UPSC MainsENGLISH-COMPULSORY202210 Marks
Q39.

He is a learned man. He cannot make that mistake. (Combine the sentence by using 'too' – 'to')

How to Approach

This question tests basic English grammar – specifically, the correct usage of ‘too…to’. The approach should involve understanding the original sentence's meaning, identifying the relationship between the two clauses, and then restructuring the sentence using the ‘too…to’ construction while preserving the original meaning. The answer should demonstrate a clear understanding of grammatical rules and the ability to apply them accurately.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Grammar forms the bedrock of effective communication, and a precise understanding of sentence structures is crucial for conveying meaning accurately. The given sentence presents a statement about a learned man and his presumed inability to make a mistake. Combining this into a single sentence using the ‘too…to’ construction requires recognizing the inherent implication – that his learning prevents him from making the mistake. This construction expresses inability due to a quality or characteristic.

The original sentence states: “He is a learned man. He cannot make that mistake.” To combine these sentences using ‘too…to’, we need to express the idea that his learning is the reason he cannot make the mistake. The correct combined sentence is:

Combined Sentence:

He is too learned to make that mistake.

Explanation of the Transformation:

  • ‘Too’ indicates an excessive degree of a quality. In this case, the quality is ‘learned’.
  • ‘To’ introduces the infinitive form of the verb, indicating the action that is impossible due to the preceding quality.
  • The structure ‘too + adjective + to + infinitive’ signifies that the degree of the adjective prevents the action from happening.

Let's break down why this construction works:

  • The original sentence implies a causal relationship: his learning prevents the mistake.
  • The ‘too…to’ structure directly expresses this causal relationship. His learning is *so great* that it prevents him from making the mistake.

Incorrect attempts might include:

  • “He is too learned and cannot make that mistake.” (This simply joins the sentences with ‘and’ and doesn’t utilize the ‘too…to’ construction.)
  • “He is to learned to make that mistake.” (Incorrect grammatical structure.)

The ‘too…to’ construction is a common grammatical pattern used to express inability. It’s important to remember that the adjective preceding ‘too’ describes a quality that is excessive enough to prevent the action following ‘to’ from occurring. This construction is frequently used in formal writing and is essential for demonstrating grammatical proficiency.

Example of similar sentence structures:

  • The coffee is too hot to drink.
  • The problem is too complex to solve easily.
  • He is too shy to speak in public.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the correct combination of the given sentences using ‘too…to’ is “He is too learned to make that mistake.” This demonstrates a clear understanding of the grammatical structure and its application in conveying the original meaning effectively. Mastering such constructions is vital for precise and articulate communication, a skill highly valued in academic and professional settings.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Infinitive
The infinitive is the basic form of a verb, usually preceded by "to" (e.g., to run, to eat, to think). It functions as a noun, adjective, or adverb.
Adjective
An adjective is a word that modifies a noun or pronoun, providing more information about its qualities or characteristics (e.g., learned, beautiful, large).

Key Statistics

According to a 2023 study by Cambridge Assessment English, approximately 70% of non-native English speakers struggle with complex grammatical structures like ‘too…to’.

Source: Cambridge Assessment English, 2023

A 2022 report by the British Council indicated that errors in grammar and sentence structure are among the top three reasons why international students face challenges in academic writing.

Source: British Council, 2022

Examples

Real-world application

In legal writing, precise grammatical structures are crucial. A misapplication of ‘too…to’ could alter the intended meaning of a contract or legal document, leading to disputes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between 'too...to' and 'so...that'?

Both express consequence, but 'too...to' indicates inability, while 'so...that' indicates a result. For example: "He is too weak to lift the box" (inability) vs. "He was so weak that he couldn't lift the box" (result).