Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
The principle of securing justice on the basis of equal opportunity is a cornerstone of India's constitutional ethos, aiming to ensure that socio-economic or other disabilities do not impede access to legal remedies. The Preamble itself enshrines justice – social, economic, and political – as a guiding ideal. This commitment is further elaborated in the Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy. The Constitution mandates the State to create a framework where the legal system serves as a tool for empowerment and equality, rather than a barrier. The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, represents a significant legislative effort to translate this constitutional mandate into tangible reality by providing legal aid and establishing mechanisms like Lok Adalats.
The question requires an examination of how the Indian State, through its Constitution and specific legislation like the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, strives to ensure that the legal system operates to promote justice based on equal opportunity.
I. Constitutional Mandate for Justice and Equal Opportunity
The Indian Constitution lays a strong foundation for ensuring justice on the basis of equal opportunity:
- Preamble: It declares India to be a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic Republic committed to securing Justice (social, economic, political), Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity. This sets the overarching goal.
- Article 14 (Equality Before Law): Guarantees that the State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India. This implies equal access to the legal system regardless of status.
- Article 21 (Protection of Life and Personal Liberty): Includes the right to a fair procedure and access to justice as integral components of the right to life and liberty. The Supreme Court has consistently interpreted this to include the right to legal aid.
- Article 39A (Equal opportunity for justice): This is the most direct constitutional provision. It mandates that the State shall secure that the operation of the legal system promotes justice, on a basis of equal opportunity, and shall, in particular, provide free legal aid, by suitable legislation or schemes or in any other way, to ensure that opportunities for securing justice are not denied to any citizen by reason of economic or other disabilities.
- Article 142 (Enforcement of Decrees and Orders): Empowers the Supreme Court to pass any order necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, indirectly supporting the goal of substantive justice.
II. The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987: Operationalizing Justice
Enacted to give effect to Article 39A, the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, provides a statutory framework for delivering free and competent legal services to the weaker sections of society.
A. Key Objectives and Structure:
- Objective: To provide free and competent legal services to the weaker sections of society to ensure that opportunities for securing justice are not denied due to economic or other disabilities.
- Structure: Establishes a multi-tiered system:
- National Legal Services Authority (NALSA): Apex body, headed by the Chief Justice of India (as Patron-in-Chief), responsible for policy formulation, monitoring, and coordination.
- State Legal Services Authorities (SLSA): Headed by respective State Chief Justices, responsible for implementing legal aid schemes within the state.
- District Legal Services Authorities (DLSA): Headed by District Judges, responsible for implementation at the district level.
- Taluk Legal Services Committees: Function at the taluk/sub-district level.
B. Provisions Promoting Equal Opportunity in Justice:
- Free Legal Services: Specifies categories of persons eligible for free legal aid, including members of Scheduled Castes/Tribes, women, children, victims of human trafficking, industrial workmen, persons in custody, individuals with annual income below a prescribed limit (determined by State Governments), and victims of mass disasters, natural calamities, or genocide.
- Types of Services: Legal services include:
- Representation in legal proceedings.
- Provision of legal advice and assistance.
- Preparation of documents, etc.
- Participation in Lok Adalats.
- Lok Adalats: The Act provides a statutory basis for organising Lok Adalats (People's Courts). These aim to resolve disputes amicably through compromise and settlement, offering a faster, cheaper, and less formal alternative to traditional courts. This promotes access to justice for those deterred by the procedural complexities and costs of regular litigation.
- Promoting Legal Awareness: NALSA and its subordinate bodies are mandated to undertake activities for legal literacy and awareness among the weaker sections.
III. Examining the Significance: Bridging the Gap
The Constitution provides the 'why', while the LSA Act provides the 'how'. Together, they signify the State's commitment to:
- Democratizing Justice: Moving beyond mere procedural fairness to ensure substantive justice, especially for marginalized groups.
- Leveling the Playing Field: Providing legal representation and support aims to balance the power dynamic between the affluent/well-represented and the poor/unrepresented litigant.
- Reducing Barriers: Addressing economic barriers (through free aid) and potentially procedural barriers (through Lok Adalats and legal advice).
- Upholding Rule of Law: Ensuring that the legal system is accessible and serves all citizens, reinforcing faith in the rule of law and constitutional governance.
However, the effectiveness faces challenges:
- Awareness Gap: Many eligible individuals remain unaware of their right to legal aid.
- Quality Concerns: Ensuring the quality and competence of legal aid counsel remains a persistent issue.
- Infrastructure & Funding: Adequate resources and infrastructure for legal services authorities are crucial but often lacking.
- Pendency: Despite Lok Adalats, the overall judicial backlog remains a significant obstacle.
Comparative Overview: Constitutional Ideals vs. Statutory Implementation
| Constitutional Provision | Statutory Mechanism (LSA Act, 1987) | Contribution to Equal Opportunity in Justice |
|---|---|---|
| Article 39A: Mandate for free legal aid and promoting justice on equal opportunity basis. | Establishes NALSA, SLSAs, DLSAs to deliver legal aid. Defines eligible persons and types of services. | Provides concrete structure and mandate to fulfill constitutional directive. Identifies beneficiaries and services. |
| Article 14: Equality before law. | Provides legal representation to the disadvantaged, aiming to equalize procedural standing. | Attempts to level the playing field in adversarial proceedings. |
| Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty (incl. access to justice). | Offers legal advice, representation, and alternative dispute resolution (Lok Adalats). | Ensures access to justice is not denied due to economic or other disabilities, fulfilling procedural fairness. |
| Preamble: Justice (Social, Economic, Political). | Lok Adalats offer swift, inexpensive justice; legal aid addresses economic barriers. | Promotes substantive social and economic justice by making the legal system accessible. |
Conclusion
The Indian Constitution, particularly Article 39A, strongly emphasizes the State's duty to ensure justice on the basis of equal opportunity. The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, is a vital legislative instrument that translates this constitutional vision into a functional reality by establishing a comprehensive network for legal aid and promoting alternative dispute resolution mechanisms like Lok Adalats. While these provisions represent a significant step towards making justice accessible to all, bridging the gap between the mandate and its effective implementation requires continuous efforts in enhancing legal awareness, ensuring quality of service, adequate funding, and addressing the persistent issue of judicial pendency. The goal remains to ensure that the legal system truly operates as an equalizing force for all citizens.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.