UPSC MainsPOLITICAL-SCIENCE-INTERANATIONAL-RELATIONS-PAPER-II202210 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q15.

Peaceful co-existence remains the cornerstone of India's foreign policy. Comment.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of India’s foreign policy principles. The answer should demonstrate how ‘peaceful co-existence’ – Panchsheel – has historically shaped India’s interactions with other nations, particularly its neighbours. It should also acknowledge evolving geopolitical realities and how India balances this principle with its growing strategic interests. Structure the answer by defining peaceful co-existence, tracing its historical application in India’s foreign policy, highlighting contemporary challenges, and concluding with its continued relevance.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Peaceful co-existence, enshrined in the Panchsheel principles (1954), has long been a defining feature of India’s foreign policy. Rooted in the post-colonial context and the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), it emphasizes mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, non-aggression, non-interference, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful resolution of disputes. In recent years, with a rising China and increasing global instability, the application of this principle has been tested, yet it remains a cornerstone, guiding India’s approach to international relations, albeit with necessary adaptations to safeguard its national interests.

Historical Context and Application

The concept of peaceful co-existence gained prominence during the Bandung Conference (1955), where India, under Jawaharlal Nehru, played a pivotal role in advocating for a new international order based on cooperation and non-interference. This led to the formalization of the Panchsheel principles with China in 1954, initially aimed at resolving border disputes.

  • Early Years (1947-1962): India’s foreign policy was largely characterized by a commitment to NAM and peaceful resolution of conflicts. This was evident in its approach to disputes with Pakistan and China.
  • The 1962 Sino-Indian War: This event marked a turning point, exposing the limitations of relying solely on peaceful co-existence in the face of aggressive actions. However, it didn’t entirely abandon the principle.
  • Post-1962 Era: India continued to emphasize peaceful co-existence, but with a greater focus on strengthening its defense capabilities and forging strategic partnerships.

Contemporary Challenges and Adaptations

The 21st century presents new challenges to the principle of peaceful co-existence. China’s assertive foreign policy, including its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and border transgressions, has strained relations with India. Furthermore, the rise of terrorism and cross-border proxy wars pose threats to regional stability.

  • China Factor: Despite the border disputes and strategic competition, India continues to engage with China through diplomatic channels and economic cooperation, demonstrating a commitment to peaceful co-existence, albeit a cautious one.
  • Pakistan Factor: India’s approach to Pakistan remains complex, balancing the need for dialogue with concerns over terrorism. The principle of non-interference is often challenged by Pakistan-sponsored cross-border terrorism.
  • Strategic Autonomy: India’s growing strategic partnerships with countries like the US, Japan, and Australia (through the Quad) are often seen as a departure from NAM. However, India maintains that these partnerships are aimed at maintaining regional stability and are not directed against any particular country.
  • Maritime Security: In the Indo-Pacific region, India advocates for a rules-based order and freedom of navigation, which aligns with the principle of peaceful co-existence but also requires a strong naval presence.

India’s Balancing Act

India’s foreign policy today is characterized by a pragmatic balancing act between the ideals of peaceful co-existence and the realities of a complex geopolitical landscape. It is no longer a strict adherence to non-alignment but a flexible approach that prioritizes national interests while upholding international law and norms.

Principle Historical Application Contemporary Application
Non-Aggression Avoidance of military conflicts Maintaining a credible defense capability; focus on deterrence
Non-Interference Respect for sovereignty of other nations Cautious engagement in regional affairs; promoting stability
Mutual Respect Equal treatment of all nations Strategic partnerships based on mutual benefit

Conclusion

Peaceful co-existence remains a fundamental tenet of India’s foreign policy, though its application has evolved in response to changing global dynamics. While India recognizes the need to safeguard its national interests and engage in strategic partnerships, it continues to prioritize dialogue, diplomacy, and peaceful resolution of disputes. The principle serves as a guiding framework for navigating a multipolar world and promoting regional stability, even as India asserts its growing role on the international stage. A continued commitment to this principle, coupled with a pragmatic approach, will be crucial for India’s future foreign policy success.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Panchsheel
The Five Principles of Peaceful Co-existence: Mutual respect for each other’s territorial integrity and sovereignty, mutual non-aggression, non-interference in each other’s internal affairs, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful co-existence.
Non-Alignment Movement (NAM)
A group of states, typically those who did not formally align with or against any major power bloc during the Cold War. India was a founding member and a key proponent of NAM, emphasizing peaceful co-existence and independent foreign policy.

Key Statistics

India’s trade with China exceeded $135.98 billion in 2023, despite ongoing border disputes.

Source: Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India (as of knowledge cutoff - 2024)

India contributed approximately $5.98 billion to UN peacekeeping operations as of December 2023, demonstrating its commitment to international peace and security.

Source: United Nations (as of knowledge cutoff - 2024)

Examples

India-Nepal Treaty of 1950

Initially based on principles of peaceful co-existence, the treaty aimed to establish close relations between India and Nepal. However, it has faced criticism for perceived Indian influence in Nepal’s internal affairs, highlighting the challenges of implementing non-interference.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is India’s growing defense cooperation with the US a departure from peaceful co-existence?

Not necessarily. India views these partnerships as necessary for maintaining regional stability and deterring aggression, aligning with the broader goal of peaceful co-existence. It’s a pragmatic adaptation to the evolving security landscape.

Topics Covered

International RelationsIndian PolityForeign PolicyNon-AlignmentDiplomacy