UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-II202515 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q8.

2. (c) What were the thrust areas of economic planning during the pre-liberalisation era? Discuss.

How to Approach

The answer should begin by defining the pre-liberalisation era and the overarching philosophy of planning. The body will delve into specific thrust areas, such as heavy industrialization, self-reliance (including food self-sufficiency), public sector dominance, poverty alleviation, and social justice, linking them to specific Five-Year Plans or policies. It is crucial to highlight the mixed economy model and regulatory mechanisms like the 'License Raj'. Conclude with a summary of the era's impact and its eventual limitations leading to the 1991 reforms.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

India, after gaining independence in 1947, adopted a path of planned economic development, largely influenced by socialist ideas and the Soviet model of Five-Year Plans. The pre-liberalisation era, spanning from 1950 to 1991, was characterized by a state-led, inward-looking economic strategy aimed at overcoming the challenges of widespread poverty, low per capita income, and an underdeveloped industrial base inherited from colonial rule. This period was marked by strong centralized planning under the Planning Commission, with specific thrust areas designed to achieve rapid economic growth, self-reliance, and social equity, laying the foundation for modern India's economy.

Thrust Areas of Economic Planning during the Pre-Liberalisation Era (1950-1991)

The economic planning in India during the pre-liberalisation period was guided by several core objectives, primarily implemented through a series of Five-Year Plans. These thrust areas reflected the nation's aspirations for economic sovereignty, social justice, and industrial growth.

1. Heavy Industrialization and Public Sector Dominance

  • Mahalanobis Model: The Second Five-Year Plan (1956-1961), based on the P.C. Mahalanobis model, laid a strong emphasis on rapid industrialization, particularly focusing on basic and heavy industries like steel, machinery, and capital goods. The rationale was that robust heavy industries would create a strong industrial base, essential for long-term self-sustained growth.
  • "Commanding Heights" of the Economy: The public sector was envisioned to occupy the "commanding heights" of the economy, driving growth and ensuring equitable distribution. Significant investments were made in State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) across various sectors including steel (e.g., Bhilai, Durgapur, Rourkela), energy, and infrastructure.
  • Industrial Policy Resolutions: The Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956 classified industries into three schedules, with the state having exclusive responsibility for Schedule A industries, reflecting its dominant role.

2. Self-Reliance (Import Substitution Industrialization)

  • Reduction of Foreign Dependence: A crucial objective was to reduce India's dependence on foreign goods and capital, both to conserve foreign exchange and to safeguard national sovereignty.
  • Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI): This strategy involved promoting domestic production of goods that were previously imported. It was supported by high tariffs, import quotas, and stringent licensing requirements (often termed the "License Raj") to protect nascent domestic industries from international competition.
  • Food Self-Sufficiency: Achieving self-sufficiency in food grains was a paramount goal, especially after periods of food shortages. The Green Revolution, starting in the mid-1960s, transformed Indian agriculture through the introduction of High-Yielding Variety (HYV) seeds, better irrigation, and chemical fertilizers, eventually making India self-sufficient in food grains.

3. Poverty Alleviation and Social Justice

  • Inclusive Growth: From the very beginning, economic planning aimed at reducing income inequalities and ensuring social justice. Measures included progressive taxation, land reforms (though with mixed success), and specific programs for rural development.
  • "Garibi Hatao": The Fifth Five-Year Plan (1974-1979) notably emphasized poverty alleviation with the slogan "Garibi Hatao" (Abolish Poverty), leading to the introduction of various anti-poverty programs.
  • Employment Generation: Efforts were made to utilize the available human resources by increasing employment levels, particularly in rural areas and through the expansion of cottage and small-scale industries.

4. Economic Growth and Stability

  • Increasing National Income: A primary goal was to achieve a high growth rate to improve the living standards of the population and increase national and per capita income.
  • Price Stability: Economic planning aimed at maintaining stable market conditions and preventing sharp fluctuations in prices, which could undermine economic progress and disproportionately affect the poor.

5. Modernization of the Economy

  • Technological Advancement: Modernization involved adopting new technologies in agriculture and industry to improve productivity and efficiency. This also included developing indigenous technological capabilities.
  • Diversification: The plans sought to diversify the economic structure, moving away from an overwhelmingly agrarian economy towards a mixed industrial base.

