UPSC Prelims 2011·CSAT·Decision Making·Administrative Scenarios

Each item describes a situation and is followed by four possible responses. Indicate the response you find most appropriate. Choose only one response for each item. The responses will be evaluated based on the level of appropriateness for the given situation You are the officer-in-charge of a village administering distribution of (+2.5) vaccine in an isolated epidemic hit village, and you are left with only one vaccine. There is a requirement of that vaccine from the Gram Pradhan and also a poor villager. You are being pressurised by the Gram Pradhan to issue the vaccine to him. You would

Dalvoy logo
Reviewed by Dalvoy
UPSC Civil Services preparation
Last updated 23 May 2026, 3:31 pm IST
  1. Ainitiate the procedure to expedite the next supply without issuing the vaccine to either
  2. Barrange vaccine for the poor villager from the distributor of another area
  3. Cask both to approach a doctor and get an input about the urgencyCorrect
  4. Darrange vaccine for the Gram Pradhan from the distributor of another area.

Explanation

The correct answer is C because it prioritizes an objective, medical assessment of urgency over social status or pressure. Analysis of options: A) initiate the procedure to expedite the next supply without issuing the vaccine to either: This is inappropriate as it delays immediate action in an epidemic. The one available vaccine would go unused while people suffer, which is irresponsible. B) arrange vaccine for the poor villager from the distributor of another area: While well-intentioned to help the poor, this option still doesn't address the immediate dilemma of the one vaccine you possess. It also implies making a decision based on social status rather than medical urgency, and sourcing from another area might not be immediate or feasible. C) ask both to approach a doctor and get an input about the urgency: This is the most appropriate response. In an epidemic with limited resources, the distribution should be based on medical necessity and urgency, not social standing or pressure. Consulting a doctor ensures an objective, expert opinion on who needs the vaccine more critically, thereby making an ethical and responsible administrative decision. D) arrange vaccine for the Gram Pradhan from the distributor of another area: This is inappropriate. It succumbs to pressure and prioritizes the Gram Pradhan's status over medical need, without even using the available vaccine. It's unethical and administratively unsound.
Decision Making: Each item describes a situation and is followed by four possible responses. Indicate the response you find most appropri

Related questions

More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.