Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
Special Economic Zones (SEZs) are designated geographical areas within a country that operate under different economic regulations than other regions. They are intended to promote industrial development, manufacturing, and exports by offering tax incentives and streamlined administrative procedures. Introduced in India in 2005, the SEZ Act aimed to attract foreign investment and boost economic growth. However, despite initial success, the SEZ scheme has faced numerous challenges, leading to a slowdown in their growth and effectiveness. Recognizing their potential, a thorough examination of the issues plaguing SEZs – particularly concerning taxation, governing laws, and administration – is essential for their augmentation and revitalization.
Taxation Issues
The initial tax benefits offered under the SEZ Act, such as exemptions from income tax, excise duty, and customs duty, were a major draw for investors. However, subsequent changes, particularly the introduction of the Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) in 2011 and the sunset clause for existing benefits, significantly eroded the attractiveness of SEZs.
- MAT imposition: The imposition of MAT on SEZ developers and units reduced the net benefits and increased the cost of doing business.
- Sunset Clause: The phasing out of tax incentives for SEZs established after 2012 created uncertainty and discouraged new investments.
- GST complexities: The implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) introduced complexities regarding the treatment of SEZ transactions, leading to disputes and administrative hurdles. While units are generally exempt from GST on supplies to DTA, complexities arise in inter-unit transfers and procurement.
Governing Laws & Regulations
The legal framework governing SEZs has been criticized for being complex and lacking clarity. Several overlapping regulations and bureaucratic procedures create bottlenecks for businesses operating within SEZs.
- Land Acquisition: Acquiring land for SEZ development has been a major challenge, often leading to delays and social unrest. The Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, while aiming to protect the rights of landowners, has further complicated the process.
- Multiple Approvals: SEZ developers and units require approvals from various authorities, including the Board of Approval, customs authorities, and state governments, leading to delays and increased compliance costs.
- Dispute Resolution: The absence of a dedicated and efficient dispute resolution mechanism for SEZ-related issues adds to the challenges faced by investors.
Administrative Issues
Inefficient administration and lack of coordination between different government agencies have hampered the effective functioning of SEZs.
- Infrastructure Deficiencies: Many SEZs lack adequate infrastructure, such as power, water, and transportation facilities, hindering their operational efficiency.
- Lack of Coordination: Poor coordination between central and state governments, as well as between different departments within the government, leads to delays in approvals and implementation of projects.
- Monitoring & Evaluation: Inadequate monitoring and evaluation of SEZ performance have resulted in a lack of accountability and transparency. The Rangarajan Committee (2011) highlighted the need for a robust monitoring mechanism.
| Issue Area | Specific Problem | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Taxation | Imposition of MAT | Reduced net benefits, discouraged investment |
| Governing Laws | Complex Land Acquisition | Project delays, social unrest |
| Administration | Infrastructure Deficiencies | Reduced operational efficiency |
Conclusion
The success of SEZs as engines of industrial development and export growth hinges on addressing the issues related to taxation, governing laws, and administration. Streamlining the tax regime, simplifying regulations, improving infrastructure, and fostering better coordination between government agencies are crucial steps. A re-evaluation of the sunset clause and a more investor-friendly approach are also necessary. While the current focus has shifted towards Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes, augmenting the SEZ framework remains vital for diversifying India’s export basket and attracting foreign investment, contributing to a more robust and competitive economy.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.