UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-I201915 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q23.

Analyse the incentive oriented programmes for removing regional imbalances in socio-economic development of India.

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer. We need to define regional imbalances, identify the incentive-oriented programs designed to address them, and analyze their effectiveness. The answer should be structured around different types of incentives (fiscal, infrastructural, and regulatory), providing specific examples of programs under each category. A critical assessment of these programs, highlighting both successes and failures, is crucial. The answer should also touch upon the constitutional provisions related to equitable development.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Regional imbalances in socio-economic development have been a persistent challenge in India since independence, stemming from historical factors, geographical disparities, and policy choices. These imbalances manifest in variations in per capita income, poverty rates, access to education and healthcare, and infrastructure development across states. To address this, the Indian government has implemented a range of incentive-oriented programs aimed at promoting balanced regional growth. These programs, often rooted in the Directive Principles of State Policy (Article 38(2) and Article 46), seek to incentivize investment and development in less developed regions, thereby reducing disparities and fostering inclusive growth.

Understanding Regional Imbalances

Regional imbalances in India are not merely economic; they are deeply intertwined with social and political factors. Historically, certain regions benefited from colonial policies and early industrialization, while others remained largely agrarian and underdeveloped. This legacy continues to shape the development landscape. The concept of ‘backwardness’ is often defined using composite indices considering economic, social, and infrastructure indicators.

Types of Incentive-Oriented Programs

1. Fiscal Incentives

Fiscal incentives are perhaps the most common approach to address regional imbalances. These involve tax breaks, subsidies, and financial assistance to businesses and individuals investing in designated backward areas.

  • Industrial Policy Resolutions (1956 & 1991): These resolutions laid the foundation for promoting industrial development in backward areas through various concessions.
  • Tax Holidays: Offering exemptions from income tax and other taxes for a specified period to units established in backward regions.
  • Investment Subsidies: Providing financial assistance to cover a portion of the capital investment in eligible projects.
  • Central Sales Tax (CST) Compensation: Compensating states for revenue losses due to the CST, particularly benefiting manufacturing states.

2. Infrastructural Incentives

Developing infrastructure in backward regions is crucial for attracting investment and promoting economic activity. This includes investments in transportation, power, communication, and irrigation.

  • Backward Regions Grant Fund (BRGF): Launched in 2006, BRGF provided funds to 256 districts identified as backward based on the 2001 census. The focus was on infrastructure development and livelihood support. (Knowledge Cutoff: 2023)
  • Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY): Aims to connect eligible habitations with a population of 500 persons or more (250 persons in hilly areas) with all-weather roads.
  • Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFC): While not exclusively for backward regions, DFCs improve connectivity and reduce logistics costs, benefiting industries in surrounding areas.
  • National Highway Development Project (NHDP): Expansion and improvement of the national highway network, enhancing connectivity to remote and underdeveloped regions.

3. Regulatory and Institutional Incentives

These incentives involve easing regulations, simplifying procedures, and establishing institutions to support development in backward areas.

  • North East Industrial and Investment Promotion Policy (NEIIPP): Provides substantial incentives for industries setting up operations in the North Eastern states, including tax benefits, capital subsidies, and infrastructure support.
  • Special Category Status (SCS): Granted to certain states (primarily North Eastern states, hilly states, and some others), providing them with preferential treatment in central funding and other benefits.
  • Establishment of Industrial Growth Centres (IGCs): Creating dedicated industrial zones with pre-developed infrastructure and streamlined regulatory processes.
  • Skill Development Initiatives: Programs like the National Skill Development Mission aim to enhance the skills of the workforce in backward regions, making them more attractive to investors.

Effectiveness and Challenges

While these incentive-oriented programs have yielded some positive results, their overall effectiveness has been mixed. Several challenges hinder their success:

  • Leakage and Corruption: Funds allocated for development often get diverted due to corruption and inefficient implementation.
  • Lack of Complementary Infrastructure: Incentives alone are not enough; they need to be accompanied by adequate infrastructure and a conducive business environment.
  • Political Interference: Political considerations can influence the selection of beneficiaries and the allocation of resources.
  • Limited Private Sector Participation: Attracting private investment remains a challenge in many backward regions due to perceived risks and uncertainties.
  • Data Deficiencies: Accurate and reliable data on regional disparities are often lacking, making it difficult to target interventions effectively.
Program Type of Incentive Key Features Effectiveness
BRGF Fiscal & Infrastructural Funds for infrastructure & livelihood in backward districts Moderate; impacted by implementation issues & lack of monitoring.
NEIIPP Fiscal & Regulatory Tax benefits, subsidies for industries in NE states Significant; attracted investment but faced challenges related to land acquisition & infrastructure.
PMGSY Infrastructural Road connectivity to eligible habitations High; significantly improved rural connectivity & access to markets.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while India has implemented a comprehensive array of incentive-oriented programs to address regional imbalances, their impact has been uneven. A more holistic approach is needed, focusing not only on fiscal and infrastructural incentives but also on improving governance, promoting skill development, and fostering a conducive business environment. Strengthening monitoring mechanisms, ensuring transparency, and promoting greater private sector participation are crucial for achieving equitable and sustainable regional development. Furthermore, a nuanced understanding of the specific challenges faced by each region is essential for tailoring interventions effectively.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Regional Imbalance
Disparities in socio-economic development across different regions within a country, often measured by indicators like per capita income, poverty rates, and access to basic amenities.
Special Category Status (SCS)
A status granted by the central government to certain states, providing them with preferential treatment in central funding, tax concessions, and other benefits, aimed at accelerating their development.

Key Statistics

As per the Economic Survey 2022-23, the income inequality (measured by the Gini coefficient) has been rising in India, indicating widening regional disparities.

Source: Economic Survey 2022-23

According to the NITI Aayog's National Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) 2023, regional disparities in poverty levels remain significant, with some states having much higher MPI scores than others.

Source: NITI Aayog National MPI 2023

Examples

Vidarbha Region, Maharashtra

The Vidarbha region in Maharashtra has historically suffered from agricultural distress and limited industrial development, despite various government interventions. This highlights the challenges of addressing deeply entrenched regional imbalances.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of the Finance Commission in addressing regional imbalances?

The Finance Commission plays a crucial role by recommending the principles governing the distribution of tax revenues between the Centre and the states, and among the states themselves. It uses various criteria, including demographic performance, income distance, and forest cover, to ensure equitable distribution of resources.

Topics Covered

EconomyPolityRegional DevelopmentEconomic PolicySocial Welfare