UPSC MainsGENERAL-STUDIES-PAPER-I201815 Marks250 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q13.

Why indentured labour was taken by the British from India to other colonies? Have they been able to preserve their cultural identity over there?

How to Approach

This question requires a two-pronged answer. First, analyze the historical context of indentured labour – why the British utilized it. Focus on the post-abolition of slavery context, economic motivations, and the colonies where it was prevalent. Second, assess the extent to which these diaspora communities have retained their cultural identity, acknowledging both preservation and assimilation. Structure the answer chronologically, then thematically, covering different regions and aspects of cultural preservation. Include examples of cultural practices, languages, and religious traditions.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1833 created a significant labour shortage in its colonies, particularly in sugar-producing regions. To address this, the British implemented a system of indentured labour, recruiting workers – primarily from India, but also from China and other parts of the world – under fixed-term contracts. This system, while legally distinct from slavery, often involved exploitative conditions. Between 1834 and 1920, over 3.3 million Indians were transported to colonies like Mauritius, Fiji, Trinidad & Tobago, Guyana, South Africa, and Malaysia. The question of whether these communities have preserved their cultural identity in these new environments is a complex one, marked by both resilience and adaptation.

The Rise of Indentured Labour

Following the abolition of slavery, plantation owners in British colonies demanded a new source of cheap labour. India, with its large population and land pressures, became a prime recruiting ground. Several factors drove this demand:

  • Economic Needs: Sugar, tea, and rubber plantations required a large, readily available workforce.
  • Post-Abolition Vacuum: The end of slavery left a significant labour gap.
  • Recruitment Practices: Recruiters, often operating through deceptive practices, lured Indians with promises of better wages and opportunities. The Emigration Act of 1858 was enacted to regulate recruitment, but abuses continued.

The initial destinations were Mauritius (1834), followed by Guyana, Trinidad & Tobago, Fiji, and South Africa. The conditions on these plantations were often harsh, resembling slavery in many respects, with long working hours, low wages, and limited freedoms.

Cultural Preservation and Transformation

The preservation of cultural identity among the Indian diaspora varied significantly depending on the colony, the size of the community, and the prevailing social and political conditions. Several key aspects of cultural preservation are noteworthy:

Language

Languages like Hindi, Bhojpuri, Tamil, and Telugu were initially maintained within families and communities. However, over generations, creolized languages emerged, blending Indian languages with English and local tongues. For example, Caribbean Hindustani is a distinct language evolved from Bhojpuri. While the original languages have diminished in usage, they continue to influence vocabulary and cultural expression.

Religion

Hinduism and Islam were the dominant religions among indentured labourers. Temples and mosques were established, often serving as community centers. Religious festivals like Diwali, Holi, Eid, and Muharram were celebrated, providing a sense of continuity and belonging. Syncretism – the blending of religious beliefs and practices – also occurred, with elements of local religions being incorporated into Indian traditions.

Social Structures & Customs

Traditional social structures, such as joint family systems and caste hierarchies (though often weakened), were initially maintained. Marriage customs, dietary habits, and traditional medicine practices were also preserved. However, these structures underwent significant changes over time due to factors like urbanization, education, and intermarriage with other communities.

Cultural Expressions: Music and Dance

Forms of Indian classical and folk music and dance were adapted and evolved in the diaspora. For instance, the Chutney music of Trinidad & Tobago is a fusion of Indian folk music, calypso, and soca. Similarly, dance forms like Kathak were modified to reflect local influences.

Regional Variations

Colony Cultural Preservation Level Key Features
Mauritius High Large Indian population (approx. 68%), strong Hindu presence, Bhojpuri widely spoken, preservation of traditional festivals.
Fiji Moderate Significant Indian population (approx. 38%), Hinduism and Islam prominent, Girmit Day (commemorating arrival of indentured labourers) celebrated, but increasing assimilation.
Trinidad & Tobago Moderate Large Indian population (approx. 40%), vibrant Hindu culture, development of unique cultural forms like Chutney music, but significant cultural blending.
South Africa Moderate to Low Indian community faced racial discrimination under apartheid, leading to some cultural suppression, but preservation of religious practices and language within families.

Conclusion

The indentured labour system was a complex chapter in colonial history, driven by economic necessity and resulting in significant social and cultural consequences. While the Indian diaspora faced immense hardship and exploitation, they demonstrated remarkable resilience in preserving aspects of their cultural identity. However, this preservation was not static; it involved adaptation, syncretism, and a degree of assimilation. The legacy of indentured labour continues to shape the cultural landscape of these nations, serving as a testament to the enduring spirit of the Indian diaspora.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Creolization
The process by which a pidgin language develops into a fully-fledged language with its own grammar and vocabulary, often resulting from the contact between different languages and cultures.

Key Statistics

Over 1.4 million Indians were sent to Mauritius between 1834 and 1920.

Source: UNESCO, "The History of Indentured Labour"

Approximately 60% of the population of Mauritius is of Indian descent.

Source: World Bank Data (as of 2023)

Examples

Girmit Day

Celebrated in Fiji and other Caribbean nations, Girmit Day commemorates the arrival of the first indentured labourers from India. It is a day of remembrance, reflection, and celebration of the contributions of the Indian diaspora.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was indentured labour truly different from slavery?

While legally distinct, indentured labour often shared many characteristics with slavery, including harsh working conditions, limited freedoms, and physical abuse. The power imbalance between employers and labourers often rendered the contracts exploitative, blurring the lines between the two systems.

Topics Covered

HistorySocial IssuesIndian DiasporaColonialismMigration patternsCultural preservationSocial history