UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-II202420 Marks
Q24.

How can morphology of Indian towns be described historically? Discuss the major features of the first planned city in India after independence.

How to Approach

This question requires a historical understanding of Indian town morphology and a detailed description of Chandigarh as the first planned city. The answer should begin by tracing the evolution of Indian towns through different periods – Indus Valley Civilization, ancient, medieval, and colonial – highlighting their characteristic features. Then, it should focus on Chandigarh, detailing its planning principles, architectural style, and socio-cultural impact. A comparative approach, contrasting Chandigarh with traditional Indian towns, would enhance the answer.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The morphology of Indian towns reflects a rich tapestry of historical influences, evolving over millennia. From the grid-patterned cities of the Indus Valley Civilization to the organically grown settlements of the medieval period and the superimposed structures of the colonial era, Indian towns showcase a unique blend of indigenous traditions and external impacts. Post-independence, India embarked on a path of planned urbanization, with Chandigarh, conceived by Le Corbusier, becoming the nation’s first planned city, symbolizing a modernist vision for urban development. This answer will explore the historical evolution of Indian town morphology and delve into the key features of Chandigarh.

Historical Morphology of Indian Towns

The morphology of Indian towns has undergone significant transformations throughout history, influenced by socio-political, economic, and technological factors.

Indus Valley Civilization (3300-1700 BCE)

  • Town Planning: Characterized by grid-patterned layouts, sophisticated drainage systems, and standardized brick sizes. Examples include Harappa and Mohenjo-daro.
  • Features: Fortified cities, residential areas, public baths, granaries, and a centralized administrative system.

Ancient Period (600 BCE – 600 CE)

  • Features: Towns emerged as centers of trade, religion, and administration. Often organically grown, with winding streets and a hierarchical spatial organization.
  • Examples: Pataliputra (modern Patna), Kaushambi, and Taxila. These towns often featured fortified walls, temples, and residential areas clustered around the central core.

Medieval Period (600 – 1800 CE)

  • Features: Towns developed around forts, religious shrines, and administrative centers. A distinct segregation of residential areas based on caste and occupation was common.
  • Examples: Delhi, Agra, Jaipur, and Ahmedabad. These cities often exhibited a walled city structure with a citadel (fort) at the center, surrounded by residential and commercial areas. The influence of Islamic architecture became prominent.

Colonial Period (1800 – 1947 CE)

  • Features: Colonial towns were often characterized by a dual structure – the ‘cantonment’ area for the British and the ‘native town’ for the Indian population. The introduction of new architectural styles (Victorian, Gothic) and infrastructure (railways, roads) significantly altered the urban landscape.
  • Examples: Calcutta (Kolkata), Bombay (Mumbai), Madras (Chennai). These cities witnessed the growth of port areas, commercial districts, and administrative centers, often segregated along racial lines.

Chandigarh: The First Planned City

Conceived after India’s independence, Chandigarh was envisioned as a model city embodying the principles of modern urban planning. Le Corbusier, the Swiss-French architect, was commissioned to design the city.

Planning Principles

  • The Three Million City Concept: Designed to accommodate a population of 3 million, with a focus on creating a self-sufficient and sustainable urban environment.
  • The Modulor System: Le Corbusier’s system of proportions based on the human body was used to determine the dimensions of buildings and spaces.
  • Sectoral Planning: The city is divided into 60 sectors, each self-contained with its own shopping, schools, and recreational facilities.
  • Hierarchy of Roads: A well-defined road network with ‘7Vs’ – the seven types of roads categorized by their traffic capacity.
  • Green Spaces: A significant portion of the city is dedicated to green spaces, parks, and forests, promoting a healthy and sustainable environment.

Architectural Features

  • Modernist Architecture: Characterized by the use of concrete, glass, and steel, with a focus on functionality and simplicity.
  • Monumental Buildings: Iconic structures like the Capitol Complex, Secretariat, and High Court showcase Le Corbusier’s architectural vision.
  • Open Plan Layouts: Buildings are designed with open plan layouts, maximizing space and natural light.

Socio-Cultural Impact

  • High Quality of Life: Chandigarh is consistently ranked among the cities with the highest quality of life in India, due to its well-planned infrastructure, green spaces, and low pollution levels.
  • Social Segregation: Despite its modernist ideals, Chandigarh has faced criticism for social segregation based on income and occupation.
  • Preservation of Heritage: Efforts are underway to preserve the architectural heritage of Chandigarh, recognizing its significance as a modernist masterpiece.

Comparison with Traditional Indian Towns: Unlike the organic growth of traditional Indian towns, Chandigarh was meticulously planned and designed. While traditional towns often lacked formal planning and infrastructure, Chandigarh prioritized functionality, efficiency, and aesthetics. However, Chandigarh also faced challenges in replicating the social vibrancy and cultural richness of traditional Indian settlements.

Conclusion

The historical morphology of Indian towns reveals a fascinating evolution shaped by diverse cultural and historical forces. From the planned cities of the Indus Valley to the organically grown settlements of the medieval period and the superimposed structures of the colonial era, Indian towns reflect a unique urban heritage. Chandigarh, as India’s first planned city, represents a modernist departure from traditional urban forms, offering a vision of a well-ordered and sustainable urban environment. While it has achieved significant success in terms of quality of life, it also highlights the challenges of balancing modernist ideals with the social and cultural complexities of the Indian context.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Morphology
In the context of geography and urban studies, morphology refers to the physical form and structure of a city or town, including its layout, building types, and spatial organization.
Cantonment
A cantonment is a military garrison town, often established by colonial powers to house troops and maintain control over a region. These towns typically featured a distinct separation between the military area and the civilian population.

Key Statistics

As of 2023, Chandigarh has a population of approximately 1.1 million (Census 2011 + projected growth).

Source: Chandigarh Administration Website

India’s urban population is projected to reach 600 million by 2036, accounting for approximately 40% of the total population.

Source: United Nations World Urbanization Prospects (2018 Revision)

Examples

Jaipur - The Pink City

Jaipur, founded in 1727 by Maharaja Sawai Jai Singh II, is a prime example of planned medieval Indian city. It was planned based on Vastu Shastra and Shilpa Shastra, featuring a grid-pattern layout with nine rectangular sectors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main criticisms leveled against Chandigarh’s planning?

Criticisms included its perceived lack of cultural context, social segregation, and the high cost of maintenance. Some also argued that its modernist design failed to capture the vibrancy and diversity of traditional Indian cities.

Topics Covered

GeographyHistoryUrban GeographyHistorical GeographyUrban Planning