6. Mixed Economy Model

  • India adopted a mixed economy model where both the public and private sectors co-existed. However, the state played a dominant and regulatory role, guiding investments and resource allocation according to national priorities. The private sector operated within a framework of licenses and regulations.

The table below summarizes the key thrust areas and their associated policies/plans:

Thrust Area Key Policy/Plan/Period Description
Heavy Industrialization Second Five-Year Plan (Mahalanobis Model), Industrial Policy Resolution 1956 Focus on capital goods, steel, and basic industries; public sector dominance.
Self-Reliance Import Substitution Industrialization, Green Revolution (mid-1960s) Reducing dependence on imports; achieving food self-sufficiency.
Poverty Alleviation & Social Justice "Garibi Hatao" (Fifth Five-Year Plan), Land Reforms, various rural development programs Reducing inequality, providing employment, welfare schemes.
Economic Growth All Five-Year Plans Increasing national and per capita income; improving living standards.
Modernization Technological advancements in agriculture and industry Adoption of new technologies, diversification of economic structure.
Mixed Economy Overall planning framework (1950-1991) Co-existence of public and private sectors with dominant state control.

While these thrust areas led to significant achievements, such as a diversified industrial base and food self-sufficiency, they also led to inefficiencies, slow growth, and a balance of payments crisis by the late 1980s, which ultimately necessitated the economic reforms of 1991.

Conclusion

The pre-liberalisation era in India was defined by a meticulously planned economic strategy centered on achieving rapid industrialization, self-reliance, and social equity under a mixed economic framework. Key thrust areas included nurturing heavy industries, promoting import substitution, ensuring food security through the Green Revolution, and implementing various poverty alleviation programs. While this foundational period succeeded in building a robust industrial base and reducing dependence on foreign aid, the extensive state control and protectionist policies also led to bureaucratic hurdles, inefficiencies, and limited global integration, setting the stage for the transformative economic reforms initiated in 1991.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Economic Planning
A systematic process by which a central authority (like a government) makes or influences key economic decisions regarding the allocation of resources and setting of production targets to achieve specific socio-economic goals, often over a predetermined period (e.g., Five-Year Plans).
Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)
An economic policy strategy where a country attempts to reduce its foreign dependence by domestically producing goods that it would otherwise import. This typically involves protectionist measures like tariffs and quotas to shield infant industries.

Key Statistics

During the pre-liberalisation period, India's average annual GDP growth rate was often referred to as the "Hindu rate of growth," hovering around 3.5% between 1950 and 1980, significantly lower than East Asian economies.

Source: Various economic analyses of Indian economy (e.g., Economic Survey)

Poverty ratio in India declined from approximately 54% in 1973-74 to around 36% by 1993-94, indicating some impact of poverty alleviation programs during the latter part of the pre-liberalisation era.

Source: Planning Commission, India

Examples

Establishment of Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs)

Key PSUs like Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL), Heavy Engineering Corporation (HEC), and Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL) were established and significantly expanded during this era to drive industrialization and achieve self-reliance in critical sectors.

Nationalization of Banks

In 1969, the Indira Gandhi government nationalized 14 major Indian banks, followed by six more in 1980. This move aimed to ensure that credit flowed to priority sectors like agriculture and small-scale industries, aligning with social justice and equitable development goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the "License Raj" during the pre-liberalisation era?

The "License Raj" refers to the elaborate system of licenses, regulations, and quotas that businesses in India needed to obtain from the government to start, operate, or expand. It was a tool for state control over the economy, aimed at directing investments and preventing concentration of wealth, but often led to inefficiency, corruption, and stunted growth.

When did India shift away from the pre-liberalisation economic model?

India initiated a major shift from its pre-liberalisation economic model with the comprehensive economic reforms introduced in 1991. These reforms, prompted by a severe balance of payments crisis, liberalized the economy, reduced state control, and opened it up to greater private and foreign investment (LPG reforms - Liberalisation, Privatisation, Globalisation).

Topics Covered

EconomyIndian HistoryEconomic PlanningLiberalisationFive Year PlansEconomic Policy