Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
C.N. Vakil (1897-1977) was a prominent Indian economist and planner, deeply involved in shaping India’s economic policies during and after independence. Trained in the Fabian tradition, Vakil distinguished himself through his advocacy for decentralized planning, emphasizing the crucial role of local communities and institutions in economic development. Unlike the dominant centralized planning approach favored by many contemporaries, Vakil believed that genuine economic progress could only be achieved by empowering local bodies and fostering self-reliance at the grassroots level. His work provided a critical counterpoint to the prevailing top-down planning models and continues to be relevant in contemporary discussions on inclusive growth.
Early Influences and Pre-Independence Work
Vakil’s early career was shaped by his association with the Servants of India Society, founded by G.K. Gokhale. This instilled in him a commitment to social reform and economic upliftment. Before independence, Vakil served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Bombay Presidency. During this period, he focused on issues of land revenue, agricultural finance, and rural development. He recognized the limitations of a purely centralized approach to economic planning, even then advocating for greater local participation.
The People’s Plan and Decentralized Planning
Vakil’s most significant contribution came with the formulation of the ‘People’s Plan’ in 1948-49. He was appointed as the Chairman of the Planning Sub-Committee of the Indian National Congress’s All India Congress Committee (AICC) in 1948. This committee was tasked with preparing a plan based on initiatives taken by people at the village level. Unlike the then-dominant Harrod-Domar model being advocated by P.C. Mahalanobis, Vakil’s plan was bottom-up.
- Key Features of the People’s Plan: It involved collecting plans from over 55,000 villages and towns across India. These plans focused on local needs and resources, emphasizing small-scale industries, irrigation projects, animal husbandry, and education.
- Emphasis on Local Resources: The plan prioritized the mobilization of local resources – both human and material – to minimize dependence on external funding.
- Decentralized Implementation: Vakil envisioned a system where local bodies (Panchayats) would be responsible for implementing the plans, fostering self-governance and accountability.
Critique of the First Five-Year Plan
Despite the extensive groundwork laid by the People’s Plan, the First Five-Year Plan (1951-56) largely adopted the centralized, heavy-industry focused model advocated by Mahalanobis. Vakil strongly criticized this approach, arguing that it neglected the needs of the rural population and exacerbated regional inequalities. He believed that the emphasis on large-scale industries would create a dualistic economy, benefiting a small elite while leaving the majority behind. He argued that the plan lacked a clear understanding of the Indian socio-economic reality and was overly influenced by Western models.
Post-Plan Contributions and Legacy
Vakil continued to advocate for decentralized planning throughout his career. He served on various committees and commissions, consistently emphasizing the importance of local participation and self-reliance. He authored several books and articles outlining his vision for a more equitable and sustainable economic development model. His ideas influenced subsequent policy debates, particularly regarding the role of Panchayati Raj institutions. While his vision wasn’t fully implemented, his emphasis on decentralization laid the groundwork for later initiatives like the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments (1992-93) which formalized local self-governance.
| Feature | Vakil’s People’s Plan | First Five-Year Plan |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Bottom-up, Decentralized | Top-down, Centralized |
| Focus | Rural development, Small-scale industries | Heavy industry, Large-scale projects |
| Resource Mobilization | Local resources | Centralized funding |
Conclusion
C.N. Vakil’s contribution to Indian Economic Planning lies in his pioneering advocacy for decentralized planning and his unwavering belief in the potential of local communities. Though his ‘People’s Plan’ was not fully adopted, it served as a crucial critique of the prevailing centralized models and highlighted the importance of inclusive growth. His ideas continue to resonate in contemporary debates on rural development, local governance, and sustainable economic planning, reminding us of the need to prioritize the needs and aspirations of the people at the grassroots level.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.