UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I202515 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q6.

Substantiate your understanding of Tom Jones as a bildungsroman and a picaresque novel.

How to Approach

The answer will first define both 'bildungsroman' and 'picaresque novel'. Then, it will systematically analyze Henry Fielding's *The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling*, substantiating how the novel embodies the key characteristics of each genre. It will provide specific examples from the plot and character development to support the arguments, culminating in a balanced conclusion that synthesizes its dual nature.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Henry Fielding's *The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling*, published in 1749, stands as a seminal work in English literature, often cited as one of the earliest and most influential English novels. Beyond its comic brilliance and intricate plot, *Tom Jones* is critically understood as a fascinating blend of two distinct literary genres: the bildungsroman and the picaresque novel. This dual classification is central to appreciating the novel's complex portrayal of human nature, societal critique, and the protagonist's eventful journey. Understanding these classifications provides a framework for analyzing Tom Jones's moral and psychological development amidst his rollicking adventures and encounters with a diverse cast of characters in 18th-century England.

Understanding the Genres: Bildungsroman and Picaresque Novel

To fully appreciate *Tom Jones*, it is essential to first delineate the characteristics of the bildungsroman and the picaresque novel.

  • Bildungsroman: Derived from German, meaning "novel of education" or "novel of formation" (Merriam-Webster, 2025). This genre focuses on the psychological and moral growth of the protagonist from youth to adulthood. Key elements include an initial emotional loss or crisis, a journey of self-discovery, conflict with societal values, and ultimately, the protagonist's integration into society with a newfound understanding of self and the world.
  • Picaresque Novel: Originating in 16th-century Spain, this genre features a "pícaro" – a rogue or lowborn adventurer – as the protagonist. The narrative is typically episodic, often in the first person, relating the picaro's adventures as he drifts through various social milieus, living by his wits. Picaresque novels often employ satire to expose societal corruption and hypocrisy, with the protagonist often remaining a fixed character, learning survival techniques rather than undergoing profound internal change (Britannica, 2025).

Tom Jones as a Bildungsroman

Fielding’s *Tom Jones* vividly illustrates the core tenets of a bildungsroman through the journey of its titular character. Tom's development is central to the narrative, showcasing his moral and psychological evolution.

1. Formative Years and Moral Education

Tom Jones begins as a foundling, an innocent but impulsive youth with a good heart but prone to rash decisions. Raised in the benevolent but often naive household of Squire Allworthy, he lacks proper guidance in navigating the complexities of virtue and vice. His early education by the hypocritical tutors Thwackum and Square further highlights his natural goodness against their feigned morality.

  • Initial Innocence and Impulsivity: Tom’s natural generosity, demonstrated in his willingness to help Black George’s family, often leads him into trouble due to a lack of prudence.
  • Confrontation with Societal Values: As an illegitimate child, Tom is perpetually judged by his social standing rather than his inherent character, forcing him to grapple with a society obsessed with appearances and status (Literature Xpres, "Tom Jones Themes").

2. Journey of Self-Discovery and Experience

Expelled from Allworthy's estate, Tom embarks on a journey that forces him to confront the harsh realities of the world. His travels expose him to a wide spectrum of human experience, from the genuine kindness of some strangers to the profound hypocrisy and villainy of others.

  • Trials and Misfortunes: His adventures in the countryside and London are marked by numerous misunderstandings, deceptions, and personal failings, particularly in his romantic entanglements. These experiences, though often painful, serve as crucial lessons.
  • Growing Prudence and Discernment: Initially, Tom is easily misled and trusts too readily. Over the course of the novel, particularly through his relationship with Sophia Western and the machinations of Blifil and other antagonists, he gradually develops a greater sense of prudence and learns to distinguish true virtue from mere outward show. His repeated mistakes, as eNotes.com highlights, stem from a lack of prudence, but his inherent goodness eventually guides him towards better judgment (eNotes.com, "Tom Jones Themes").

3. Integration and Maturity

The resolution of the novel sees Tom not only discovering his true parentage (revealed to be Allworthy's nephew) but also achieving a moral maturity. He earns Sophia's hand, demonstrating a deeper understanding of love, loyalty, and responsibility. His final acceptance into society is a testament to his learned virtue, where his good heart is complemented by newfound wisdom.

  • Moral Awakening: Tom's journey culminates in an understanding that true virtue lies in benevolent actions and sincere intentions, rather than rigid adherence to social conventions or outward piety.
  • Harmonious Resolution: The novel concludes with Tom's reintegration into a more just social order, reflecting the typical positive resolution of a bildungsroman where the protagonist finds peace and belonging.

Tom Jones as a Picaresque Novel

While Tom undergoes significant internal growth, the episodic structure, the nature of his adventures, and his role as a lowborn wanderer firmly place *Tom Jones* within the picaresque tradition.

1. The Pícaro Protagonist and Episodic Structure

Tom Jones, despite his inherent goodness, fits the mold of a "pícaro" or rogue adventurer in many respects. He is of uncertain parentage, an outsider navigating a world that often treats him with suspicion due to his perceived low birth.

