Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
India has historically maintained a strong relationship with Palestine, rooted in its anti-colonial past and solidarity with the Palestinian national movement. This support was formalized through consistent diplomatic and financial assistance, and vocal advocacy for a two-state solution. However, in recent decades, India’s relationship with Israel has undergone a significant transformation, marked by increased cooperation in areas like defense, agriculture, and technology. This evolving dynamic raises questions about whether India’s traditional commitment to Palestinian statehood has been altered, or if it has managed to navigate a more balanced approach. The question necessitates an examination of whether the burgeoning Indo-Israeli partnership has fundamentally reshaped India’s stance on the Palestinian issue.
Historical Context: India’s Traditional Stance
For decades, India’s foreign policy towards the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was firmly rooted in its support for the Palestinian cause. This stemmed from several factors:
- Anti-Colonial Legacy: India, having experienced colonialism itself, identified with the Palestinian struggle against occupation.
- Solidarity with the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM): India’s membership in NAM, which generally supported the Palestinian cause, influenced its policy.
- Domestic Political Considerations: A significant Muslim population within India historically favored a pro-Palestinian stance.
India was one of the first countries to recognize the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1974 and consistently voted in favor of UN resolutions supporting Palestinian rights. However, full diplomatic relations with Israel were only established in 1992, following the Oslo Accords.
The Shift in Indo-Israeli Relations
The 1990s witnessed a gradual but significant shift in India’s approach to Israel, driven by:
- Strategic Convergence: Shared concerns regarding terrorism and regional instability led to increased security cooperation.
- Economic Opportunities: Israel emerged as a key partner in areas like defense technology, agriculture, and water management.
- Changing Global Dynamics: The end of the Cold War and the rise of new geopolitical realities prompted India to diversify its foreign policy.
This shift culminated in a series of high-level visits and agreements, including defense deals worth billions of dollars. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Israel in 2017 was a landmark event, signifying a further deepening of ties. The Abraham Accords in 2020, normalizing relations between Israel and several Arab nations, also provided a new context for India’s engagement with both sides.
Impact on India’s Stand on Palestinian Statehood
While strengthening ties with Israel, India has maintained its support for a two-state solution and the creation of a viable Palestinian state. However, the nature of this support has evolved:
- De-Hyphenation: India has consistently emphasized that its relationship with Israel is independent of its relationship with Palestine – a policy of ‘de-hyphenation’.
- Balanced Approach: India continues to provide financial assistance to Palestine and supports UN resolutions affirming Palestinian rights, but its rhetoric has become more nuanced.
- Increased Engagement with Both Sides: India has actively engaged with both Israeli and Palestinian leaders, attempting to play a mediating role.
Despite the closer ties with Israel, India has not altered its recognition of the State of Palestine. However, critics argue that the increased focus on strategic and economic cooperation with Israel has diminished the prominence of the Palestinian issue in India’s foreign policy calculations. The recent abstention from votes at the UN criticizing Israel, while explained by India as a matter of principle, has also raised concerns among Palestinian supporters.
Recent Developments
The October 2023 Hamas attack on Israel and the subsequent conflict in Gaza have further tested India’s balancing act. India reiterated its support for a two-state solution and called for de-escalation, while also expressing solidarity with Israel in the face of terrorism. This demonstrates India’s attempt to maintain a pragmatic approach, acknowledging Israel’s security concerns while upholding its long-standing commitment to Palestinian rights.
Conclusion
The Indo-Israeli relationship has undoubtedly introduced new dynamics into India’s foreign policy in the Middle East. While India has significantly strengthened its ties with Israel, it has not entirely abandoned its traditional support for Palestinian statehood. Instead, it has adopted a more nuanced and pragmatic approach, emphasizing ‘de-hyphenation’ and engaging with both sides. The challenge for India lies in maintaining this balance, ensuring that its growing relationship with Israel does not come at the expense of its long-held commitment to a just and lasting resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The future will likely see India continuing to navigate this complex landscape, seeking to play a constructive role in promoting peace and stability in the region.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.