UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II202215 Marks
Q8.

Why does an anisotropic mineral, viewed under crossed polars, suffer four times of complete extinction during a 360° rotation of microscope stage? What is pleochroism and how is it determined?

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of optical mineralogy, specifically anisotropic minerals and pleochroism. The approach should involve explaining the concept of extinction in anisotropic minerals under crossed polars, detailing why four extinctions occur during a 360° rotation, and then defining pleochroism and explaining how it is determined. The answer should be structured logically, starting with the basics of anisotropy and building towards the more complex concepts. Diagrams, though not explicitly requested, would be beneficial for understanding.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Anisotropic minerals, unlike isotropic minerals, exhibit properties that vary with the direction of light passing through them. This directionality arises from their crystal structure lacking cubic symmetry. When observed under a petrographic microscope with crossed polars (polarizing filters oriented 90 degrees to each other), anisotropic minerals display interference colors and extinction phenomena. The complete extinction of an anisotropic mineral occurs when the vibration directions of light passing through the mineral are perpendicular to both the polarizer and analyzer. This question delves into the reason for four extinctions during a 360° rotation and explores the phenomenon of pleochroism, a crucial tool in mineral identification.

Anisotropy and Extinction under Crossed Polars

Anisotropic minerals possess a refractive index that varies depending on the direction of light propagation. This is described by two refractive indices, nω and nε, representing the ordinary and extraordinary rays respectively. When light enters an anisotropic mineral, it splits into these two rays, each traveling at a different velocity and with a different refractive index. Under crossed polars, the interference color observed depends on the thickness of the mineral grain and the difference between nω and nε (birefringence).

Extinction refers to the complete loss of interference color, appearing as a dark area. This happens when the vibration directions of both the ordinary and extraordinary rays are aligned parallel or perpendicular to the polarizer and analyzer. For an anisotropic mineral, extinction doesn’t occur in all orientations. Instead, it occurs at specific angles due to the orientation of the optic axes within the crystal.

Four Extinctions During 360° Rotation

The reason for four extinctions during a 360° rotation of the microscope stage is directly related to the symmetry of the indicatrix, the geometric representation of refractive indices in an anisotropic mineral. The indicatrix is an ellipsoid, and its shape dictates the extinction behavior.

  • Optic Axes: Anisotropic minerals have two optic axes, which are directions within the crystal where light travels with equal velocity (nω = nε).
  • Fast and Slow Directions: The directions of fastest and slowest light propagation are perpendicular to the optic axes.
  • Rotation and Extinction: As the stage is rotated, the orientation of the mineral’s crystallographic axes relative to the polarizer and analyzer changes.
  • Four Extinction Positions: For most uniaxial minerals, complete extinction occurs four times during a 360° rotation. This is because the vibration directions of both rays can be aligned with the polarizer and analyzer in four different orientations. These orientations are related to the symmetry of the crystal and the position of the optic axis.

The angle between successive extinction positions is typically 90° for uniaxial minerals. Biaxial minerals exhibit more complex extinction patterns, but the principle remains the same – extinction occurs when the vibration directions of both rays align with the polarizer and analyzer.

Pleochroism: Definition and Determination

Pleochroism is the optical property of certain anisotropic minerals where the color of the mineral changes when viewed in different polarization directions. This occurs because the mineral absorbs light differently depending on the direction of vibration of the light waves. The absorption of light is related to the electronic structure of the mineral and the wavelengths of light that are absorbed.

How Pleochroism is Determined

Pleochroism is determined by rotating the mineral grain (or the stage) under crossed polars while observing the color changes. The process involves:

  • Rotating the Stage: The mineral is rotated 360° while observing its color under the microscope.
  • Identifying Color Changes: The observer notes the different colors displayed by the mineral as it is rotated.
  • Describing Pleochroic Scheme: The pleochroic scheme is described by listing the colors observed in the directions of maximum and minimum absorption. For example, a mineral might exhibit a pleochroic scheme of "dark green to pale yellow."
  • Use of Rotating Stage: A rotating stage is essential for accurately determining pleochroism, as it allows for precise control over the orientation of the mineral.

Pleochroism is a valuable diagnostic tool in mineral identification, particularly for minerals that lack strong cleavage or other easily identifiable features. It is commonly used to identify minerals like tourmaline, biotite, and hornblende.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the four extinctions observed in anisotropic minerals under crossed polars are a direct consequence of their anisotropic nature and the symmetry of their indicatrix. Pleochroism, the change in color with polarization direction, provides a crucial diagnostic property for mineral identification. Understanding these optical properties is fundamental to petrographic analysis and geological interpretation, allowing geologists to decipher the composition and history of rocks and minerals. Further advancements in microscopy techniques continue to refine our ability to analyze these subtle optical phenomena.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Anisotropy
The property of being directionally dependent; having different properties in different directions. In mineralogy, it refers to minerals whose optical properties vary with the direction of light propagation.
Birefringence
The difference between the maximum and minimum refractive indices in an anisotropic mineral. It is a measure of the mineral's ability to split light into two rays with different velocities.

Key Statistics

Approximately 60% of all known minerals are anisotropic (as of 2023).

Source: Mindat.org (knowledge cutoff 2023)

The birefringence of calcite is approximately 0.173, making it one of the most birefringent common minerals.

Source: Klein & Dutrow, Manual of Mineral Science (2007)

Examples

Calcite and Double Refraction

Calcite is a classic example of an anisotropic mineral. Its strong double refraction (birefringence) causes a double image when looking through it, demonstrating its anisotropic nature. This is commonly observed when looking at print through a piece of calcite.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between uniaxial and biaxial minerals?

Uniaxial minerals have one optic axis, while biaxial minerals have two. This difference affects their extinction patterns and interference figures under crossed polars. Uniaxial minerals typically exhibit four extinction positions during a 360° rotation, while biaxial minerals have more complex extinction patterns.

Topics Covered

GeologyMineralogyOptical MineralogyOptical PropertiesBirefringenceMineral Identification