  • Rogue Hero Characteristics: Tom lives by his wits, often charming his way through difficult situations, and sometimes engages in minor transgressions (like poaching) to survive or help others. His journey is a series of loosely connected adventures rather than a tightly plotted, linear progression, characteristic of the picaresque genre (Britannica, "Picaresque Novel", Study.com, "Picaresque Novels Definition").
  • Wandering and Social Mobility: His expulsion from Allworthy's estate forces him into a nomadic existence, traveling across the English countryside and into London. This exposes him to various social strata – from rural squires and innkeepers to urban gentlemen and ladies – mirroring the picaro's journey through diverse social milieus.

2. Satire and Social Commentary

Fielding uses Tom's adventures as a vehicle for sharp social satire, a hallmark of the picaresque novel. Through Tom's encounters, he exposes the hypocrisy, corruption, and moral failings prevalent in 18th-century English society.

  • Critique of Hypocrisy: Characters like Blifil, Thwackum, and Square, who outwardly profess virtue but secretly act with malice and self-interest, are direct targets of Fielding's satirical pen. Tom, with his honest flaws, often serves as a foil to these hypocritical figures.
  • Exposure of Social Injustice: The novel satirizes the legal system, class prejudices, and the shallow morality of the upper classes. Tom's unjust banishment and subsequent struggles highlight the arbitrary nature of social judgment and the prevalence of vice among the ostensibly virtuous (Literature Xpres, "Tom Jones Themes").

3. Narratorial Presence and Realism

The highly visible, omniscient narrator in *Tom Jones* is a distinctive feature, often directly addressing the reader and offering commentary on human nature and societal norms. This narrative technique, while not exclusive to picaresque, often complements its satirical aims and episodic nature.

  • Direct Address and Didacticism: The narrator explicitly states the novel's purpose to explore "human nature" and offers moral guidance, reflecting Fielding's didactic intentions (UPSC English Literature Optional, "Tom Jones by Henry Fielding").
  • Realistic Portrayal: The novel's vivid descriptions of everyday life, diverse characters, and detailed settings contribute to its realism, a quality often found in picaresque narratives seeking to depict the world as it is, rather than an idealized version.

In conclusion, *Tom Jones* masterfully combines these two literary forms. While Tom's character arc, leading to moral wisdom and integration, aligns it with the bildungsroman, his adventures as a wandering, lowborn hero amidst a corrupt society, and the novel's extensive use of satire, firmly establish its picaresque credentials. This unique fusion allows Fielding to present a comprehensive and entertaining critique of 18th-century society while simultaneously exploring the timeless themes of growth, virtue, and human nature.

Conclusion

Henry Fielding's *The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling* is a remarkable literary achievement precisely because of its successful integration of the bildungsroman and picaresque traditions. It charts the moral and psychological development of its protagonist, Tom, from an impulsive youth to a mature individual capable of prudence and genuine virtue, fulfilling the core requirements of a bildungsroman. Concurrently, Tom's episodic adventures as a lowborn hero navigating a corrupt society, coupled with Fielding's pervasive social satire and realistic portrayal of 18th-century England, firmly place the novel within the picaresque genre. This dual nature allows the novel to offer both a compelling tale of personal growth and a biting critique of societal hypocrisy, securing its place as a cornerstone of the English novel tradition.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Bildungsroman
A literary genre that chronicles the psychological and moral growth of the protagonist from childhood to adulthood, often involving a journey, conflict with societal values, and eventual self-realization and integration into society.
Picaresque Novel
An early form of novel, typically a first-person narrative, that recounts the episodic adventures of a "pícaro" (rogue or lowborn adventurer) as he moves from place to place, often satirizing societal norms and hypocrisy through his encounters.

Examples

Tom's Moral Education

Tom's early experiences with his tutors, Thwackum (representing rigid, often hypocritical, religious dogma) and Square (representing abstract, equally hypocritical, philosophical virtue), highlight his innate goodness against their superficial morality. Their teachings fail to truly guide him, rather his actual experiences in the world shape his moral compass.

Satire of Social Class

The novel consistently satirizes the 18th-century obsession with social standing and birthright. Despite his good heart and noble actions, Tom is frequently scorned and disinherited due to his status as a foundling, while his half-brother Blifil, though malicious and scheming, is initially favored due to his legitimate birth and outward piety.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is *Tom Jones* considered a purely comic novel?

While *Tom Jones* is indeed a comic novel, celebrated for its wit and humorous situations, it also delves into serious themes of morality, social justice, and human nature. Its comic elements often serve to highlight the absurdities and hypocrisies of 18th-century society.

How does the narrator's role enhance the novel's themes?

The highly visible, omniscient narrator in *Tom Jones* directly addresses the reader, offers philosophical commentary, and often foreshadows events. This intrusive narration allows Fielding to explicitly guide the reader's moral judgments, inject satirical observations, and reflect on the art of storytelling itself, enriching both the bildungsroman's didactic purpose and the picaresque's social critique.

Topics Covered

English LiteratureProseNovelTom JonesHenry FieldingBildungsromanPicaresque NovelLiterary Genres