-30 breaths/min
Lung Volume ~3-4 Liters ~4-6 Liters (generally higher)
EPAS1 Gene Variant Rare Common (particularly in Tibetans)

Case Study: Tibetans and the EPAS1 Gene

The Tibetan population, residing in the Tibetan Plateau (average altitude 4,000 meters), exhibits a unique adaptation involving a variant of the EPAS1 gene. This variant reduces the production of hemoglobin, preventing the excessive red blood cell production seen in other high-altitude populations. This adaptation minimizes the risk of blood thickening and pulmonary hypertension, demonstrating a fine-tuned physiological response to chronic hypoxia.

Conclusion

In conclusion, high-altitude environments pose significant physiological challenges, primarily due to hypoxia. Native highlander populations have developed a combination of short-term acclimatization responses and long-term evolutionary adaptations, particularly in their cardio-respiratory systems. These adaptations, ranging from increased ventilation and hemoglobin levels to genetic variations like the EPAS1 variant in Tibetans, enable them to thrive in these demanding environments. Further research into these adaptations holds potential for developing therapies for hypoxic conditions and improving human health in challenging environments.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Hypoxia
A condition in which the body or a region of the body is deprived of adequate oxygen supply.
2,3-DPG
2,3-Diphosphoglycerate, a molecule in red blood cells that shifts the oxygen dissociation curve, promoting oxygen release to tissues.

Key Statistics

The partial pressure of oxygen decreases by approximately 10% for every 1000 meters increase in altitude.

Source: Basic Physiological Principles

Tibetans have significantly lower hemoglobin levels (around 16 g/dL) compared to other high-altitude adapted populations, which can have levels up to 22 g/dL.

Source: Scientific publications on Tibetan adaptation (Knowledge cutoff)

Examples

Andean Highlanders

Andean populations, such as those in Peru and Bolivia, have developed increased lung volumes and higher capillary density in their muscles.

Ethiopian Highlanders

Ethiopian highlanders exhibit a combination of increased ventilation and a slightly higher hemoglobin concentration compared to lowland populations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why don't all highlander populations have the same adaptations?

Adaptations are shaped by the specific selective pressures faced by each population, including the altitude, diet, lifestyle, and genetic history.

Can lowland populations acclimatize to high altitude?

Yes, lowland populations can acclimatize through physiological changes like increased ventilation and erythropoiesis, but their adaptations are typically less pronounced than those of native highlanders.

Topics Covered

AnthropologyBiologyPhysiologyHuman Adaptation, Physiological Responses, Environmental Stress